Interrogating Metabolic Interactions Between Skeletal Muscle and Liver Circadian Clocks In Vivo

Jacob G. Smith, Kevin B. Koronowski, Tomoki Sato, Carolina M. Greco, Paul Petrus, Amandine Verlande, Siwei Chen, Muntaha Samad, Ekaterina Deyneka, Lavina Mathur, Ronnie Blazev, Jeffrey Molendijk, Thomas Mortimer, Arun Kumar, Oleg Deryagin, Mireia Vaca-Dempere, Peng Liu, Valerio Orlando, Benjamin L. Parker, Pierre Baldi, Patrick-Simon Welz, Cholsoon Jang, Selma Masri, Salvador Aznar Benitah, Pura Muñoz‐Cánoves, Paolo Sassone‐CorsibioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Our internal body clocks, particularly those in the liver and muscles, are crucial for maintaining metabolic health. This study reveals that while these clocks operate somewhat independently, they must communicate with each other, especially in response to feeding cues, to effectively regulate glucose metabolism and overall glucose tolerance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The body's circadian clock system is fundamental to daily metabolic homeostasis, and its disruption is linked to metabolic diseases like diabetes. While we know that clocks in various organs (brain, liver, muscle, etc.) contribute to glucose regulation, it's unclear which organs are most critical and how they coordinate their efforts. Specifically, this paper investigates the interplay between the liver and skeletal muscle clocks, exploring whether their communication is essential for maintaining healthy glucose levels, particularly in the context of feeding and fasting cycles.

Methods

The researchers utilized a sophisticated genetic approach involving Bmal1-stopFL mice. These mice allow for the precise "reconstitution" (restoration) of the Bmal1 gene, a key component of the circadian clock, in specific tissues. By crossing these mice with Cre-driver lines targeting the liver (Alfp-Cre) and skeletal muscle (Hsa-Cre), they created several experimental groups:

  • Wild-type (WT): All clocks functioning normally.
  • Full Bmal1 knockout (KO): No functional Bmal1 in any tissue.
  • Liver-RE: Bmal1 restored only in the liver.
  • Muscle-RE: Bmal1 restored only in skeletal muscle.
  • Liver+Muscle-RE: Bmal1 restored in both liver and muscle.

They employed a range of techniques to assess clock function and metabolic output:

  • Western blotting: To confirm the tissue-specific expression of BMAL1.
  • Metabolic cage studies: To measure body weight, food intake, and locomotor activity under different feeding conditions (ad libitum and night feeding).
  • RNA sequencing (RNA-seq): To analyze genome-wide gene expression patterns and identify rhythmic transcripts in liver and muscle.
  • JTK_CYCLE and BIO_CYCLE: Algorithms used to identify rhythmic gene expression.
  • Isotope tracing with 13C-labeled glucose: To track glucose metabolism and its conversion into other metabolites in liver and muscle.
  • Oral Glucose Tolerance Tests (OGTT): To assess the body's ability to clear glucose from the bloodstream.
  • qPCR: To measure the expression of specific clock and metabolic genes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on data generated from their own mouse models and experimental procedures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tissue-specific autonomy: Liver and muscle clocks can oscillate independently to some extent, but their autonomous capabilities are not fully sufficient for robust glucose homeostasis. The liver clock appears to be more autonomous than the muscle clock.
  • Inter-organ communication is key: The study strongly suggests that communication between the liver and muscle clocks is vital for effective glucose regulation.
  • Feeding rhythms are critical synchronizers: The presence of a daily feeding-fasting rhythm (specifically, night feeding in this study) is crucial for enabling a synergistic state between the liver and muscle clocks, leading to improved glucose tolerance.
  • Synergy for glucose tolerance: While individual liver or muscle clocks can partially restore some metabolic functions, it's the combination of both clocks plus the feeding rhythm that is required for glucose tolerance comparable to wild-type animals.
  • Muscle clock's role in feeding integration: The muscle clock, like the liver clock, can integrate feeding-fasting signals, influencing gene expression related to glucose metabolism.

Key Results

  • In the absence of feeding-fasting cycles, neither the liver nor the muscle clock alone was sufficient for systemic glucose metabolism or to establish functional connections influencing local rhythms.
  • When a daily feeding-fasting rhythm was introduced, the synergistic state between liver and muscle clocks restored systemic glucose tolerance.
  • Mice with only liver or only muscle clocks reconstituted showed impaired glucose tolerance compared to WT mice, even with feeding rhythms.
  • RNA-seq revealed that while the liver clock could restore a significant percentage of WT rhythmic transcripts, the muscle clock restored a much smaller proportion, highlighting its less robust autonomous output.
  • Isotope tracing showed that while individual clocks could partially rescue glucose metabolism defects in their respective tissues, the combination of both clocks did not offer further improvement under ad libitum feeding.
  • Oral glucose tolerance tests demonstrated that only when both liver and muscle clocks were present and under a night-feeding regimen did mice achieve glucose tolerance comparable to WT.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model limitations: The study acknowledges that the Bmal1 reconstitution models, while powerful, have limitations. The overall systemic metabolism is shaped by a mutant hypothalamus and other Bmal1-null metabolic organs, which might influence the interpretation of results.
  • Unidentified soluble factors: The exact molecular mechanisms by which liver and muscle clocks communicate, especially under feeding-fasting conditions, remain to be elucidated. The authors suggest that soluble factors might be involved.
  • Broader clock network: The study focuses on liver and muscle, but future work should explore the impact of other tissue clocks (e.g., pancreas) and the central clock in the hypothalamus on this axis.
  • Physiological and pathophysiological states: Further research is needed to understand how liver-muscle clock connections function under various physiological and disease conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Expressed throughout the body, the circadian clock system achieves daily metabolic homeostasis at every level of physiology, with clock disruption associated with metabolic disease ( 1 , 2 ). Molecular clocks present in the brain, liver, adipose, pancreas and skeletal muscle each contribute to glucose homeostasis ( 3 ). However, it is unclear; 1) which organ clocks provide the most essential contributions, and 2) if these contributions depend on inter-organ communication. We recently showed that the liver clock alone is insufficient for most aspects of daily liver glucose handling and requires connections with other clocks ( 4 ). Considering the pathways that link glucose metabolism between liver and skeletal muscle, we sought to test whether a clock connection along this axis is important. Using our previous published methodology for tissue-specific rescue of Bmal1 in vivo ( 4 , 5 ), we now show that in the absence of feeding-fasting cycles, liver and muscle clocks are not sufficient for systemic glucose metabolism, nor do they form a functional connection influencing local glucose handling or daily transcriptional rhythms in each tissue. However, the introduction of a daily feeding-fasting rhythm enables a synergistic state between liver and muscle clocks that leads to restoration of systemic glucose tolerance. These findings reveal limited autonomous capabilities of liver and muscle clocks and highlight the need for inter-organ clock communication for glucose homeostasis which involves at least two peripheral metabolic organs.
BibTeX
@misc{smith2022interrogating,
  author = {Jacob G. Smith and Kevin B. Koronowski and Tomoki Sato and Carolina M. Greco and Paul Petrus and Amandine Verlande and Siwei Chen and Muntaha Samad and Ekaterina Deyneka and Lavina Mathur and Ronnie Blazev and Jeffrey Molendijk and Thomas Mortimer and Arun Kumar and Oleg Deryagin and Mireia Vaca-Dempere and Peng Liu and Valerio Orlando and Benjamin L. Parker and Pierre Baldi and Patrick-Simon Welz and Cholsoon Jang and Selma Masri and Salvador Aznar Benitah and Pura Muñoz‐Cánoves and Paolo Sassone‐Corsi},
  title = {{Interrogating Metabolic Interactions Between Skeletal Muscle and Liver Circadian Clocks In Vivo}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.02.27.482160},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure