Introduction to the Minitrack on Smart Tourism and Data-driven Decision Making

Jahyun Goo, Chun‐Ying Huang, Chul Woo Yoo, Soyoung ParkProceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2024 · DOI

Smart tourism has evolved from a technological buzzword into a complex, data-intensive ecosystem. At the 57th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS 2024), the "Smart Tourism and Data-driven Decision Making" minitrack explores this evolution, emphasizing that smart tourism is an integrated effort to enhance sustainability and resident quality of life through strategic data utilization.

The Theoretical and Statistical Challenge

Despite its rapid growth, the field of smart tourism faces significant hurdles. Theoretically, there is a lack of clear strategic frameworks that define how data collection translates into destination improvement. Methodologically, much of the industry relies on tourist surveys using bipolar scales (e.g., Likert scales ranging from "Strongly Disagree" to "Strongly Agree").

A critical flaw in current research is the tendency to focus on the magnitude of agreement while neglecting the magnitude of disagreement. This "disagreement blind spot" introduces systematic bias into both descriptive and inferential analyses. When researchers ignore the negative side of the scale, they lose vital information, leading to weakened statistical results and, ultimately, flawed managerial decisions.

Advancing Methodology: Compositional Data Statistics

To address these biases, featured research within the minitrack (notably by Lehmann and Vogt) proposes a shift toward Compositional Data Statistics.

Traditional analytical methods often treat survey responses as independent points on a linear scale. In contrast, compositional data analysis treats data as parts of a whole—specifically as proportions or ratios. By applying this framework to bipolar scales, researchers can simultaneously account for the relationship between agreement and disagreement.

Through the use of simulated data, this approach has demonstrated:

  • Bias Reduction: Correcting the inherent errors found in traditional bipolar scale analysis.
  • Increased Statistical Power: Making results more sensitive to actual trends and more reliable for decision-making.

The Data Ecosystem

The minitrack defines a broad data landscape essential for smart tourism:

  • Tourist-Centric Data: Psychographics, behavioral patterns, and spending habits.
  • Supplier Data: Operational information from airlines, lodging, and tour operators.
  • Infrastructure Data: Real-time inputs from smart city sensors and government sources.

By aggregating these diverse sources—ranging from physical infrastructure to social connections and even psychophysiological data—destinations can create more effective "business value-propositions" centered on efficiency and sustainability.

From Statistical Power to Decision Power

The ultimate goal of improving mathematical rigor is to enhance "decision power." For destination managers, more accurate analytics enable "contextual marketing" and "personalized services." By bridging the gap between advanced statistics and practical management, smart tourism can move from simple data collection to strategic, evidence-based governance.

Future Outlook

As the field matures, several areas require further investigation:

  • Strategic Deceleration: Moving away from trend-chasing toward building robust theoretical foundations.
  • Big Data Validation: Testing compositional statistics against massive, "noisy" real-world datasets from smart cities.
  • Community Impact: Shifting focus toward how data-driven decisions improve the quality of life for local residents, ensuring that tourism benefits the host community as much as the visitor.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{goo2024introduction,
  author = {Jahyun Goo and Chun‐Ying Huang and Chul Woo Yoo and Soyoung Park},
  title = {{Introduction to the Minitrack on Smart Tourism and Data-driven Decision Making}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.24251/hicss.2024.213},
}
Figure