Introduction

Angela McCarthySites 2020 · DOI

Abstract

On 15 March 2019, Muslims at prayer in the Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Islamic Centre in Christchurch, New Zealand, found themselves under a terrorist attack livestreamed on the Internet. All told, 51 Muslim worshippers—former refugees and migrants, New Zealand and foreign born—were murdered in cold blood while a further 40 were wounded. They were the target of an Australian white supremacist who viewed them as 'invaders' seeking to replace 'his' people. This terror attack had particular resonance in Dunedin, where the gunman resided and had initially planned to launch his assault. This multidisciplinary collection serves as a tribute to the mosque victims and survivors, exploring the complexities of refugee resettlement in the wake of this tragedy.

From "Refugee Crisis" to "Reception Crisis"

A central argument of this paper is the need for a conceptual shift in how we view displacement. Rather than framing the movement of people as a "refugee crisis," the author suggests we address it as a reception crisis. This perspective shifts the focus from the displaced individuals to the host nations and their potential failure to provide adequate, culturally competent, and safe environments for newcomers.

In New Zealand, while the Christchurch attacks represented an extreme form of overt violence, the paper identifies a more insidious challenge: structural violence. This manifests through institutional monoculturalism and neoliberal policies that create economic inequities in essential areas such as housing, health, and education. When the host community's reception is inadequate, the resettlement period can become more traumatic than the initial displacement.

Multidisciplinary Methodologies

As an introduction to a journal volume (SITES: New Series), this work synthesizes various qualitative approaches used to understand the lived experience of "everyday citizenship." Key methods include:

  • Narrative Inquiry: Deep-dives into personal histories, such as the journeys of Bhutanese and Syrian refugees.
  • Qualitative Interviews: Engaging with "former refugees," NGOs, and support providers to bridge the gap between policy and practice.
  • Visual Methods: Using photography to examine how refugees interact with "therapeutic landscapes" like public parks and outdoor spaces.
  • Historical and Comparative Analysis: Comparing current Syrian resettlement in Dunedin with the city’s history of Cambodian resettlement in the 1970s, and looking at the experiences of female students across different national contexts.

Key Insights: Agency and Manākitanga

The research highlights several critical themes regarding the resettlement landscape:

  • The Power of Terminology: There is a deliberate move toward using terms like "former refugee" or "refugee-background" to avoid the stigma associated with the "refugee" label, though some individuals reclaim the term to honor their history or mobilize resources.
  • Manākitanga (Hospitality): The author advocates for resettlement efforts to be guided by the Māori concept of manākitanga, fostering a holistic, indigenous-informed approach to welcoming newcomers.
  • The Burden of "First Hosts": Former refugees often act as the primary, informal support network for new arrivals. They perform the vital labor of resettlement that formal institutions sometimes fail to provide.
  • Barriers to Wellbeing: Even when "therapeutic landscapes" exist, they are often inaccessible due to practical hurdles like lack of transportation, time constraints, and the shock of a new climate.

Institutional Results and Future Directions

The collection identifies that "monocultural institutions" often expect migrants to adapt to a Pākehā (European-descendant) culture, which can exacerbate existing trauma. However, there are systemic changes underway, including New Zealand's 2020 commitment to increasing its refugee quota to 1,500 per annum and expanding resettlement to regional locations like Ashburton and Timaru.

Looking forward, the author calls for a shift away from "deficit-based" approaches toward strengths-based research. This involves highlighting refugee agency, resilience, and the benefits of multilingualism. Future research must also address the specific experiences of child refugees and the critical intersection between refugee resettlement and Māori/Indigenous concerns.

Summary updated

Abstract

On 15 March 2019, Muslims at prayer in the Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Islamic Centre in Christchurch, New Zealand, found themselves under a terrorist attack livestreamed on the Internet. All told, 51 Muslim worshippers, former refugees and migrants, New Zealand and foreign born, were murdered in cold blood while a further 40 were wounded. They were the target of an Australian white supremacist who believed them to be a visible and large group of socalled invaders with high fertility rates and strong traditions seeking to occupy lands and replace 'his' people. The terror attack had particular resonance in Dunedin for it was here that the gunman resided, and he had initially planned to launch his assault on the city's Al Huda Mosque. In September 2020 he was sentenced to life in prison. This multidisciplinary collection is a tribute to the mosque victims and survivors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mccarthy2020introduction,
  author = {Angela McCarthy},
  title = {{Introduction}},
  booktitle = {Sites},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.11157/sites-id475},
}
Figure