Abstract
Traditional artificial intelligence systems often suffer from rigidity, operating within fixed reasoning logic that cannot adapt to procedural failures. This paper presents a framework for introspective reasoning within a case-based planner, enabling the system to monitor its own internal processes against a hierarchical model of ideal behavior. By identifying "expectation failures" during memory retrieval and plan adaptation, the system can autonomously repair its internal memory indexing. Preliminary results in a city navigation domain demonstrate that this self-monitoring approach improves retrieval efficiency and overall planning success rates.
Introduction
Most contemporary AI systems are characterized by a certain "brittleness." While they may exhibit expertise in specific, well-defined domains, their reasoning mechanisms are typically hard-coded by human designers. This lack of flexibility becomes a liability when the system encounters complex or shifting environments where its internal logic may no longer be optimal.
In the context of Case-Based Reasoning (CBR), a system solves new problems by retrieving and adapting solutions from past experiences. However, a significant gap exists: how can a system determine if its own retrieval and adaptation processes are functioning correctly? If a planner retrieves a case that proves to be a poor fit, the error often lies not in the data itself, but in how the system organizes and searches its memory. This research explores the implementation of introspective reasoning—a process where the system monitors its internal performance to identify and rectify procedural flaws.
Methodology
The proposed architecture integrates a standard case-based planner with a model-based introspective reasoner. The system is designed to navigate city streets, utilizing a recursive CBR mechanism where the components of the planner itself are implemented using the same reasoning principles as the overall system.
Hierarchical Assertions
To bridge the gap between abstract reasoning theory and practical application, the authors utilize a hierarchy of assertions. High-level assertions define general principles of ideal AI behavior (e.g., "the retrieved case should be the most similar available"). These are linked to low-level, task-specific assertions (e.g., "verify if the street segment matches the goal direction"). This structure allows the system to map broad performance goals to specific operational checks.
Expectation Failures and Self-Repair
The system constantly evaluates its reasoning steps against these hierarchical assertions. When a discrepancy is detected—for instance, if the system realizes post-execution that a different case would have yielded a more efficient route—it triggers an "expectation failure."
Once a failure is identified, the introspective reasoner performs a root-cause analysis. If the failure is traced back to a retrieval error, the system performs a self-repair by re-indexing its memory. By creating new indices that better distinguish between the "true best" case and the sub-optimal choice, the system ensures it does not repeat the same reasoning error in future tasks.
Experimental Evaluation
The system was evaluated within a custom planning domain modeled after the CHEF planner (Hammond 1989), specifically focusing on city street navigation. The evaluation compared the performance of the planner with the introspective reasoning module enabled against a baseline version where it was disabled.
Key Findings
Preliminary results indicate that introspective reasoning significantly enhances the planner's capabilities:
- Retrieval Efficiency: Introspectively re-indexing memory alone was shown to improve the efficiency of the retrieval process over time.
- Success Rates: The system achieved higher success rates in planning tasks, as the self-repair mechanism allowed it to learn from past retrieval errors and avoid them in subsequent trials.
- Structural Validation: The implementation of a skeletal hierarchical model successfully demonstrated that general CBR principles could be mapped to specific, repairable planning failures.
Discussion and Future Work
While the current results are promising, the authors acknowledge that the system is currently a "skeletal" model. The vocabulary of failure types needs to be expanded to handle a wider array of reasoning errors beyond simple retrieval issues. Furthermore, the current scope of repair is primarily limited to memory re-indexing; future iterations aim to include repairs for adaptation mechanisms—the process of modifying old plans to fit new constraints.
Finally, while the hierarchical approach is designed for generalizability, the low-level assertions are currently specific to the city navigation domain. Testing the portability of this introspective framework to diverse domains remains a critical next step in developing truly robust, self-adaptive AI systems.
Summary updated