Intraspecific sequence variation and complete genomes refine the identification of rapidly evolved regions in humans

Yanting Luo, Riley J. Mangan, Seth Weaver, Sarah A Zhao, Federica Mosti, Michael C. Thomas, Ravi Karra, Debra L. Silver, Manolis Kellis, Craig B. LowebioRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces "Consensus HAQERs," a refined set of rapidly evolved human genomic regions identified using complete telomere-to-telomere (T2T) genome assemblies and accounting for human population variation. These regions show signatures of accelerated evolution, positive selection, and regulatory function, offering new insights into the genetic basis of human-specific traits and disease susceptibilities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Humans have undergone significant evolutionary changes compared to other great apes, but pinpointing the genetic drivers of these differences has been challenging. Previous studies relied on incomplete reference genomes and single assemblies, which conflated true interspecies divergence with intraspecific variation. This made it difficult to accurately identify regions that rapidly evolved specifically in the human lineage. Additionally, many of these rapidly evolving regions were located in complex, repetitive genomic areas that were historically difficult to sequence and analyze.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel approach to identify "Consensus HAQERs" (Human Ancestor Quickly Evolved Regions). This involved:

  • Telomere-to-Telomere (T2T) Genome Alignment: They aligned 20 complete T2T genome assemblies from humans and great apes. This provided a more comprehensive view of the genome, including previously inaccessible repetitive regions.
  • Incorporating Population Variation: Crucially, they included multiple human T2T assemblies representing different ancestries. This allowed them to distinguish between true human-specific divergence and variations present within human populations.
  • Probabilistic Ancestral Reconstruction: They used probabilistic methods to infer ancestral sequences, further refining the identification of divergence events.
  • Multiplex, Single-Cell Enhancer Assays (scSTARR-seq): To functionally validate the identified HAQERs, they used these assays in developing brain and heart cells to assess their regulatory activity as enhancers.

Datasets

  • Genome Assemblies: 20 telomere-to-telomere (T2T) genome assemblies were used, including:
  • 1 human reference genome (hs1/T2T-CHM13)
    • 7 diverse T2T human haplotypes (Ashkenazi and Han Chinese ancestries)
    • 12 T2T non-human ape assemblies (chimpanzee, bonobo, gorilla, Bornean orangutan, Sumatran orangutan, and siamang gibbon)
  • Human Genetic Variation Data: 1000 Genomes Project data from 501 African individuals was used to assess population variation.
  • Epigenomic Data: 127 and 833 reference epigenomes from the Roadmap Epigenomics Consortium and EpiMap were used for chromatin state analysis.
  • GWAS Catalog: Data from the GWAS Catalog was used to assess enrichment in disease-linked loci.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Importance of Complete Genomes and Population Data: The study highlights that using complete T2T genomes and accounting for intraspecific variation is essential for accurately identifying lineage-specific evolutionary changes, moving beyond the limitations of older methods.
  • HAQERs as Drivers of Human Uniqueness: Consensus HAQERs are not just regions of divergence but show strong signatures of accelerated mutation rates, ancient positive selection, and regulatory function, suggesting they play a significant role in shaping human-specific traits.
  • Regulatory Elements in Repetitive DNA: Many HAQERs emerged in previously "dark" repetitive regions of the genome, indicating that these areas are not just genomic junk but can harbor important functional elements driving evolution.
  • Bivalent Chromatin and Poised Regulatory Function: HAQERs are enriched in bivalent chromatin states, which are poised for context-specific activation, suggesting their role in fine-tuning gene regulation during development and in response to environmental cues.

Key Results

  • Identification of 1,596 Consensus HAQERs: This new set of regions represents the most divergent segments between the human-chimpanzee ancestor and an inferred human ancestral node, accounting for population variation.
  • Signatures of Accelerated Evolution: Consensus HAQERs exhibit elevated mutation rates and evidence of ancient positive selection.
  • Enrichment in Disease-Linked Loci: HAQERs are significantly enriched in regions associated with various diseases, including neuroblastoma, psychiatric disorders, and gastrointestinal conditions.
  • Functional Enhancer Activity: Multiplex, single-cell enhancer assays demonstrated that HAQERs function as active enhancers in developing brain and heart cells, highlighting their role in human-specific gene regulation. For example, one HAQER was found to be an active enhancer in the developing cerebral cortex overlapping the DLGAP2 gene, which is linked to neuropsychiatric disorders. Another HAQER showed enhancer activity in cardiomyocytes, overlapping the BDH1 gene, associated with heart failure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited African Ancestry Data: The current set of T2T human assemblies lacks representation from African ancestries, which are crucial for a comprehensive understanding of human genetic diversity. Future work with more diverse T2T genomes is needed.
  • Heterogeneity of Selection: While HAQER sets show signatures of positive selection, selection is likely heterogeneous within these regions, with some HAQERs under selection and others evolving neutrally. Developing methods to evaluate selection at single loci across deep evolutionary timescales remains a challenge.
  • Functional Validation: While functional enhancer activity was demonstrated, future work is needed to directly link HAQER evolution to altered gene expression and organismal phenotypes.
  • Gorilla-Specific Analysis: The study detected relatively few gorilla-AQERs, likely due to the longer phylogenetic branch from the human-gorilla ancestor. The framework may be better tuned for closely related species.
  • Balance of Mechanisms: The relative contribution of modifying existing elements versus creating de novo functional sequences in human evolution remains an open question.

Summary updated

Abstract

Humans exhibit significant phenotypic differences from other great apes, yet pinpointing the underlying genetic changes has been limited by incomplete reference genomes and a reliance on single assemblies to represent a species. We aligned 20 telomere-to-telomere (T2T) assemblies spanning great ape divergence and variation to define 1,596 Consensus HAQERs (consensus human ancestor quickly evolved regions), regions that diverged rapidly between the human-chimpanzee ancestor and an ancestral node of modern humans. Unlike prior HAQER sets, Consensus HAQERs incorporate population variation, reducing the likelihood of intraspecies variation appearing as interspecies divergence. Consensus HAQERs exhibit signatures of elevated mutation rates, ancient positive selection, bivalent regulatory function, are enriched in disease-linked loci, and often emerged in previously inaccessible repetitive DNA. Through multiplex, single-cell enhancer assays, we identify HAQERs as active enhancers in the developing brain and cardiomyocytes, highlighting their potential contributions to human-specific gene regulation across multiple tissues.
BibTeX
@misc{luo2025intraspecific,
  author = {Yanting Luo and Riley J. Mangan and Seth Weaver and Sarah A Zhao and Federica Mosti and Michael C. Thomas and Ravi Karra and Debra L. Silver and Manolis Kellis and Craig B. Lowe},
  title = {{Intraspecific sequence variation and complete genomes refine the identification of rapidly evolved regions in humans}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.10.20.683446},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure