Investigating mobility-based fast food outlet visits as indicators of dietary intake and diet-related disease

Abigail L. Horn, Brooke M. Bell, Bernardo García Bulle Bueno, Mohsen Bahrami, Burçin Bozkaya, Yan Cui, John P. Wilson, Alex Pentland, Esteban Moro, Kayla de la HayemedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Excessive consumption of fast food (FF) is a primary driver of chronic disease, yet population-level dietary intake is notoriously difficult to measure. Traditional research relies on static home-based environment mapping or self-reported surveys, both of which are prone to significant bias. This study investigates whether mobility data from smartphones can serve as a more accurate indicator of FF intake, obesity, and diabetes. By analyzing 14.5 million food outlet visits from 243,644 anonymous smartphone users in Los Angeles County (LAC) and comparing them with the 2011 Los Angeles County Health Survey (LACHS), we demonstrate that mobility-based metrics are not only significantly associated with self-reported intake but are also superior predictors of obesity and diabetes compared to traditional self-reports.

Introduction

Fast food accounts for approximately 16% of the total caloric intake in the United States. Despite its impact on public health, measuring actual consumption at scale remains a challenge. Current methodologies often suffer from two major limitations:

  1. Static Environmental Assumptions: Researchers often assume individuals only eat near their homes, ignoring the "activity space" of commutes and workplaces.
  2. Recall Bias: Self-reported dietary data is frequently inaccurate due to under-reporting and memory errors.

This research explores the utility of "big data"—specifically passive smartphone geolocation pings—to bridge these gaps by providing a dynamic, objective measure of food environment exposure and behavioral patterns.

Methodology

To transform raw GPS data into health indicators, the researchers developed a multi-stage processing pipeline:

Data Sources

  • Cuebiq Mobility Data (2016-2017): Anonymized GPS data from over 243,000 users in LAC.
  • Foursquare API: Used to categorize over 53,000 food outlets, including 4,151 specific fast-food locations.
  • LACHS (2011): A representative survey of 8,036 LAC residents providing ground-truth data on self-reported FF intake, obesity, and diabetes.

Feature Engineering

The study identified "stays" of at least five minutes, filtering out transient pings like traffic stops. Two primary metrics were calculated and aggregated at the census tract level (scaled 0–10):

  • FF visits/time: The frequency of daily time periods (morning, midday, evening) where a user visited at least one FF outlet.
  • FF visits/food: The ratio of FF visits relative to all food-related visits (e.g., grocery stores, full-service restaurants).

Statistical Analysis

Multinomial and binary logistic regressions were used to associate mobility features with health outcomes. Model performance was evaluated using Akaike weights (derived from the Akaike Information Criterion) to determine which indicators best fit the observed prevalence of obesity and diabetes.

Key Results

Association with Self-Reported Intake

Mobility-based metrics showed a strong, significant correlation with how residents described their own eating habits. For every 10% increase in the FF visits/time metric, the odds of a resident reporting "frequent" fast food intake increased by 35% (OR, 1.35; 95% CI, 1.28-1.42).

Predicting Chronic Disease

Mobility data proved to be a robust indicator of diet-related disease. A 10% increase in FF visits/time was associated with:

  • 16% greater odds of obesity (AOR, 1.16; 95% CI, 1.12-1.21).
  • 15% greater odds of diabetes (AOR, 1.15; 95% CI, 1.09-1.21).

Superiority Over Self-Reporting

Crucially, models utilizing mobility data outperformed those using self-reported intake when predicting health outcomes. For obesity, the probability that the mobility-based model was the "best fit" was 0.90, compared to a near-zero probability ($3.6 \times 10^{-7}$) for the self-report model. Similar results were observed for diabetes, suggesting that passive mobility data captures a "cleaner" signal of health-harming behaviors than human memory.

Discussion

The "Social Signal" of Mobility

Aggregated mobility data may capture the "social signal" of a neighborhood—the collective behavioral norms and environmental pressures that influence individual health. Unlike static maps, this approach accounts for the "dynamic" food environment, capturing consumption that occurs during commutes or near workplaces.

Overcoming Measurement Error

By relying on passive data collection, this method avoids the inherent biases of dietary surveys. While individual privacy is maintained through neighborhood-level aggregation, the data remains granular enough to provide actionable insights for public health surveillance.

Limitations

  • Temporal Gap: The mobility data (2016-17) and health survey (2011) were collected several years apart. However, sensitivity analyses suggest the underlying associations remain robust.
  • Ecological Fallacy: Neighborhood-level averages may not perfectly represent every individual within that tract.
  • Demographic Bias: Smartphone users often skew younger and higher-income, though post-stratification weighting was used to mitigate this effect.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that population-scale mobility data provides a powerful, passive indicator of fast food intake and diet-related disease. These metrics offer a scalable complement to traditional dietary surveillance, allowing researchers and policymakers to better understand how movement through the urban environment shapes public health outcomes. Future work may utilize these methods to redefine "food deserts" based on actual travel patterns rather than simple proximity to home.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Importance Excessive consumption of fast food (FF) is associated with chronic disease. Population-level research on FF outlet visits is now possible with mobility data, however its usefulness as an indicator of FF intake and diet-related disease must be established. Objective Investigate whether FF outlet visits from mobility data are indicators of self-reported FF intake, obesity, and diabetes, and compared with self-reported intake, equivalent or better indicators of obesity and diabetes. Design, Setting, and Participants A secondary analysis of data from a representative sample of 8,036 adult residents of Los Angeles County (LAC) from the 2011 Los Angeles County Health Survey (LACHS), and mobility data representing all geolocations between October 2016 - March 2017 of 243,644 anonymous and opted-in smartphone users in LAC. Main Outcomes and Measures Main outcomes were self-reported FF intake frequency (never, infrequent, moderate, frequent), obesity, and diabetes from LACHS. FF outlet visits were computed as the temporal frequency of FF visits (FF visits/time) and the ratio of visits to FF over all food outlets (FF visits/food), summarized over smartphone users in a neighborhood, scaled from 0-10, and linked to LACHS respondents by census tract. Results The analytic sample included 5,447 LACHS respondents and 234,995 smartphone users with 14,498,850 visits to food outlets. FF outlet visits were significantly associated with self-reported FF intake (reference: never) for both FF visits/time (infrequent: odds ratio [OR], 1.13; 95% CI, 1.06-1.20; frequent: OR, 1.35; 95% CI, 1.28-1.42) and FF visits/food (infrequent: OR, 1.12; 95% CI, 1.06-1.17; frequent: OR, 1.28; 95% CI, 1.22-1.33). FF outlet visits were significantly associated with obesity (FF visits/time: adjusted OR [AOR], 1.16; 95% CI, 1.12-1.21; FF visits/food: AOR, 1.13; 95% CI, 1.10-1.17) and diabetes (FF visits/time: AOR, 1.15; 95% CI, 1.09-1.21; FF visits/food: AOR, 1.11; 95% CI, 1.07-1.16), adjusted for sociodemographic factors. Models of the association between FF outlet visits and obesity or diabetes had better fits than between self-reported FF intake and obesity or diabetes. Conclusions and relevance This study illustrates that population-scale mobility data provide useful, passively-collected indicators of FF intake and diet-related disease within large, diverse urban populations that may be better than self-report intake. Key Points Question Do visits to fast food outlets observed in mobility data provide meaningful measures of fast food intake, and when compared with self-reported intake, equivalent or better indicators of diet-related disease? Findings In this cross-sectional Los Angeles County study from a survey of 8,036 adults and mobility data from 243,644 smartphone users with 14.5 million food outlet visits, neighborhood-level features representing visits to fast food outlets were significantly associated with self-reported fast food intake, significantly associated with obesity and diabetes, and were a better predictor of these diseases than self-reported fast food intake. Meaning Measures of food behaviors observed in population-scale mobility data can provide meaningful indicators of food intake and diet-related diseases, and could complement existing dietary surveillance methods.
BibTeX
@misc{horn2021investigating,
  author = {Abigail L. Horn and Brooke M. Bell and Bernardo García Bulle Bueno and Mohsen Bahrami and Burçin Bozkaya and Yan Cui and John P. Wilson and Alex Pentland and Esteban Moro and Kayla de la Haye},
  title = {{Investigating mobility-based fast food outlet visits as indicators of dietary intake and diet-related disease}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.28.21265634},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure