Intracellular Calcium Spikes in Rat Suprachiasmatic Nucleus Neurons Induced by BAPTA-Based Calcium Dyes

Jin Hee Hong, Cheol Hong Min, Byeongha Jeong, Tomoyoshi Kojiya, Eri Morioka, Takeharu Nagai, Masayuki Ikeda, Kyoung J. LeePLoS 2010 · DOI

Abstract

Despite extensive experimentation, no evidence of a circadian rhythm was found in the spontaneous calcium ($Ca^{2+}$) spiking activity of the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN). This study strongly suggests that such spiking activity is an artifact caused by the $Ca^{2+}$ chelating effect of BAPTA-based dyes, specifically fluo-4. Consequently, this induced activity appears irrelevant to the intrinsic circadian rhythm of cytosolic free calcium ($[Ca^{2+}]_c$) in SCN neurons. While these findings highlight a significant methodological concern regarding $Ca^{2+}$ spikes in the SCN, they do not invalidate the use of these dyes in other contexts or dismiss the potential functional roles of $Ca^{2+}$ spikes in SCN physiology.

Introduction

The suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) serves as the primary circadian pacemaker in mammals, coordinating daily physiological and behavioral rhythms. SCN neurons are characterized by two prominent circadian oscillations: the frequency of action potential (AP) firing and the slow fluctuation of cytosolic free calcium ($[Ca^{2+}]_c$).

Previous research utilizing chemical fluorescent dyes reported "calcium spikes"—rapid transients lasting between 10 and 100 seconds. However, the biological significance of these spikes and their relationship to the core circadian clock remained contentious. This study investigates whether these spikes are an intrinsic feature of SCN neurons or an experimental artifact induced by the measurement tools themselves.

Methodology

To investigate the origin of calcium spikes, researchers compared two distinct imaging modalities:

  1. Chemical Indicators: Fluo-4 AM, a high-affinity, BAPTA-based fluorescent dye.
  2. Genetically Encoded Calcium Indicators (GECIs): Yellow Cameleon (YC3.6), a protein-based sensor that does not utilize BAPTA-like chelation.

Experiments were conducted on acute brain slices and organotypic slice cultures from Sprague-Dawley rats and C57BL/6J mice. The study involved a large-scale analysis of over 2,600 cells across 82 slices. To correlate calcium dynamics with electrical activity, simultaneous patch-clamp recordings and imaging were performed, tracking the physiological changes in neurons as the chemical dyes diffused into the cytoplasm.

Key Findings

The Role of Chelation

A stark contrast was observed between the two imaging methods. Approximately 18% of SCN cells loaded with fluo-4 exhibited frequent calcium spikes. In contrast, these spikes were nearly absent (less than 3%) in cells expressing the Yellow Cameleon protein.

The "smoking gun" was identified when BAPTA-AM—a calcium chelator that shares the chemical backbone of fluo-4 but lacks fluorescent properties—was added to Cameleon-expressing cells. This addition successfully induced calcium spikes, confirming that the act of calcium chelation itself triggers the abnormal spiking behavior.

Altered Neuronal Physiology

Patch-clamp data revealed that the introduction of fluo-4 fundamentally altered the neurons' electrical properties. As the dye entered the cell, the resting membrane potential hyperpolarized (dropping from approximately -43 mV to -54 mV). This was followed by a transition from regular firing patterns to an abnormal "bursting" mode, where each burst of electrical activity corresponded directly to a calcium spike.

Absence of Circadian Modulation

Unlike the well-documented circadian rhythms in AP firing and slow $[Ca^{2+}]_c$ oscillations, the frequency of these induced calcium spikes showed no significant day/night variation. This lack of rhythmicity further supports the conclusion that these spikes are not a component of the SCN's natural circadian output.

Discussion and Limitations

The study provides a cautionary tale regarding the use of high-affinity BAPTA-based dyes in neurobiology. The researchers hypothesize that these dyes interfere with the cell's internal calcium buffering mechanisms, potentially forcing the neuron into a compensatory "recovery mode" characterized by bursting activity.

While the study clarifies the nature of these transients, it does not rule out the existence of extremely rapid calcium events. The image acquisition rate was limited to approximately one frame per second, meaning transients shorter than one second might remain undetected. Future studies using high-speed imaging or non-chelating indicators may provide further clarity on the natural calcium dynamics of the SCN.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite our extensive set of experiments, no evidence of a circadian rhythm was found in the spontaneous Ca(2+) spiking activity of SCN. Furthermore, our study strongly suggests that the spontaneous Ca(2+) spiking activity is caused by the Ca(2+) chelating effect of the BAPTA-based fluo-4 dye. Therefore, this induced activity seems irrelevant to the intrinsic circadian rhythm of [Ca(2+)](c) in SCN neurons. The problems with BAPTA based dyes are widely known and our study provides a clear case for concern, in particular, for SCN Ca(2+) spikes. On the other hand, our study neither invalidates the use of these dyes as a whole, nor undermines the potential role of SCN Ca(2+) spikes in the function of SCN.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hong2010intracellular,
  author = {Jin Hee Hong and Cheol Hong Min and Byeongha Jeong and Tomoyoshi Kojiya and Eri Morioka and Takeharu Nagai and Masayuki Ikeda and Kyoung J. Lee},
  title = {{Intracellular Calcium Spikes in Rat Suprachiasmatic Nucleus Neurons Induced by BAPTA-Based Calcium Dyes}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0009634},
}
Figure