Investigate Jobs–Housing Spatial Relationship with Individual-Based Mobility Big Data of Public Housing Tenants: A Case Study in Chongqing, China

Yi Hong, Lu Wang, Qiao Li, Xiang LiSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the spatial relationship between where public housing tenants live and work in Chongqing, China, using a novel combination of macro-level statistics and micro-level mobile phone data. It reveals that while urban structure plays a role, individual socio-economic factors and proximity to local job centers are crucial for understanding commuting patterns and potential social marginalization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urbanization, particularly in rapidly developing countries like China, often leads to a mismatch between where people live and where they work. This "jobs-housing imbalance" can result in long commutes, increased transportation costs, and social isolation, especially for vulnerable populations. Public rental housing, designed to address housing affordability, can exacerbate these issues if not strategically located. While previous research has explored jobs-housing relationships at a city-wide or district level, there's a significant gap in understanding these dynamics for specific, often marginalized, groups like public housing tenants. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the jobs-housing characteristics of public housing tenants in Chongqing, a megacity with a unique geographical layout and a mature public rental housing system.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining traditional macro-level statistical data with innovative micro-level mobile phone data.

  • Macro-level Analysis: The researchers used data from the Statistical Yearbook to calculate the Jobs-Housing Ratio (JHR) and the Jobs-Housing Balance Index (JHB) for Chongqing's administrative districts. JHR indicates the ratio of jobs to residents, while JHB assesses the balance between employment and residential functions within an area.
  • Micro-level Analysis: Crucially, the study utilized anonymized mobile phone data from 16,984 public rental housing tenants. This data allowed for the precise identification of dwelling and working locations based on patterns of nighttime presence and weekday activity.
  • Commuting Analysis: Baidu Maps' public transportation interface was used to calculate commuting time and distance, simulating weekday morning commutes. This provided a more realistic measure of travel cost for residents who primarily rely on public transport.
  • Thermodynamic Diagrams: These visualizations were used to map the density of job distribution around the studied communities, highlighting areas of high employment concentration.

This combination of data sources and analytical techniques allows for a more granular and nuanced understanding of jobs-housing relationships than traditional methods alone.

Datasets

  • Macro-level Data: Chongqing Statistical Yearbook data (number of employees and permanent residents by administrative region).
  • Micro-level Data: Anonymized mobile phone data from 16,984 public rental housing tenants in Chongqing, collected over nine days in April 2017. This data was provided by the government and excluded sensitive information.
  • Commuting Data: Baidu Maps' public transportation interface data for calculating commuting time and distance.
  • Industrial Zone Data: Government-released information on industrial zones surrounding the studied communities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urban Structure Matters, But So Does Proximity: While the overall urban spatial structure and transportation accessibility (like proximity to subway lines) influence commuting, the study highlights that proximity to local job centers is a significant driver for public housing tenants.
  • "Sandwich Layer" Commuters: A substantial portion of public rental housing applicants are young, single, and in the early stages of their careers. This demographic is more flexible in choosing where to live but is also highly sensitive to commuting costs due to limited income, making nearby job opportunities particularly attractive.
  • Beyond Simple Ratios: The study demonstrates that while JHR and JHB provide a broad overview, they don't fully capture the lived experience of specific groups. Mobile phone data offers a more direct insight into actual commuting behaviors and spatial relationships.
  • Policy Implications for "Homeownership": The findings underscore the need for future public housing planning to consider the location of industrial parks and employment centers to reduce commuting burdens and enhance the quality of life for residents.

Key Results

  • Jobs-Housing Imbalance: The JHR for most administrative districts in Chongqing's central urban area is below the ideal range of 0.8-1.2, indicating a general imbalance, with many districts being residential-dominant.
  • Commuting Patterns: Despite the overall imbalance, the average commuting time and distance for the studied public rental housing tenants were slightly lower than the city-wide average for 2018. This is attributed to the good location conditions and public transport accessibility of some communities, particularly those near subway lines.
  • Local Job Preference: Thermodynamic diagrams revealed that most residents of the studied public rental communities tend to find jobs in nearby areas, often coinciding with the location of industrial parks.
  • District-Specific Variations: The study identified significant differences in jobs-housing relationships across districts, with some exhibiting better balance (e.g., Yubei, Jiulongpo) and others showing a stronger residential dominance (e.g., Beibei, Ba'nan, Shapingba, Dadukou, Nan'an), leading to more severe commuting problems in the latter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that it could not cover all public rental housing projects in Chongqing due to data limitations.
  • Comparison Scope: The study could not compare the jobs-housing patterns of public rental housing tenants with other demographic groups.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should focus on exploring the underlying driving forces of location choice and applying the methodology to study other residential relationships, such as dwelling and school relationships, to provide a more comprehensive picture of residential choices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dwelling and working are two of the most fundamental urban functions. The jobs–housing relationship is pertinent to a city’s spatial and social structure. By using macro-level statistical data and micro-level mobile phone data, this paper innovatively adapts a way to explore the jobs–housing characteristics of public housing tenants in Chongqing, China. It finds that both external and internal factors matter. This study might provide some useful implications for further policy-making on public housing planning, and the research method could be used to examine urban spatial relationships further.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hong2022investigate,
  author = {Yi Hong and Lu Wang and Qiao Li and Xiang Li},
  title = {{Investigate Jobs–Housing Spatial Relationship with Individual-Based Mobility Big Data of Public Housing Tenants: A Case Study in Chongqing, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14063211},
}
Figure