Inverse Stability Problem and Applications to Renewables Integration

Thanh Long Vu, Hung Dinh Nguyen, Alexandre Megretski, Jean-Jacques E. Slotine, Konstantin S. TuritsynIEEE Control. Syst. Lett 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the concept of "inverse stability" for power grids, shifting focus from finding initial states that lead to stability to identifying stable operating points that a system will converge to from a given initial state. This novel approach offers a more practical way to assess and ensure grid stability, especially with the increasing integration of intermittent renewable energy sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern power grids are becoming increasingly complex due to the integration of renewable energy sources like wind and solar. These sources are intermittent, meaning their output fluctuates, leading to a constantly changing operating point (where supply meets demand). Traditional methods for assessing power system stability, which focus on whether the system returns to a fixed stable operating point after a disturbance, become computationally cumbersome and technically challenging in this dynamic environment. The paper addresses this by proposing a new framework, "inverse stability," which considers the scenario where the stable operating point itself can change. This allows for a more robust assessment of stability under varying grid conditions and renewable generation levels.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in formulating and solving the "inverse stability problem." Instead of traditional transient stability assessment (TSA) which asks "from which initial states will the system reach a given stable equilibrium point (EP)?", this paper asks "given an initial state, what is the region of EPs the system will converge to?".

The authors leverage a structure-preserving model of power systems and approximate the system's energy function quadratically. This approximation allows them to derive an "inverse stability certificate." This certificate helps define a region around a given initial state, such that if the system's operating point (EP) falls within this region, the system is guaranteed to converge to that EP from the initial state.

Key techniques include:

  • Quadratic Approximation of Energy Function: This is crucial for simplifying the complex dynamics and enabling analytical solutions.
  • LaSalle's Invariance Principle: Used to prove convergence properties based on the energy function's behavior.
  • Definition of Inverse Stability Region: A novel concept that characterizes the set of stable EPs reachable from a given initial state.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses a simulated 3-machine 9-bus system for illustration and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting the Stability Paradigm: The most significant insight is the redefinition of the stability problem from "where does it go?" to "where can it go?". This is particularly relevant for systems with dynamic EPs.
  • Practical Stability Assessment for Renewables: The inverse stability certificate provides a computationally tractable way to assess grid stability under fluctuating renewable generation, which is a major challenge for grid operators.
  • Enabling New Control Strategies: The concept opens doors for novel control strategies, such as stability-constrained optimal power flow (sOPF) and emergency control actions that actively steer the system towards stable operating points.
  • Robustness through Dynamic EPs: The paper demonstrates that by understanding the reachable set of EPs, we can design systems that are robust to uncertainties in power injections and line parameters.

Key Results

The paper successfully formulates the inverse stability problem and provides a certificate for it. The authors demonstrate its utility through three key applications:

  1. Robust Stability Assessment: The inverse stability certificate can be used to assess the transient stability of power systems for various levels of power injections, effectively handling uncertainties from renewable sources.
  2. Stability-Constrained Optimal Power Flow (sOPF): The dynamic stability constraint is transformed into a static constraint on the EP, making it feasible to incorporate into OPF problems. This allows for the design of operating conditions that are not only economically optimal but also dynamically stable.
  3. Stability-Guaranteed Corrective Action Design: The paper illustrates how power dispatching can be used to relocate the system's EP, guiding the system from a potentially unstable fault-cleared state towards a desired stable operating point. Simulations show that this control effectively stabilizes the system, as seen in Figures 5, 6, and 7.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Model: The paper uses a simplified power system model that ignores voltage variations, reactive powers, and detailed dynamics of rotor flux and controllers. The authors acknowledge that more realistic models would be more complex but suggest that the core methodology, based on energy function analysis and quadratic bounds, is extendable.
  • Approximation Accuracy: The accuracy of the inverse stability certificate depends on the quality of the quadratic approximation of the energy function.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the results to more realistic power system models and exploring further applications of the inverse stability concept in advanced control and grid management. They also mention the potential for extending this approach to port-Hamiltonian formulations of power systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{vu2018inverse,
  author = {Thanh Long Vu and Hung Dinh Nguyen and Alexandre Megretski and Jean-Jacques E. Slotine and Konstantin S. Turitsyn},
  title = {{Inverse Stability Problem and Applications to Renewables Integration}},
  journal = {IEEE Control. Syst. Lett.},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/lcsys.2017.2764040},
}
Figure