Intracranial EEG signals disentangle multi-areal neural dynamics of vicarious pain perception

Huixin Tan, Xiaoyu Zeng, Jun Ni, Kun Liang, Cuiping Xu, Yanyang Zhang, Jiaxin Wang, Zizhou Li, J. C. S. Yang, Chunlei Han, Yuan Gao, Xinguang Yu, Shihui Han, Fangang Meng, Yina MaNature Communications 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Empathy enables understanding and sharing of others' feelings. Human neuroimaging studies have identified critical brain regions supporting empathy for pain, including the anterior insula (AI), anterior cingulate (ACC), amygdala, and inferior frontal gyrus (IFG). However, to date, the precise spatio-temporal profiles of empathic neural responses and inter-regional communications remain elusive. Here, using intracranial electroencephalography, we investigated electrophysiological signatures of vicarious pain perception. Others' pain perception induced early increases in high-gamma activity in IFG, beta power increases in ACC, but decreased beta power in AI and amygdala. Vicarious pain perception also altered the beta-band-coordinated coupling between ACC, AI, and amygdala, as well as increased modulation of IFG high-gamma amplitudes by beta phases of amygdala/AI/ACC. We identified a necessary combination of neural features for decoding vicarious pain perception. These spatio-temporally specific regional activities and inter-regional interactions within the empathy network suggest a neurodynamic model of human pain empathy.

Introduction

While it is well-established that empathy allows us to "feel" the pain of others, the underlying neural mechanics have remained difficult to characterize. Functional MRI (fMRI) has identified a "core empathy network"—including the anterior insula (AI), anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), amygdala, and inferior frontal gyrus (IFG)—but its temporal resolution is too slow to capture rapid, millisecond-scale communication. Conversely, traditional scalp EEG lacks the spatial resolution to probe deep structures like the amygdala. This study addresses these gaps by using intracranial EEG (iEEG) to map the temporal order, spectral patterns, and inter-regional coordination of the empathy network.

Methods

The researchers recorded iEEG signals from 22 pre-surgical epilepsy patients (13 males, mean age ~25.7) with electrodes implanted directly into the brain. To ensure behavioral representativeness, results were compared with a healthy control group of 22 age- and gender-matched individuals. Participants viewed 20 pairs of images depicting hands in painful situations (e.g., a door slamming on a finger) versus matched non-painful control situations. The experimental task followed a structured sequence: a fixation period (800-1600ms), a stimulus display (500ms), and a self-paced pain judgment task where participants rated whether the person in the picture experienced pain.

Experimental paradigm and stimulus examples.

Results

Behavioral Validation

Behavioral assessments confirmed that participants accurately distinguished between painful and non-painful stimuli. Perceived pain intensity ratings were significantly higher for the painful condition compared to the non-painful condition, validating the efficacy of the visual stimuli in eliciting empathic responses.

Behavioral ratings of perceived pain intensity.

Spatio-Temporal Dynamics

The iEEG data revealed a clear chronological sequence of neural activation. The process begins in the IFG (60ms), moves to the AI (120ms) and ACC (180ms), and finally reaches the amygdala (370ms). This timeline suggests a hierarchical processing of vicarious pain, starting from early perception and moving toward affective evaluation.

Spectral Signatures and Network Hubs

The study identified beta-band oscillations as a primary "language" for network coordination. Vicarious pain increased beta power in the ACC but decreased it in the AI and amygdala. Notably, the IFG emerged as a central integrator; its high-gamma amplitude was modulated by the beta phases of the AI, ACC, and amygdala. This phase-amplitude coupling suggests the IFG synthesizes sensory and affective information from across the network.

Decoding Vicarious Pain

Using Support Vector Machine (SVM) decoding, the researchers achieved 76.28% accuracy in discriminating painful from non-painful stimuli. A "virtual disruption" analysis revealed that no single neural feature was sufficient for this task. Instead, a specific combination of eight neural features—including ACC beta power and inter-regional couplings—was required for successful decoding.

Discussion

These findings provide a comprehensive neurodynamic model of human pain empathy. The results support the "shared representation hypothesis," as the suppression of alpha/beta oscillations in the AI and ACC during vicarious pain mirrors neural patterns observed during first-hand pain experiences. While the study is limited by its clinical population and electrode coverage, it offers unprecedented insight into how the human brain integrates distributed signals to perceive and share the suffering of others.

Summary updated

Abstract

Empathy enables understanding and sharing of others' feelings. Human neuroimaging studies have identified critical brain regions supporting empathy for pain, including the anterior insula (AI), anterior cingulate (ACC), amygdala, and inferior frontal gyrus (IFG). However, to date, the precise spatio-temporal profiles of empathic neural responses and inter-regional communications remain elusive. Here, using intracranial electroencephalography, we investigated electrophysiological signatures of vicarious pain perception. Others' pain perception induced early increases in high-gamma activity in IFG, beta power increases in ACC, but decreased beta power in AI and amygdala. Vicarious pain perception also altered the beta-band-coordinated coupling between ACC, AI, and amygdala, as well as increased modulation of IFG high-gamma amplitudes by beta phases of amygdala/AI/ACC. We identified a necessary combination of neural features for decoding vicarious pain perception. These spatio-temporally specific regional activities and inter-regional interactions within the empathy network suggest a neurodynamic model of human pain empathy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2024intracranial,
  author = {Huixin Tan and Xiaoyu Zeng and Jun Ni and Kun Liang and Cuiping Xu and Yanyang Zhang and Jiaxin Wang and Zizhou Li and J. C. S. Yang and Chunlei Han and Yuan Gao and Xinguang Yu and Shihui Han and Fangang Meng and Yina Ma},
  title = {{Intracranial EEG signals disentangle multi-areal neural dynamics of vicarious pain perception}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-49541-1},
}
Figure