Interplay of water and a supramolecular capsule for catalysis of reductive elimination reaction from gold

Valerie Vaissier Welborn, Wan‐Lu Li, Teresa Head‐GordonNature Communications 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have uncovered that the "secret sauce" behind the enzyme-like efficiency of a specific supramolecular nanocage ($Ga_4L_6^{12-}$) isn't just the cage itself, but a single encapsulated water molecule. This "guest" water generates precise electric fields that stabilize the transition state of a gold-based reductive elimination reaction, while the cage host "preconditions" the substrate to be more sensitive to these fields.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supramolecular assemblies—man-made "cages" that can hold other molecules—are the holy grail of synthetic chemistry because they can catalyze reactions with the speed and selectivity of natural enzymes. However, while we know they work, we often don't know why.

Specifically, this paper investigates the reductive elimination reaction from gold(III) complexes. In a laboratory setting, this reaction is slow. When tucked inside a $Ga_4L_6^{12-}$ nanocage, it speeds up by five orders of magnitude. The authors wanted to bridge the gap between experimental observation and physical understanding: Is the cage just a passive container, or is it actively manipulating the electronic environment? Furthermore, what role does the surrounding water play in this process?

Methods

The team used a suite of advanced computational tools to simulate the reaction in "explicit solvent" (meaning they modeled individual water molecules rather than a generic fluid):

  • Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD): Specifically, Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics, to simulate the real-time movement of atoms based on quantum mechanical forces.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT): They employed the B97M-V functional, a high-accuracy method well-validated for liquid water systems.
  • Metadynamics: A technique used to "push" the simulation out of local energy wells, allowing the researchers to map the entire free energy landscape and identify the transition state (the highest energy point on the path from reactants to products).
  • Committor Analysis: A statistical check to ensure the identified transition states were genuine.
  • Electric Field Projections: They calculated the electric fields generated by different parts of the system (the cage, the bulk water, and the internal water) and projected them onto the breaking chemical bonds to see which components were actually driving the catalysis.

Datasets

As a theoretical chemistry paper, the "datasets" consist of the generated trajectories and electronic structure data from the simulations:

  • Simulated Trajectories: Over 50ps of metadynamics for both catalyzed and uncatalyzed pathways.
  • Structural Snapshots: 200 structures for the reactant state and approximately 45 geometries for each transition state ensemble.
  • Reference Data: Comparison against previously published experimental rate constants and X-ray resolved structures of the $Ga_4L_6^{12-}$ assembly.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Catalytic Moiety" is Water: Surprisingly, the nanocage doesn't just rely on host-guest interactions. Instead, it traps a "primary" water molecule alongside the substrate. This internal water molecule generates an electric field that aligns perfectly with the breaking gold-carbon bonds, lowering the energy barrier.
  • Preconditioning the Substrate: The cage acts like a specialized "mold." It forces the gold complex into a geometry (the transition state) that is significantly more sensitive to electric fields than it would be in bulk solution.
  • The "Bad" Interfacial Water: Unlike natural enzymes, which have evolved scaffolds to organize surrounding water into helpful patterns, this synthetic nanocage is somewhat messy. The water molecules just outside the cage (interfacial water) actually create electric fields that oppose the reaction.
  • Electrostatic Dominance: Roughly 5 kcal/mol of the total 9 kcal/mol stabilization comes purely from electrostatic effects, highlighting the importance of "electrostatic preorganization" in catalyst design.

Key Results

  • Barrier Reduction: The activation free energy barrier was reduced from 33 kcal/mol (uncatalyzed) to 24 kcal/mol (catalyzed).
  • Rate Acceleration: This ~9 kcal/mol drop corresponds to a theoretical rate acceleration of 3.3 x $10^7$, which is in good agreement with experimental observations ($10^5$ to $10^6$).
  • Electric Field Impact: In the catalyzed transition state, the internal "complexed" water provides a stabilizing electric field, while the bulk water provides a destabilizing one. The cage's net effect is to provide a microenvironment where the "good" internal water can outweigh the "bad" external water.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify a few areas for improvement:

  • Solvent Complexity: The simulations used pure water, whereas experiments often use a methanol/water mix. Methanol is less polarizable, which might slightly alter the electrostatic interactions.
  • Scaffold Design: The finding that interfacial water is "detrimental" suggests a massive opportunity for future design. If researchers can redesign the exterior of the nanocage to better organize the surrounding solvent (similar to how enzymes do), they could potentially achieve even higher catalytic efficiencies.
  • Theory Limits: While B97M-V is robust, the quantitative accuracy of Transition State Theory (TST) can sometimes be limited by dynamical effects not fully captured in these models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Supramolecular assemblies have gained tremendous attention due to their ability to catalyze reactions with the efficiencies of natural enzymes. Using ab initio molecular dynamics, we identify the origin of the catalysis by the supramolecular capsule Ga<sub>4</sub>L<sub>6</sub><sup>12-</sup> on the reductive elimination reaction from gold complexes and assess their similarity to natural enzymes. By comparing the free energies of the reactants and transition states for the catalyzed and uncatalyzed reactions, we determine that an encapsulated water molecule generates electric fields that contributes the most to the reduction in the activation free energy. Although this is unlike the biomimetic scenario of catalysis through direct host-guest interactions, the electric fields from the nanocage also supports the transition state to complete the reductive elimination reaction with greater catalytic efficiency. However it is also shown that the nanocage poorly organizes the interfacial water, which in turn creates electric fields that misalign with the breaking bonds of the substrate, thus identifying new opportunities for catalytic design improvements in nanocage assemblies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{welborn2020interplay,
  author = {Valerie Vaissier Welborn and Wan‐Lu Li and Teresa Head‐Gordon},
  title = {{Interplay of water and a supramolecular capsule for catalysis of reductive elimination reaction from gold}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-14251-6},
}
Figure