TL;DR
This paper provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of 457 research articles on school travel behavior published between 1996 and 2021. It maps the research landscape, identifying key countries, journals, and thematic clusters, and highlights the significant influence of individual, family, and built environment factors on students' travel choices, offering insights for sustainable urban transport policies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The increasing phenomenon of urban sprawl has led to longer commutes for students, contributing to a decline in active transportation (walking and cycling) to school. This shift has significant implications for urban traffic congestion, public health (e.g., childhood obesity), and environmental sustainability. While numerous studies exist, a consolidated, systematic overview of the research progress, trends, and key findings in school travel behavior is lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by providing a bibliometric analysis to understand the evolution, current state, and future directions of this research field.
Methods
The study employs a bibliometric analysis approach, following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. This involved:
- Data Collection: Searching four major databases (Web of Science, ScienceDirect, TRID, and MEDLINE) for relevant literature.
- Search Strategy: Using a combination of keywords related to students (e.g., "students," "children") and school travel (e.g., "school travel," "mode choice").
- Inclusion Criteria: Selecting peer-reviewed English journals and conference papers published between 1996 and 2021, focusing on transportation and school travel behavior for elementary, middle, and high school students.
- Bibliometric Analysis: Utilizing descriptive statistics and network analysis techniques. Specifically, VOSviewer software was used to analyze:
- Annual publication trends: To understand the growth of research over time.
- Country and regional performance: To identify leading research contributors.
- Journal characteristics: To pinpoint key publication outlets.
- Keyword co-occurrence: To identify research hotspots and themes.
- Co-citation analysis: To map the intellectual structure and influential works within the field.
Datasets
The study utilized data from four academic databases:
- Web of Science
- ScienceDirect
- TRID (Transport Research International Documentation)
- MEDLINE
A total of 457 relevant studies were selected for analysis. The paper does not introduce any new datasets or benchmarks.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Active Travel" Shift: Research has increasingly focused on "active travel to school" since 2014, emphasizing students' physical activity and health, moving beyond just mode choice.
- The Dominance of Developed Nations: The US, Canada, and Australia are leading in school travel research, indicating a mature research landscape in these regions.
- The Interconnectedness of Factors: School travel mode choice is not driven by a single factor but is a complex interplay of individual characteristics, family conditions, social status, and the built environment.
- Built Environment's Crucial Role: The physical environment, including urban form, street connectivity, and proximity to schools, significantly influences the likelihood of active travel.
- Parental Influence is Key, but Children's Voices Matter: While parents are primary decision-makers, qualitative research suggests children's preferences and feedback are increasingly being considered.
- COVID-19's Potential Impact: The pandemic may have exacerbated the decline in active travel, with concerns about a reversal of positive trends.
Key Results
- Publication Trends: Research on school travel has seen a steady increase, with a rapid growth phase observed from 2008 to 2021.
- Productive Countries: The top three countries in terms of publications are the USA (59 papers), Canada (41 papers), and Australia (24 papers).
- Key Journals: The "Journal of Transport & Health" is the primary source for school travel research, followed by the "Journal of Transport Geography."
- Research Themes (Keywords): Three main clusters emerged:
- Walking to school: Influenced by city design and family factors.
- Active travel and health: The relationship between physical activity and student well-being.
- Built environment and safety: The impact of the physical environment on school behavior and safety.
- Co-citation Analysis: Identified three clusters:
- School travel mode choice factors.
- Active travel to school.
- School travel behavior and student health/route safety.
- Highly Cited Articles: Primarily focus on school travel mode choice, active travel, and the influence of family interactions.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * The analysis relied on data from four databases, potentially missing relevant literature. * A formal risk-of-bias assessment was not conducted. * Retrieval bias and language bias (focusing only on English) may have introduced errors. * Keywords in articles were sometimes non-standardized, and citation counts can be problematic due to varying citation practices and time-dependent increases.
Future Work: * Comparative Studies: Strengthen comparative research on school travel behavior between developing and developed countries, exploring cultural differences and the impact of rapid urbanization and Transit-Oriented Development (TOD). * Theoretical Frameworks: Develop comprehensive theoretical frameworks to integrate the various factors influencing school travel behavior, moving beyond single-factor analyses. * Methodological Advancements: Explore more sophisticated analytical methods like structural equation modeling and discrete choice models to better understand complex relationships. * Policy Integration: Translate theoretical research into practical policies for school planning, promoting sustainable transport, and enhancing infrastructure sustainability and school route safety. * Developing Countries: Focus research efforts on understanding school travel behavior in developing countries, which are often in a rapid urbanization phase.
Summary updated