Introduction of the Double-Differenced Ambiguity Resolution into Precise Point Positioning

Haojun Li, Jingxin Xiao, Shoujian Zhang, Jin Zhou, Jiexian WangRemote 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method that integrates double-differenced (DD) ambiguity resolution into precise point positioning (PPP). By leveraging the strengths of both techniques, the proposed approach significantly improves PPP accuracy and convergence times, making it more suitable for applications like displacement monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Precise Point Positioning (PPP) is a powerful technique for determining a receiver's position with high accuracy using a single GNSS receiver. However, a major limitation of traditional PPP is that its ambiguities (which are crucial for achieving centimeter-level accuracy) are estimated as real-valued numbers and cannot be directly fixed to integers. This "float" ambiguity estimation leads to longer convergence times and can impact overall accuracy.

On the other hand, the double-differenced (DD) model, commonly used in relative positioning, excels at resolving integer ambiguities quickly due to the differencing between receivers and satellites. However, DD positioning estimates relative coordinates, making it unsuitable for monitoring absolute displacements of individual stations.

This paper aims to bridge this gap by combining the advantages of both PPP and DD ambiguity resolution. The goal is to achieve the high accuracy and integer ambiguity fixing of DD methods within the absolute positioning framework of PPP, thereby enhancing PPP's performance and applicability, especially for displacement monitoring.

Methods

The core of this paper is a new strategy that integrates DD integer ambiguity resolution into the PPP processing workflow. Here's a breakdown of the key steps:

  • DD Ambiguity Generation: The method first generates double-differenced (DD) ambiguities using observations from reference stations and the user receiver.
  • DD Ambiguity Fixing: These DD ambiguities are then fixed to their integer values using a DD model-based algorithm.
  • Undifferenced Ambiguity Estimation: Crucially, the paper uses the fixed DD ambiguities to derive high-quality undifferenced (SD - Satellite-Differenced) ambiguities for the user. This is a key innovation, as it leverages the reliability of DD fixing to improve the quality of the undifferenced ambiguities used in PPP.
  • Ratio Test and Weighted Ambiguity Selection: The selection of the best undifferenced ambiguities for PPP processing is guided by a ratio test applied to the DD ambiguities. Furthermore, a ratio value-based weighting scheme is employed to ensure the quality of the selected ambiguities. This helps to filter out unreliable ambiguity estimates.
  • PPP Re-processing: Finally, these high-quality, fixed undifferenced ambiguities are introduced into the PPP processing for the user, leading to improved position estimates and reduced convergence times.

The paper also details the mathematical models for these transformations, including how satellite and receiver biases are handled and how the DD ambiguities are derived from SD ambiguities.

Datasets

The study utilizes GPS data from two experiments:

  • Experiment 1: Ten days of data (August 11-20, 2014) from eight stations in China, including local (average distance ~53 km) and regional (average distance ~399 km) reference stations. One station (SHJD) was designated as the user station. Data was sampled at 30-second intervals with an elevation cut-off angle of 9 degrees.
  • Experiment 2: 12 hours of data collected on August 12, 2014, from two GNSS receivers placed approximately 300 meters apart. This experiment was specifically designed to test the method's capability in displacement monitoring.

The final International GNSS Service (IGS) products for satellite clocks and orbits were used for processing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the PPP-DD Gap: The most significant insight is the successful integration of DD ambiguity resolution into PPP. This allows PPP to benefit from the rapid and reliable integer fixing capabilities of DD methods, overcoming a fundamental limitation of traditional PPP.
  • Quality Control for Ambiguities: The use of the DD ambiguity ratio test and ratio value-based weighting is a clever way to ensure the quality of the undifferenced ambiguities fed into the PPP process. This directly addresses the issue of unreliable ambiguity estimates in PPP.
  • Enhanced Displacement Monitoring: The paper demonstrates that the proposed method is superior to traditional DD methods for monitoring absolute displacements. While DD methods provide accurate relative positioning, they cannot detect individual station movements if they occur synchronously. The new PPP-based approach, however, can detect these absolute displacements.
  • Space-Correlation Errors: The analysis of residuals reveals the presence of space-correlation errors that are not fully modeled by the coordinate-differenced algorithm. This explains why even the improved PPP solutions might not reach the accuracy of DD methods in certain scenarios and points to areas for future research.

Key Results

The proposed method demonstrated significant improvements in PPP accuracy and convergence:

  • Positioning Accuracy:
    • For 1-h, 2-h, and 4-h sessions, mean relative improvements of approximately 19%, 18%, and 15% for north, east, and up components were observed compared to a baseline PPP strategy.
  • When the ratio value-based weight was used, prominent improvements of 29%, 31%, and 25% for north, east, and up components were achieved.
  • RMS errors were reduced, with improvements up to 20% for local reference stations and 27% for regional reference stations in certain scenarios.
  • Convergence Time: The mean convergence times for the improved strategies (#2 and #3) were reduced to 10 minutes, compared to 13 minutes for the baseline strategy (#1).
  • Displacement Monitoring: The method successfully detected obvious displacements in the north, east, and up directions in the second experiment, a capability that traditional DD methods lacked due to their focus on relative positioning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Space-Correlation Errors: The paper acknowledges that space-correlation errors (e.g., ionospheric delays) can affect PPP accuracy and are not fully modeled by the current approach. Further improvements in modeling these errors are needed.
  • GNSS Clock and Orbit Improvement: The authors suggest that significant further improvements in PPP solutions, particularly in convergence time and accuracy, may require advancements in GNSS clock and orbit products.
  • Comparison with DD: While the new method excels in displacement monitoring, the paper notes that the DD model-based relative positioning solution can still be slightly more accurate for relative positioning itself. However, its inability to monitor absolute displacement limits its application in certain scenarios.

Future work could focus on better modeling of space-correlation errors and exploring how improved GNSS products can further enhance the performance of this integrated PPP-DD ambiguity resolution strategy.

Summary updated

Abstract

According to the advantages of the precise point positioning (PPP) and the double-differenced (DD) model based algorithm, a new method for the integration of DD integer ambiguity resolution into PPP is presented. This method uses the undifferenced ambiguity estimated with PPP computation and the DD ambiguity generated from the DD model based algorithm to realize the PPP ambiguity fixing. In the presented method, the selection of the undifferenced ambiguity bases on the ratio test of the DD ambiguity and the ratio values based weight is used in PPP processing. This ensures the quality of the used undifferenced ambiguity. To validate the presented method, two experiments are implemented using the ten days (11 to 20 August 2014) data from local and regional reference stations and the moved two receivers. The results of the presented strategy show that improvements are achieved in all three coordinate components. The 1-h, 2-h, and 4-h PPP results indicate that the mean relative improvements were about 19%, 18%, and 15% for north, east, and up components. These results also show that prominent improvements of 29%, 31%, and 25% for north, east, and up components were obtained when the ratio values based weight was used. The application of the presented method in the displacement monitoring was implemented with the experiment and it showed that the PPP estimation computed with the presented strategy benefits local or regional displacement monitoring and improves the detecting ability for displacement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2018introduction,
  author = {Haojun Li and Jingxin Xiao and Shoujian Zhang and Jin Zhou and Jiexian Wang},
  title = {{Introduction of the Double-Differenced Ambiguity Resolution into Precise Point Positioning}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/rs10111779},
}
Figure