Intimate Partner Violence Screening Instruments: A Protocol for a COSMIN-Based Systematic Review

Yanjia Li, Keyi Zhou, Siyuan Tang, Jiarui ChenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper outlines a protocol for a systematic review to evaluate the quality and suitability of existing intimate partner violence (IPV) screening instruments. By applying the COSMIN methodology, the review aims to provide researchers with evidence-based guidance on selecting the most appropriate IPV screening tools for their specific contexts, ultimately improving the identification and support of IPV victims.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intimate partner violence (IPV) is a significant global public health issue with far-reaching consequences for individuals and society. While numerous screening instruments exist to identify IPV, their development and validation often occur in specific cultural and linguistic contexts. This leads to a challenge for researchers and practitioners worldwide: how to select the most appropriate, methodologically sound, and contextually relevant IPV screening instrument from a diverse and unevenly validated pool of tools. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a rigorous systematic review protocol to critically appraise these instruments.

Methods

The authors propose a systematic review based on the COSMIN (COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments) methodology. This approach is specifically designed for evaluating patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). The review will adapt the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses) checklist, focusing on construct, populations, type of instruments, and measurement properties.

The core methodological steps include:

  • Formulating the review's aim and eligibility criteria: Defining what constitutes an IPV screening instrument and the types of studies to be included.
  • Comprehensive literature search: Utilizing multiple databases (PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global, EBSCO PBSC) with a detailed search strategy combining medical subject headings and free-text terms related to IPV, screening, and measurement properties.
  • Study screening and data extraction: A multi-stage process involving duplicate removal, title/abstract screening, and full-text review by at least two independent researchers, with a third researcher resolving disagreements. Data extraction will cover general study information, instrument characteristics, measurement properties (validity, reliability, internal consistency), and feasibility.
  • Quality appraisal: Using the COSMIN Risk of Bias checklist to evaluate the methodological quality of studies reporting on measurement properties. Instruments will be assessed for each property, and the overall quality will be determined using the "worst score counts" principle.
  • Data synthesis: Evaluating four key measurement properties (validity, reliability, internal consistency, feasibility) using updated COSMIN quality criteria. Evidence will be pooled or qualitatively summarized, and the quality of evidence will be graded using the GRADE approach.
  • Formulating recommendations: Classifying PROMs into categories (A, B, or C) based on the strength of evidence for their measurement properties, providing clear recommendations for their use.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper describes a protocol for a systematic review of existing literature, not the creation or use of new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The critical need for context-specific validation: The paper highlights that instruments developed in one setting may not perform well in another due to cultural and linguistic differences, underscoring the importance of contextually relevant validation.
  • The COSMIN framework as a gold standard: By adopting the COSMIN methodology, the review aims to bring a high level of rigor and standardization to the evaluation of IPV screening instruments, addressing the current uneven quality of research in this area.
  • Beyond psychometric properties: The importance of feasibility: The protocol explicitly includes feasibility as a crucial factor, recognizing that even a psychometrically sound instrument is useless if it's impractical to administer or unacceptable to participants.
  • Bridging the gap between research and practice: The ultimate goal is to provide actionable recommendations that empower researchers and practitioners to select the best tools for their specific needs, thereby improving IPV identification and intervention.

Key Results

As this is a protocol paper, no results from the systematic review itself are presented. The paper outlines the planned methodology and the expected outcomes, which include:

  • Identification and description of existing and validated IPV screening instruments.
  • Assessment of the methodological quality of studies evaluating these instruments.
  • Evaluation and comparison of the measurement properties (validity, reliability, internal consistency) and feasibility of these instruments.
  • Categorization of instruments based on the strength of evidence, leading to recommendations for their use.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Language bias: The review will be limited to studies published in English, potentially excluding relevant research from non-English speaking regions.
  • Exclusion of non-primary studies: Discussion papers, letters, editorials, and case studies will be excluded, which might miss valuable qualitative insights or preliminary findings.
  • Focus on measurement properties: While feasibility is considered, the primary focus remains on psychometric properties, and the depth of feasibility assessment might vary.

Future Work:

The systematic review itself is the future work proposed by this protocol. Upon completion, the findings will:

  • Provide a comprehensive overview of IPV screening instruments.
  • Offer evidence-based suggestions for researchers and practitioners on instrument selection.
  • Identify gaps in the existing research, potentially guiding future instrument development and validation studies.
  • Support improved screening for IPV victims, leading to better support and intervention.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intimate partner violence (IPV) is a major public health problem resulting in a significant impediment to equal participation, quality of life, and personal, social, and economic development. At present, a variety of screening instruments for IPV have emerged in developed countries, and some of them have been adapted to the language and culture of different countries, such as Hurt, Insult, Threaten, Scream (HITS) and the Abuse Assessment Screen (AAS). The selection of the most appropriate IPV screening instrument for the target population and context from among those instruments has become difficult for researchers when intending to start screening. Therefore, a systemic review of IPV screening instruments is needed. This protocol describes a COSMIN-based systematic review of the measurement properties of these instruments. The aims of the systematic review are to (1) evaluate the methodological quality of studies on the measurement properties including the validity, reliability, and internal consistency of these IPV screening instruments, and (2) provide suggestions for relevant researchers in their local context for using the IPV screening instruments.
BibTeX
@article{li2023intimate,
  author = {Yanjia Li and Keyi Zhou and Siyuan Tang and Jiarui Chen},
  title = {{Intimate Partner Violence Screening Instruments: A Protocol for a COSMIN-Based Systematic Review}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20021541},
}
Figure