Intersection of the Web-Based Vaping Narrative With COVID-19: Topic Modeling Study

Kamila Janmohamed, Abdul‐Nasah Soale, Laura Forastiere, Weiming Tang, Yongjie Sha, Jakob Demant, Edoardo M. Airoldi, Navin KumarJournal of Medical Internet Research 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study explores the evolution of online vaping discussions during the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. By analyzing over 4 million web documents using structural topic modeling, researchers identified a significant shift from concerns about lung injury and bans to a narrative promoting vape-administered CBD as a potential treatment or preventative measure for COVID-19. These findings highlight the rapid spread of health misinformation and the need for targeted public health interventions.

Introduction

The intersection of the vaping community and the COVID-19 pandemic created a unique environment for the proliferation of health misinformation. Prior to the pandemic, the online vaping narrative was largely defined by the 2019 e-cigarette or vaping use–associated lung injury (EVALI) crisis and subsequent regulatory bans. However, as COVID-19 spread globally, the conversation shifted. This study aimed to quantify these shifts and identify emerging themes that could impact public health.

Methodology: Structural Topic Modeling

To analyze the massive volume of "web-based chatter," researchers employed Structural Topic Modeling (STM). Unlike traditional clustering methods, STM incorporates document metadata—such as publication date and source type—to influence topic prevalence and word usage.

The dataset comprised 4,027,172 documents (over 361 million words) from approximately 200,000 domains, including blogs (86%), news articles (11%), and forums (3%). The timeline spanned from August 1, 2019, to April 21, 2020, with December 31, 2019, serving as the pivot point for the pandemic's emergence. The team utilized models with $k=15$ and $k=20$ topics to ensure semantic coherence, validated through qualitative coding of "exemplar" documents.

Key Findings: The Rise of the CBD "Cure"

The most striking result was the transition from a narrative of "Harms" to one of "Help."

From EVALI to Harm Reduction

Before COVID-19, the narrative was dominated by words like "ban," "lung," and "quit," reflecting the EVALI crisis. Post-emergence, a new archetype appeared: Vaping as Harm Reduction or Treatment. This shift suggests that the community pivoted from defensive discussions about health risks to proactive (though often inaccurate) discussions about health benefits.

The CBD Misinformation Narrative

A specific "CBD product preference" topic emerged after the pandemic began. Qualitative analysis revealed that 62% of the top-ranked posts in this category promoted vaping CBD as a way to prevent or treat COVID-19. Many of these claims suggested CBD could mitigate "cytokine storms," a dangerous immune response associated with severe COVID-19 cases. This narrative was not purely organic; it was significantly bolstered by marketing campaigns positioning cannabis products as "coronavirus prepping tools."

Word cloud illustrating the most prevalent terms in the web-based vaping narrative, highlighting the emergence of CBD-related topics.

Results and Discussion

The word prevalence shift was statistically significant. Mentions of "CBD" and "oil" spiked alongside positive-sentiment terms like "good" and "best." While core archetypes like "Vaping Lifestyle" and "Regulation" remained stable, the "Treatment" archetype was a structural addition to the landscape.

The density of misinformation within the CBD topic is particularly concerning. Medically unsubstantiated claims regarding COVID-19 prevention were prevalent in high-engagement documents, suggesting that vapers were being exposed to dangerous advice during a global health crisis. This highlights the "perfect storm" where marketing interests and public anxiety converge to promote unproven health claims.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study faced several limitations:

  • Geographic Data: The lack of location metadata prevented regional analysis of narrative variance.
  • Duration: The data only extended through April 2020, missing later evolutions of the pandemic narrative.
  • Behavioral Link: It remains unclear if these online narratives translated into real-world behavioral changes.

Future research should integrate survey data to bridge the gap between online sentiment and actual health behaviors. Furthermore, public health officials should consider mandating that vaping forums and platforms provide evidence-based information to counter misinformation in real-time.

Conclusion

The emergence of a vape-administered CBD treatment narrative during the COVID-19 pandemic underscores the agility of misinformation. Understanding these shifts is crucial for developing targeted interventions and ensuring that vulnerable populations receive accurate health information during crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our main finding is the emergence of a vape-administered CBD treatment narrative around COVID-19 when comparing the web-based vaping narratives before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. These results are key to understanding how vapers respond to inaccurate information about COVID-19, optimizing treatment of vapers who contract COVID-19, and possibly minimizing instances of inaccurate information. The findings have implications for the management of COVID-19 among vapers and the monitoring of web-based content pertinent to tobacco to develop targeted interventions to manage COVID-19 among vapers.
BibTeX
@article{janmohamed2020intersection,
  author = {Kamila Janmohamed and Abdul‐Nasah Soale and Laura Forastiere and Weiming Tang and Yongjie Sha and Jakob Demant and Edoardo M. Airoldi and Navin Kumar},
  title = {{Intersection of the Web-Based Vaping Narrative With COVID-19: Topic Modeling Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2196/21743},
}
Figure