Investigating microscale patchiness of motile microbes under turbulence in a simulated convective mixed layer

Alexander Kier Christensen, Matthew D. Piggott, Erik van Sebille, Maarten van Reeuwijk, Samraat PawarPLOS Computational Biology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the movement of tiny microbes, called microbes, creates clumpy distributions (patchiness) in turbulent water. By combining a detailed fluid dynamics simulation with a model of microbe behavior, they found that this patchiness is not universal but depends heavily on microbe agility and depth, being most pronounced in calmer, deeper waters. This work is crucial for understanding microbial ecosystems and nutrient cycling in aquatic environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microbes are fundamental to aquatic ecosystems, driving key processes like nutrient cycling and primary productivity. Their spatial distribution, or "patchiness," significantly impacts these functions. While large-scale patchiness is well-documented, understanding how microbes form clumps at very small scales (microscale), especially in the presence of turbulence, has been a long-standing challenge. Traditional assumptions suggested turbulence would homogenize microbial distributions. However, recent research indicates that turbulence can, under specific conditions, actually drive patchiness. This paper aims to test the hypothesis that the interaction between a microbe's active swimming (gyrotaxis) and turbulent fluid motion can lead to intense microscale patchiness, and to explore how this phenomenon varies with depth in a realistic turbulent environment.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated approach combining two key computational techniques:

  • Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) of Convective Mixed Layer Turbulence: They simulated a scaled-down model of a mixed layer in water experiencing cooling from the surface. This type of cooling mimics natural processes like night-time cooling or cold-air outbreaks, which generate turbulence. The DNS allowed them to resolve all the turbulent scales of motion, providing a highly accurate representation of the fluid dynamics.
  • Individual-Based Model (IBM) for Microbes: On top of the simulated fluid flow, they implemented an IBM to track the movement of individual virtual microbes. This model incorporated:
  • Advection: Microbes are carried along by the simulated fluid flow.
  • Gyrotactic Motility: Motile microbes actively swim with a tendency to orient themselves vertically. This is modeled using a "gyrotaxis" model, where a stabilizing torque (related to the microbe's reorientation timescale, B) counteracts the disorienting effect of fluid vorticity (turbulence).
  • Swimming Speed (vswim): The speed at which motile microbes swim.

They simulated both non-motile (passive) and motile (gyrotactic) microbes to compare their distributions. The model was run at a high resolution to capture sub-millimeter scales.

Datasets

The study did not use external datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, they generated their own data through the described simulation. The outputs of the microbial individual-based model simulations are publicly hosted on the Open Science Framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Patchiness is Depth-Structured and Motility-Dependent: The most striking finding is that microscale patchiness is not a universal outcome of microbial motility in turbulence. It is strongly dependent on both the microbe's swimming ability and its depth within the water column.
  • Turbulence Dominates Near the Surface: In the highly turbulent surface layer, the intense fluid motion overwhelms the microbes' swimming ability, leading to a relatively uniform distribution of both motile and non-motile microbes.
  • Deeper Waters Favor Patchiness: As depth increases and turbulence decreases (analogous to a thermocline), highly motile microbes can become significantly more concentrated in patches than their non-motile counterparts.
  • Agility is Key, but Balance is Crucial: While faster swimmers and microbes with quicker reorientation times (low B) show stronger patch enhancement, a balance between reorientation and turbulent overturning (Ψ ≈ 1) is important for maximizing patchiness.
  • "Expressways" for Agile Swimmers: Agile microbes can exploit fast-moving fluid packets to boost their effective velocity, moving much faster than their individual swimming speed would suggest. This is a key mechanism for their enhanced patch formation in deeper, less turbulent regions.
  • Gyrotaxis is Essential for Patchiness: Simulations with non-gyrotactic but still motile microbes showed no significant patch enhancement, highlighting the critical role of the anisotropic reorientation mechanism provided by gyrotaxis in counteracting turbulence and enabling patch formation.

Key Results

  • Patch Concentration Enhancement (Q): The study quantified patchiness using the Q-statistic, which measures the difference in concentration between motile and non-motile microbes within patches.
  • In the Shallow and Mid regions, Q was generally weak and often negative (around -0.03 to -0.09), indicating little to no enhancement of patchiness for motile microbes compared to non-motile ones.
  • In the Deep region, Q was positive and significantly higher, reaching up to 0.27 for agile microbes. This means agile microbes formed patches more than twice as concentrated as non-motile microbes.
  • Agile vs. Non-Agile Microbes: Agile microbes (high vswim, low B) consistently showed stronger patch enhancement, particularly in the Deep region. Non-agile microbes exhibited minimal patchiness enhancement across all regions.
  • Effective Velocity: In the Deep region, agile microbes had a significantly higher effective velocity (up to 25.1 mm/s) compared to non-agile ones (12.6 mm/s), driven by their ability to stay within fast-moving fluid packets.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation Length: The simulations ran for 60 seconds, which was sufficient to observe patch formation and differences between microbe types. However, the authors acknowledge that longer timescales might reveal different dynamics for patch maintenance versus patch creation. Future work could explore these longer-term behaviors.
  • Turbulence Sources: The study focused on turbulence generated by surface cooling. Real-world aquatic environments also experience turbulence from wind and waves. While the authors predict these would not qualitatively change their findings (as they also tend to be stronger near the surface), their inclusion would be a valuable extension.
  • Microbial Adaptations: The current model assumes constant motility parameters. Future research could incorporate how microbes dynamically adjust their swim speed or agility in response to environmental cues like temperature, nutrient gradients, or turbulence.
  • Other Motility Mechanisms: The study focused on gyrotaxis. Many microbes use isotropic reorientation mechanisms (like "tumbles"). Investigating how these interact with turbulence is a promising avenue.
  • Trophic Interactions: The model did not include other trophic levels (e.g., predators, nutrients). Incorporating these would provide a more complete ecological picture.
  • Patch Longevity: Reliably determining the lifespan of microbial patches is crucial for understanding their ecological impact, as patch lifetime must be comparable to reproduction or resource consumption timescales. This remains a challenge for modeling and measurement.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{christensen2022investigating,
  author = {Alexander Kier Christensen and Matthew D. Piggott and Erik van Sebille and Maarten van Reeuwijk and Samraat Pawar},
  title = {{Investigating microscale patchiness of motile microbes under turbulence in a simulated convective mixed layer}},
  journal = {PLOS Computational Biology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pcbi.1010291},
}

Loading related content...

Figure