Interplay of Quasi-Quantum Hall Effect and Coulomb Disorder in Semimetals

Ian A. Leahy, Anthony D. Rice, Jocienne N. Nelson, Hervé Ness, Mark van Schilfgaarde, Wei Pan, Kirstin Alberi, Pan, Wei, Alberi, KirstinarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Low carrier densities in topological semimetals (TSMs) enable the exploration of novel magnetotransport in the quantum limit (QL). Recent findings consistent with 3D quasi-quantum Hall effect (QQHE) have positioned TSMs as promising platforms for exploring 3D quantum Hall transport, but the lack of tunability in the Fermi level has thus far limited the ability to observe a QQHE signal. Here, we tune the defect concentrations in the Dirac semimetal Cd${}_3$As${}_2$ to achieve ultra-low carrier concentrations at 2 K around $2.9\times10^{16}$cm${}^{-3}$, giving way to QQHE signal at modest fields near 10 T. At low carrier densities, where QQHE is most accessible, we find that clear QQHE is obscured by a carrier density dependent background originating from Coulomb disorder from charged point defects and Landau level broadening. Our results highlight the interplay between QQHE and Coulomb disorder, demonstrating that clear observation of QQHE in TSMs intricately depends on Fermi level and disorder magnitudes. We find that Coulomb disorder, as theoretically predicted, is an essential ingredient for understanding the magnetoresistivity for a spectrum of Fermi levels in Cd${}_3$As${}_2$, anchoring the role of defects and charged disorder in TSM applications. We discuss future constraints and opportunities in exploring 3D QQHE and quantum Hall effects in TSMs.

Introduction: The Challenge of 3D Quantum Hall Transport

In two-dimensional electronic systems, the Quantum Hall Effect (QHE) is characterized by robustly quantized Hall resistance plateaus and vanishing longitudinal resistance. Extending this phenomenon to three dimensions is fundamentally challenging. Unlike 2D systems with discrete energy levels, 3D semimetals possess "Landau bands" that disperse along the direction of the magnetic field (Fig. 1c). This dispersion typically prevents the formation of a clean energy gap.

The Quasi-Quantum Hall Effect (QQHE) is the 3D counterpart where plateaus appear but are neither perfectly quantized nor dissipationless. Observing QQHE requires reaching the "Quantum Limit" (QL), where only the lowest Landau band is occupied. This state is accessible through either extremely high magnetic fields or ultra-low carrier densities.

Conceptual comparison of 2D and 3D Landau levels and the effect of disorder on transport signatures.

Methodology: Tuning Carrier Density in Cd$_3$As$_2$

Researchers utilized Molecular Beam Epitaxy (MBE) to grow high-quality thin films of the Dirac semimetal Cd$_3$As$_2$. By precisely controlling defect concentrations during synthesis, they achieved carrier densities as low as $2.9 \times 10^{16} cm^{-3}$, representing some of the lowest values reported for this material.

Magnetotransport measurements of resistivity ($\rho_{xx}$) and Hall resistivity ($\rho_{xy}$) were conducted at 2 K in magnetic fields up to 30 T. To interpret the results, the team combined an 8-band $k \cdot p$ electronic structure model with an empirical scattering model designed to isolate the topological QQHE signal from background noise caused by Coulomb disorder—scattering from charged point defects like vacancies.

Results: The Screening Trade-off

The study reveals a critical "catch-22" in semimetal physics: the screening trade-off. In these materials, mobile electrons screen the electric fields of charged defects. Reducing carrier density to reach the Quantum Limit simultaneously weakens this screening. Consequently, the Coulomb disorder potential ($eV_0$) increases relative to the Fermi energy ($E_F$), broadening the Landau bands and smearing the QQHE plateaus (Fig. 1d).

Experimental data from samples A through D (Fig. 5) demonstrate this transition. In the lowest-density sample (Sample A, $2.9 \times 10^{16} cm^{-3}$), the QQHE signal is present but heavily obscured by a large, density-dependent background. As carrier density increases (e.g., Sample D, $9.3 \times 10^{16} cm^{-3}$), the background diminishes, revealing clearer QQHE signatures—kinks in $\rho_{xy}$ and corresponding features in $\rho_{xx}$—at fields near 10 T.

Magnetoresistivity and Hall resistivity for samples A-D, illustrating the obscuration of QQHE by Coulomb disorder at low carrier densities.

The researchers noted that in clean systems, a scaling relation $\rho_{xx} \propto H \partial_H \rho_{xy}$ is expected; however, as carrier density drops, this relation breaks down as the disorder background begins to dominate. The total magnetoresistivity was found to be a superposition of the topological QQHE signal and a background from Coulomb scattering. Mapping the disorder potential strength ($eV_0$) against $E_F$ (Fig. 5j) shows that Cd$_3$As$_2$ resides in a regime of higher disorder compared to other materials like ZrTe$_5$, explaining its historically "messier" quantum signatures.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work establishes that Coulomb disorder is an essential factor in understanding the magnetotransport of topological semimetals. While the researchers successfully observed and modeled the QQHE, the inherent disorder at low densities currently prevents the realization of a "true," perfectly quantized 3D QHE.

Future efforts will focus on defect engineering to passivate charged centers and the use of electrostatic gating. Gating would allow for tuning the Fermi level within a single sample, providing a cleaner method to isolate the effects of disorder from the underlying topological physics. These advancements may eventually reveal hidden correlated bulk states or surface-mediated 3D QHE.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low carrier densities in topological semimetals (TSMs) enable the exploration of novel magnetotransport in the quantum limit (QL). Recent findings consistent with 3D quasi-quantum Hall effect (QQHE) have positioned TSMs as promising platforms for exploring 3D quantum Hall transport, but the lack of tunability in the Fermi level has thus far limited the ability to observe a QQHE signal. Here, we tune the defect concentrations in the Dirac semimetal Cd${}_3$As${}_2$ to achieve ultra-low carrier concentrations at 2 K around $2.9\times10^{16}$cm${}^{-3}$, giving way to QQHE signal at modest fields near 10 T. At low carrier densities, where QQHE is most accessible, we find that clear QQHE is obscured by a carrier density dependent background originating from Coulomb disorder from charged point defects and Landau level broadening. Our results highlight the interplay between QQHE and Coulomb disorder, demonstrating that clear observation of QQHE in TSMs intricately depends on Fermi level and disorder magnitudes. We find that Coulomb disorder, as theoretically predicted, is an essential ingredient for understanding the magnetoresistivity for a spectrum of Fermi levels in Cd${}_3$As${}_2$, anchoring the role of defects and charged disorder in TSM applications. We discuss future constraints and opportunities in exploring 3D QQHE and quantum Hall effects in TSMs.
BibTeX
@misc{leahy2024interplay,
  author = {Ian A. Leahy and Anthony D. Rice and Jocienne N. Nelson and Hervé Ness and Mark van Schilfgaarde and Wei Pan and Kirstin Alberi and Pan, Wei and Alberi, Kirstin},
  title = {{Interplay of Quasi-Quantum Hall Effect and Coulomb Disorder in Semimetals}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2412.05273},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.05273},
}
Figure