TL;DR
This paper analyzes global technological progress from 1980-2011 using US patent citation data. It reveals that emerging Asian economies like Korea and Taiwan have significantly improved both their patent quality and their speed of adopting new technologies, while advanced economies like Europe and Japan have seen a decline. The US, meanwhile, has strengthened its leading position.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the challenge of accurately measuring and comparing technological progress across countries over time. While patenting activity has surged globally, concerns exist about the actual substance and quality of these patents. Traditional methods often struggle with country-specific biases and the dynamic nature of patenting practices. This study aims to provide a rigorous international comparison of innovation quality and the speed of technological diffusion, using patent citations as a key indicator.
Methods
The authors employ a difference-in-differences (DiD) estimation strategy to compare the patent quality of non-US inventors to that of US inventors across three decades (1980s, 1990s, 2000s). This method helps control for country-wide heterogeneity and the time-varying nature of USPTO practices. To measure patent quality, they use the logarithm of "average citations" received within two years of a patent's grant date. They also develop an "adjusted average citations" measure to mitigate potential biases from patent size and "home bias" (where US patents might be cited more due to their origin in the USPTO).
For measuring the speed of technological diffusion, they analyze "citation lags." This involves treating US patents as the technological frontier and measuring how quickly non-US inventors cite these frontier patents relative to US inventors. They use a fixed-effects estimator, similar to Griffith et al. (2011), to model the hazard function of citation lags.
Datasets
The primary dataset used is USPTO patent citation data from January 1980 to December 2011. This data was compiled from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) US Patent Citations Data Files (PAT63_99 and CITE75_99) and augmented with data from Bronwyn Hall and direct extraction from USPTO for the later period. The analysis focuses on the top 15 countries by patent grants, including the US, Japan, Germany, EU, France, UK, Taiwan, Korea, Canada, Switzerland, Australia, Israel, China, India, and Former Soviet Union states.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Emerging Economies' Rise: The most striking finding is the rapid catch-up of emerging Asian economies, particularly Korea and Taiwan, in patent quality and their ability to adopt new technologies faster.
- Diverging Paths: While some nations are advancing, others are falling behind. Advanced economies like Europe and Japan are showing a decline in patent quality relative to the US.
- US Strength: The US has not only maintained its leading position but has actually strengthened it, outperforming many countries that were once close competitors.
- China's Unique Trajectory: China shows significant improvement in patent quality but has not yet reduced its citation lag, suggesting a different path of technological development compared to Korea and Taiwan.
- "Death of Distance" Nuance: While improved communication technology might generally reduce citation lags, the study highlights that the closing of these lags is not uniform and depends on a country's absorptive capacity.
Key Results
- Patent Quality:
- Korea and Taiwan caught up with US patent quality in the 1990s, and China in the 2000s.
- Advanced economies (Europe, Japan) experienced a steady decline in patent quality relative to the US.
- The US strengthened its relative patent quality position over the period.
- Citation Lags (Speed of Technology Adoption):
- Korea, Taiwan, and Israel made significant gains in narrowing citation lags, catching up with and even surpassing Japan.
- Japan, Germany, and EU maintained relatively stable citation lags, staying close to the US frontier.
- China's citation lag did not improve significantly in the last decade.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that using USPTO patent data might introduce a bias in favor of US patents. However, they argue that their use of relative measures and adjusted citation rates mitigates this. They suggest future research could:
- Analyze data from other major patent offices (e.g., EU) to provide a broader perspective.
- Explore alternative measures of patent quality, such as market value, which can be influenced by factors beyond citations (e.g., patent portfolios).
- Investigate the sources of technological progress, such as R&D expenditure and higher education, to explain the observed cross-country variations.
- Examine trends in overall technological progress beyond patenting activity, as not all industries rely equally on patents.
Summary updated