Interoperable vocabulary for marine microbial flow cytometry

Mélilotus Thyssen, Gérald Grégori, Véronique Créach, Soumaya Lahbib, Mathilde Dugenne, Hedy M. Aardema, Luis-Felipe Artigas, Bangqin Huang, Aude Barani, Laureen Beaugeard, Amel Bellaaj Zouari, Alfred Beran, Raffaella Casotti, Yolanda Del Amo, Michel Denis, G. B. J. Dubelaar, Sonja Endres, Lumi Haraguchi, Bengt Karlson, Christophe Lambert, Arnaud Louchart, Dominique Marie, Gwenaëlle Moncoiffé, D. Pecqueur, François Ribalet, M. Rijkeboer, Tina Šilović, Ricardo Silva, Sophie Marro, Heidi M. Sosik, Marc Sourisseau, Glen A. Tarran, Nicolas Van Oostende, Li Zhao, Shan ZhengFrontiers in Marine Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a standardized, consensus-based vocabulary for the 13 most common marine microbial groups identified via flow cytometry (FCM). By providing a logic-based decision tree and machine-readable identifiers, the authors aim to transform fragmented oceanographic data into a "FAIR" (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable) global resource for climate and ecosystem modeling.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine microorganisms—from tiny Prochlorococcus to larger nanophytoplankton—are the engines of the ocean’s biogeochemical cycles, producing half the Earth's oxygen and forming the base of the food web. Since the 1980s, Flow Cytometry (FCM) has been the gold standard for studying these cells at a single-cell level, recording their light-scattering and fluorescence properties in real-time.

However, the field has long suffered from a "Tower of Babel" problem. Because different researchers use different instrument settings and naming conventions, one lab’s "picoeukaryote" might be another’s "RedPico." This lack of standardization makes it nearly impossible to combine datasets from different cruises or decades to perform large-scale global analyses. As autonomous sensors begin to generate massive amounts of data, the need for a machine-readable, interoperable language has become critical.

Methods

The authors developed a consensus framework through extensive consultation with FCM experts and a literature review spanning 1983–2020. Key components include:

  • Consensus Vocabulary: A list of 13 microbial groups defined by their optical signatures (e.g., chlorophyll-a red fluorescence, phycoerythrin orange fluorescence, and light scatter).
  • Standardized Cytograms: A common layout for 2D log-transformed plots to visualize cell populations consistently.
  • Classification Decision Tree: A logic-based flow (Figure 2 in the paper) that guides researchers through the identification process based on specific fluorescence and scattering thresholds.
  • Technical Governance: The vocabulary is hosted on the NERC Vocabulary Server (NVS) using the Simple Knowledge Organization System (SKOS). Each term is assigned a unique, permanent URI (Uniform Resource Identifier), making the definitions machine-readable and "future-proof."

Datasets

While the paper does not introduce a new biological dataset, it is built upon:

  • Annex 1 (Supplementary Material): A comprehensive extraction of terms and group definitions from the literature between 1983 and 2020.
  • Reference Standards: The use of 3 µm silica beads as a standardized internal proxy to separate "pico" (< 2–3 µm) from "nano" (3–20 µm) size classes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Moving Beyond Taxonomy: The paper acknowledges that FCM rarely provides true species-level taxonomy. Instead, it focuses on Functional Groups, which are often more relevant for ecological modeling than precise species names.
  • The 3µm Pivot: Traditionally, the "pico-nano" cutoff was defined by 2 µm filters. The authors advocate for using 3 µm silica beads as a more robust optical standard, as cell size can fluctuate significantly during the cell cycle.
  • FAIRification is a Social Process: The authors emphasize that technical standards are useless without community buy-in. By hosting the vocabulary on GitHub and the NVS, they allow for transparent, community-driven updates.
  • Relative vs. Absolute: Because FCM light units are arbitrary and vary by instrument, the vocabulary relies on the relative positions of groups on a cytogram rather than absolute numerical values.

Key Results

  • The "Look-up Table" (Table 1): Provides a definitive map between common "jargon" terms (like Syn or HNA) and standardized labels (like OraPicoProk or HetHNA).
  • Machine-Readability: Every group is now linked to a URI (e.g., SDN:F02::F0200002 for RedPicoProk). This allows data repositories to automatically cross-reference datasets.
  • The Decision Tree: Provides a standardized "if-then" logic for classifying particles, which is essential for training future machine learning and convolutional neural network (CNN) models for automated ocean monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Instrument Variability: The authors admit that while the relative positions of groups are consistent, the absolute "brightness" of a cell depends heavily on instrument settings and laser power.
  • Excluded Groups: This initial vocabulary excludes viruses and microzooplankton, as they are not yet routinely analyzed using the specific automated, unstained methods discussed here.
  • The "Expert" Gap: While the decision tree helps, some groups (like those with overlapping fluorescence) still require expert manual "gating."
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest expanding the vocabulary to include imaging-in-flow data (which adds cell shape/morphology) and more complex staining protocols for heterotrophic organisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent development of biological sensors has extended marine plankton studies from conducting laboratory bench work to in vivo and real-time observations. Flow cytometry (FCM) has shed new light on marine microorganisms since the 1980s through its single-cell approach and robust detection of the smallest cells. FCM records valuable optical properties of light scattering and fluorescence from cells passing in a single file in front of a narrow-collimated light source, recording tens of thousands of cells within a few minutes. Depending on the instrument settings, the sampling strategy, and the automation level, it resolves the spatial and temporal distribution of microbial marine prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Cells are usually classified and grouped on cytograms by experts and are still lacking standards, reducing data sharing capacities. Therefore, the need to make FCM data sets FAIR (Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reusability of digital assets) is becoming critical. In this paper, we present a consensus vocabulary for the 13 most common marine microbial groups observed with FCM using blue and red-light excitation. The authors designed a common layout on two-dimensional log-transformed cytograms reinforced by a decision tree that facilitates the characterization of groups. The proposed vocabulary aims at standardising data analysis and definitions, to promote harmonisation and comparison of data between users and instruments. This represents a much-needed step towards FAIRification of flow cytometric data collected in various marine environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thyssen2022interoperable,
  author = {Mélilotus Thyssen and Gérald Grégori and Véronique Créach and Soumaya Lahbib and Mathilde Dugenne and Hedy M. Aardema and Luis-Felipe Artigas and Bangqin Huang and Aude Barani and Laureen Beaugeard and Amel Bellaaj Zouari and Alfred Beran and Raffaella Casotti and Yolanda Del Amo and Michel Denis and G. B. J. Dubelaar and Sonja Endres and Lumi Haraguchi and Bengt Karlson and Christophe Lambert and Arnaud Louchart and Dominique Marie and Gwenaëlle Moncoiffé and D. Pecqueur and François Ribalet and M. Rijkeboer and Tina Šilović and Ricardo Silva and Sophie Marro and Heidi M. Sosik and Marc Sourisseau and Glen A. Tarran and Nicolas Van Oostende and Li Zhao and Shan Zheng},
  title = {{Interoperable vocabulary for marine microbial flow cytometry}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2022.975877},
}
Figure