INVARIANTS OF TORIC SEIBERG DUALITY

Amihay Hanany, Yang‐Hui He, Vishnu Jejjala, Jurgis Pašukonis, Sanjaye Ramgoolam, Diego Rodrı́guez-GómezInternational Journal of Modern Physics A 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Three-branes at a given toric Calabi–Yau singularity lead to different phases of the conformal field theory related by toric (Seiberg) duality. Using the dimer model/brane tiling description in terms of bipartite graphs on a torus, we find a new invariant under Seiberg duality, namely the Klein j-invariant of the complex structure parameter in the distinguished isoradial embedding of the dimer, determined by the physical R-charges. Additional number theoretic invariants are described in terms of the algebraic number field of the R-charges. We also give a new compact description of the a-maximization procedure by introducing a generalized incidence matrix.

Introduction

In the study of $\mathcal{N}=1$ supersymmetric gauge theories, Seiberg duality provides a powerful framework for understanding how different ultraviolet (UV) descriptions can flow to the same infrared (IR) physics. When these theories are realized as the worldvolume theories of D3-branes probing a toric Calabi–Yau (CY) singularity, the duality is referred to as "toric duality." While certain invariants like the central charge $a$ and the moduli space of the theory are well-known to be preserved under duality, identifying additional mathematical "fingerprints" is crucial for classifying these theories and understanding the underlying geometry of the extra dimensions.

Dimer Models and Isoradial Geometry

The gauge theories in question are elegantly represented using dimer models, also known as brane tilings. These are bipartite graphs embedded on a two-torus ($T^2$), where the nodes represent superpotential terms and the edges represent bifundamental fields.

A critical tool in this analysis is the isoradial embedding. In this specific geometric representation, the bipartite graph is drawn such that every face is inscribed in a circle of equal radius. This embedding is physically significant because the physical R-charges of the fields, determined via $a$-maximization, are directly proportional to the angles subtended by the edges in this geometry.

Isoradial embedding of a dimer model where R-charges are represented by angles θ.

The Klein j-invariant as a Duality Invariant

The central discovery of this work is that the complex structure $\tau_R$ of the torus, as defined by the isoradial embedding, is an invariant of Seiberg duality. While the graph itself may undergo "urban renewal" moves (local transformations of the bipartite graph), the underlying shape of the torus—characterized by the Klein $j$-invariant $j(\tau_R)$—remains unchanged.

The authors provide a field-theoretic proof of this invariance and derive a "toric formula" that allows for the calculation of $\tau_R$ directly from the toric diagram of the CY singularity. This bypasses the need for explicit construction of the dimer graph, providing a direct link between the geometry of the singularity and the IR physics of the gauge theory.

Number Theoretic and Algebraic Invariants

Beyond the geometric $j$-invariant, the paper identifies invariants rooted in number theory. The physical R-charges are roots of polynomials with rational coefficients, making them algebraic numbers. The authors demonstrate that the algebraic number field generated by these R-charges, specifically its extension degree over $\mathbb{Q}$ and the rank of the vector space spanned by the charges, are invariant under toric duality.

For instance, in the case of the Suspended Pinched Point (SPP), the extension degree is 2 (involving $\sqrt{3}$), whereas more complex geometries like the $dP_2$ surface result in a degree of 4. These values serve as robust classifiers for the different phases of the theory.

Matrix Formulation of a-maximization

To streamline the calculation of these invariants, the paper introduces a generalized incidence matrix $\mathcal{M}$. This matrix unifies the linear constraints imposed by the vertices, faces, and edges of the dimer graph. The authors show that the dimension of the kernel of $\mathcal{M}$ is fixed by the number of external points in the toric diagram, providing a unified matrix-theoretic perspective on the $a$-maximization procedure.

Conclusion

By identifying the Klein $j$-invariant and number-theoretic properties of R-charges as invariants of toric Seiberg duality, this research bridges the gap between gauge theory and complex geometry. While certain non-minimal phases (such as those in $L^{2,2,2}$) present subtle challenges, the results suggest a profound geometric meaning for these invariants in string theory, paving the way for future explorations into the relationship between brane tilings and the arithmetic of Calabi-Yau manifolds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Three-branes at a given toric Calabi–Yau singularity lead to different phases of the conformal field theory related by toric (Seiberg) duality. Using the dimer model/brane tiling description in terms of bipartite graphs on a torus, we find a new invariant under Seiberg duality, namely the Klein j-invariant of the complex structure parameter in the distinguished isoradial embedding of the dimer, determined by the physical R-charges. Additional number theoretic invariants are described in terms of the algebraic number field of the R-charges. We also give a new compact description of the a-maximization procedure by introducing a generalized incidence matrix.
BibTeX
@article{hanany2012invariants,
  author = {Amihay Hanany and Yang‐Hui He and Vishnu Jejjala and Jurgis Pašukonis and Sanjaye Ramgoolam and Diego Rodrı́guez-Gómez},
  title = {{INVARIANTS OF TORIC SEIBERG DUALITY}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics A},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1142/s0217751x12500029},
}
Figure