Interpreting Basis Path Set in Neural Networks

Juanping Zhu, Qi Meng, Wei Chen, Zhiming MaarXiv 2019 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the "black box" problem of understanding how basis paths contribute to the success of G-SGD in optimizing ReLU neural networks. By framing neural networks as graphs, the authors introduce a novel hierarchical algorithm (HBPS) to identify and represent these crucial basis paths, offering a new lens for interpreting network behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While G-SGD has shown superior performance in optimizing ReLU neural networks compared to standard SGD, the underlying reasons for this improvement remain unclear. Specifically, the "basis path set" concept, central to G-SGD, lacks a deep, interpretable understanding of its inner workings. This paper aims to demystify this by exploring the structural properties of basis paths within neural networks from a graph theory perspective, ultimately providing a method to identify and utilize these paths for better network interpretation and potentially optimization.

Methods

The authors approach neural networks as directed acyclic graphs. They define key graph-theoretic concepts like "basis path" and "basis path set." A core contribution is the proposed Hierarchical Algorithm HBPS for finding a basis path set in fully connected neural networks. HBPS operates in two levels:

  1. Upper Level (Inter-structure Independence): This level decomposes the neural network into independent substructures. It identifies "substructure paths" and uses numerical linear algebra to find a "maximal linearly independent substructure path set." This step ensures that the chosen substructures do not share edges, promoting independence.
  2. Lower Level (Intra-structure Basis Paths): For each identified independent substructure, a recursive subroutine is employed to find the basis path set within that substructure. This subroutine is designed for networks without edge skipping, building upon concepts of direct and cross paths.

The algorithm then combines the basis path sets from all independent substructures to form the overall basis path set for the entire network.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical definitions and algorithmic development for general neural network structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Neural Networks as Graphs: Viewing neural networks through the lens of graph theory provides a powerful framework for understanding their internal structure and operations.
  • Basis Paths as Fundamental Building Blocks: The concept of a "basis path set" is analogous to a basis in linear algebra, where a minimal set of paths can represent all other paths in the network.
  • Hierarchical Decomposition for Complexity: The HBPS algorithm's hierarchical approach effectively breaks down the complex problem of finding basis paths in a large network into more manageable sub-problems.
  • Inter-structure Independence is Crucial: The requirement that independent substructures do not share edges is key to ensuring that the basis paths identified are truly distinct and contribute unique structural information.
  • Interpretability Through Structure: By identifying basis paths, the paper offers a path towards understanding how neural networks learn and make decisions, moving beyond just input-output mappings.

Key Results

  • The paper formally defines "basis path" and "basis path set" within the context of graph theory applied to neural networks.
  • It proposes the Hierarchical Algorithm HBPS to find a basis path set in fully connected neural networks, particularly those with potential layer skipping.
  • A key theoretical result (Theorem 1) establishes that the cardinality of the basis path set found by HBPS is related to the number of edges and hidden nodes in the network and its substructures.
  • The algorithm is designed to handle networks with edge skipping, a common feature in modern neural architectures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Shared Layers Constraint: The current HBPS algorithm requires that independent substructures do not share layers. The authors suggest that extending the algorithm to handle shared layers would be a valuable future direction.
  • Generalization to Non-Fully Connected Networks: The current work focuses on fully connected networks. Future work could explore how to adapt these concepts to more complex, sparsely connected architectures.
  • Practical Application to Training: While the paper provides a theoretical framework for understanding basis paths, its direct application to improving G-SGD or other training algorithms is an area for further research. The paper hints at this by stating that "the weights on the paths in ReLU network [7] can be easily manipulated through the path operations within the basis path set."
  • Empirical Validation: The paper is primarily theoretical. Future work would benefit from empirical validation of the HBPS algorithm and its impact on network interpretability and performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on basis path set, G-SGD algorithm significantly outperforms conventional SGD algorithm in optimizing neural networks. However, how the inner mechanism of basis paths work remains mysterious. From the aspect of graph theory, this paper defines basis path, investigates structure properties of basis paths in regular fully connected neural network and interprets the graph representation of basis path set. Moreover, we propose hierarchical algorithm HBPS to find basis path set B in fully connected neural network by decomposing the network into several independent and parallel substructures. Algorithm HBPS demands that there doesn't exist shared edges between any two independent substructure paths.
BibTeX
@misc{zhu2019interpreting,
  author = {Juanping Zhu and Qi Meng and Wei Chen and Zhiming Ma},
  title = {{Interpreting Basis Path Set in Neural Networks}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1910.09402},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.09402},
}
Figure