Internet Use, Subjective Well-Being, and Environmentally Friendly Practices in Rural China: An Empirical Analysis

Shuo Lei, Lu Zhang, Chunfei Hou, Yongwei HanSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how internet use, subjective well-being (SWB), and environmentally friendly agricultural practices (EAPs) interact among rural Chinese farmers. It reveals that while internet access generally encourages EAPs, the way farmers use the internet and their overall well-being significantly mediate this relationship, with potential for both positive and negative outcomes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agriculture is a major contributor to environmental degradation, and China, with its vast agricultural sector, faces significant sustainability challenges. Adopting environmentally friendly agricultural practices (EAPs) is crucial for mitigating issues like nonpoint source pollution. However, farmer adoption of EAPs is influenced by more than just policy; their attitudes and well-being play a key role. While the impact of internet use on subjective well-being (SWB) and on EAPs has been studied separately, the complex interplay between internet use, SWB, and EAPs, particularly in rural contexts, remains underexplored. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing the direct and indirect effects of internet use on EAPs, mediated by SWB, among rural Chinese farmers.

Methods

The researchers employed Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze the complex relationships between internet use, SWB, and EAPs. SEM is a statistical technique that allows for the examination of both direct and indirect effects between multiple variables simultaneously. They used a recursive equation system to model these pathways. For parameter estimation, they utilized Maximum Likelihood (ML) estimation, a robust method for handling missing data and estimating model parameters. The analysis was conducted using StataCorp Stata MP 16.0 software.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the China Rural Revitalization Survey (CRRS), a nationwide, large-scale rural tracking survey conducted in 2020 by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. This survey is notable for encompassing internet use and EAPs of farmers, which is a key differentiator from other available datasets. The CRRS data covered 10 provinces, 50 counties, and 156 townships, with a final sample of 3833 rural households.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nuanced Impact of Internet Access: Simply having internet access (IA) generally encourages EAPs, particularly those that might lead to output loss (EAPOs) or require more time (EAPTs). This suggests farmers are willing to make trade-offs for environmental benefits when connected.
  • The Double-Edged Sword of Internet Function Utilization (IFU): While IA is broadly positive, how farmers use the internet matters. Increased utilization of various internet functions (IFU) negatively impacts EAPs involving additional expenses (EAPEs). This could be due to exposure to negative information or a greater focus on cost-sensitive economic activities online.
  • SWB as a Mediator: Subjective well-being (SWB) acts as a crucial intermediary. Higher general life satisfaction and happiness are linked to increased adoption of EAPs, suggesting that a positive outlook fosters pro-environmental behavior.
  • Income Satisfaction's Complex Role: Income satisfaction has a mixed effect. It encourages EAPOs (farmers less worried about output loss), but paradoxically, it can decrease EAPEs and EAPTs. This might indicate that farmers with higher income satisfaction are more sensitive to production costs and time investments.
  • The Internet's U-Shaped Effect on SWB: Internet use initially boosts SWB but can later decline it with increased usage. This is attributed to exposure to negative information, social comparison, and potential addiction, which can lead to feelings of anxiety and depression. This decline in SWB can, in turn, negatively affect EAP adoption.
  • Demographic Factors Matter: Younger, more educated individuals, and members of the Communist Party of China (CPC) are more likely to adopt EAPs. This highlights the importance of targeted education and outreach.

Key Results

  • IA and EAPOs/EAPTs: Farmers with improved IA adopted more EAPOs (H1a validated) and EAPTs (H1c validated).
  • IFU and EAPEs: Farmers with greater IFU adopted fewer EAPEs (H2b validated).
  • SWB and EAPEs/EAPTs: Farmers with higher general life satisfaction adopted more EAPEs (H3b validated), while those with higher living environment satisfaction and happiness adopted more EAPTs (H5c and H6c validated).
  • Internet Use and SWB: Both improved IA (H7a-d validated) and greater IFU (H8a-d validated) positively impacted all measures of SWB.
  • Indirect Effects: IA had a significant positive indirect effect on EAPTs. IFU had a negative indirect effect on EAPEs, and a negative impact on SWB (specifically income satisfaction) indirectly led to a negative total effect on EAPTs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Emotional Cognition Measurement: The study's indicators and data from public databases may overlook nuanced emotional cognition when measuring SWB.
  • Model Fit vs. Perfection: While the model achieved a perfect fit, this was partly due to a lack of redundant degrees of freedom, not necessarily implying the model was perfect.
  • Continuous Variables: Building a more robust model using continuous variables would be beneficial for further validation.
  • Pre-COVID Data: The data was collected before the COVID-19 pandemic. Future research should investigate how the pandemic has impacted the relationship between internet use, SWB, and EAPs.

They suggest future work should focus on developing more robust models and exploring the impact of recent events like the COVID-19 pandemic. They also emphasize the need for targeted education and leveraging internet tools like e-commerce and microcredit to incentivize EAP adoption, especially for cost-sensitive farmers.

Summary updated

Abstract

Expanding internet connectivity to rural areas requires a comprehensive understanding of the influence path among internet usage, subjective well-being (SWB), and environmentally friendly agricultural practices (EAPs) of farmers. This study aimed to analyze the direct and indirect effects of internet use by employing structural equation modeling. Farmers with improved internet access adopted more EAPs, resulting in output loss (EAPOs) and increased time investment (EAPTs). However, increased internet function utilization negatively affected EAPs involving additional expenses (EAPEs). Although SWB increased EAP engagement, income satisfaction could decrease EAPEs and EAPTs. The impact of internet use on SWB initially increased but later declined with increased internet usage, indirectly affecting EAPs. This may strengthen the positive total effect or alleviate the negative total effect. Young individuals, higher-income households, educated individuals, and members of the Communist Party of China (CPC) were more inclined to adopt EAPs, as they helped mitigate the adverse influence of negative online information and enhance overall well-being. Consequently, it is imperative to provide internet usage education and training, utilize more internet features, including e-commerce or microcredit, to incentivize EAP adoption, address and alleviate negative emotions from the internet promptly, prioritize providing education to young rural residents, and empower CPC members in advocating for sustainable practices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2023internet,
  author = {Shuo Lei and Lu Zhang and Chunfei Hou and Yongwei Han},
  title = {{Internet Use, Subjective Well-Being, and Environmentally Friendly Practices in Rural China: An Empirical Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151410925},
}
Figure