Investigating Maternal Stress, Depression, and Breastfeeding: A Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (2016–2019) Analysis

Shubhecchha Dhaurali, Vickie Dugat, Tayler Whittler, Shikhar Shrestha, Marwah Kiani, Maria Gabriela Ruiz, Iman Ali, Courtney Enge, Ndidiamaka Amutah‐OnukaghaHealthcare 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzed PRAMS data from 2016-2019 to investigate the complex relationships between maternal stress, depression, and breastfeeding. Surprisingly, experiencing certain types of stress (partner-related, financial) was associated with a higher likelihood of breastfeeding, while depression showed no significant link. The findings highlight crucial racial disparities, particularly for Black mothers, suggesting a need for tailored breastfeeding support.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maternal mental health is a significant concern, with roughly one in five mothers experiencing mental health challenges during the perinatal period. These challenges, including stress and depression, are known to impact postpartum recovery and well-being. Breastfeeding is recognized as beneficial for both maternal physical and mental health. However, the precise interplay between maternal psychosocial stress, depression, and breastfeeding initiation/duration remains complex and not fully understood. Previous research has suggested that stress and depression might hinder breastfeeding, but the causal pathways are unclear, and the influence of various stressor types and demographic factors, especially race, needs further exploration. This paper aims to untangle these associations to inform better interventions and policies.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative, cross-sectional study design using secondary data analysis. They utilized logistic regression models to calculate adjusted odds ratios (aORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) to assess the associations between maternal psychosocial stressors, depression, and breastfeeding. Covariates such as maternal age, education, marital status, race/ethnicity, household income, prenatal health insurance, parity, and pregnancy intention were controlled for in the models. Sensitivity analyses were conducted to address missing data.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring Systems (PRAMS) for the years 2016–2019. PRAMS is a population-based surveillance system that collects self-reported data from women who have recently given birth, representing approximately 81% of US births. The dataset included information on women's experiences and attitudes during preconception, pregnancy, and postpartum periods. The study excluded data from 2020 due to the potential impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on maternal demographics and behaviors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stress as a potential driver for breastfeeding? This is the most counter-intuitive finding. While we often assume stress hinders breastfeeding, this study suggests that for certain stressors (partner-related, financial), mothers might be more likely to breastfeed. This challenges the prevailing narrative and points to potential underlying mechanisms like cost-saving or a desire for the health benefits of breastfeeding when facing financial strain.
  • Depression's surprising neutrality: The lack of a significant association between depression (at any stage) and breastfeeding is noteworthy. This suggests that while depression is a critical issue for maternal well-being, its direct impact on the act of breastfeeding might be less pronounced than previously assumed, or that other factors mediate this relationship.
  • The critical role of race and intersectionality: The significant interaction effects between stressors and Black race/ethnicity are a major takeaway. This highlights that the experience of stress and its impact on breastfeeding is not uniform across all populations and that targeted interventions are essential.
  • Financial stress and breastfeeding as a cost-saving measure: The strong association between financial stress and increased breastfeeding odds suggests that economic factors play a significant role in feeding choices, with breastfeeding being a more affordable option.

Key Results

  • Approximately 88% of the nearly 96,000 participants attempted breastfeeding.
  • Mothers experiencing any form of stress had a slightly higher likelihood of breastfeeding (aOR = 1.12).
  • Partner-related stress (aOR = 1.11) and financial stress (aOR = 1.17) were significantly associated with increased odds of breastfeeding.
  • Trauma-related and emotional stressors did not show a significant association with breastfeeding.
  • Depression (preconception, prenatal, or postpartum) showed no significant association with breastfeeding.
  • A significant interaction effect was observed between any stress and Black race/ethnicity on breastfeeding odds (aOR = 1.27), indicating that stress impacts breastfeeding differently for Black mothers. Similar interaction effects were found for partner-related, trauma, financial, and emotional stressors with Black race/ethnicity.
  • Compared to White individuals, Black individuals had lower odds of breastfeeding (aOR = 0.82). Conversely, Hispanic individuals had substantially higher odds (aOR = 2.66).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Self-reported data: This introduces potential biases like social desirability and recall bias.
  • Categorization of racial/ethnic groups: The five broad categories may not fully capture the diversity within these groups.
  • Exclusion of PRAMS sites: Sites without specific exposure or outcome questions were excluded, potentially limiting generalizability.
  • Missing data: While sensitivity analyses were performed, missing data for income and insurance could still influence estimates.

Future work should focus on:

  • Investigating the duration of breastfeeding in relation to stress and depression.
  • Examining the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on maternal mental health and breastfeeding.
  • Developing tailored breastfeeding interventions, particularly for Black mothers, to address their unique needs and improve outcomes.
  • Further research into the exact mechanisms driving the positive association between certain stressors and breastfeeding.
  • Exploring the role of social support in mitigating the negative impacts of stress and depression on maternal well-being and breastfeeding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Breastfeeding is invaluable for postpartum physical healing and mental wellbeing, but psychosocial stress and depression impede such recovery processes. To inform future interventions and policies, associations between breastfeeding, maternal stress, and depression were examined. Data from the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS) were analyzed (2016-2019). Logistic regression models were used to calculate adjusted odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals. Of the total sample (<i>n</i> = 95,820), approximately 88% of participants attempted breastfeeding. Our findings indicate that participants who experienced any form of stress had a slightly higher likelihood of breastfeeding compared to those without stress. Specifically, partner-related and financial-related stressors were significantly associated with increased odds of breastfeeding. However, no significant associations were observed trauma-related or emotional-related stressors and breastfeeding. Additionally, no significant association was found between depression at different stages (preconception, prenatal, and postpartum) and breastfeeding. A significant interaction effect was noted between having experienced any of the 13 stressors and Black race/ethnicity on breastfeeding odds. Similarly, significant interaction effects were observed between partner-related, trauma, financial, or emotional stressors and Black race/ethnicity. These findings emphasize the importance of considering various factors when promoting breastfeeding in diverse populations, and screening for psychosocial stress during postpartum visits. Our study recommends tailoring breastfeeding interventions to address the needs of Black mothers which could significantly improve maternal health and breastfeeding outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dhaurali2023investigating,
  author = {Shubhecchha Dhaurali and Vickie Dugat and Tayler Whittler and Shikhar Shrestha and Marwah Kiani and Maria Gabriela Ruiz and Iman Ali and Courtney Enge and Ndidiamaka Amutah‐Onukagha},
  title = {{Investigating Maternal Stress, Depression, and Breastfeeding: A Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (2016–2019) Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Healthcare},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/healthcare11121691},
}
Figure