Internal Regret with Partial Monitoring: Calibration-Based Optimal Algorithms

Vianney PerchetJMLR 2011 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel algorithms for sequential decision-making under partial monitoring, where outcomes are not directly observed but inferred from noisy signals. The key innovation is a generalized "calibration" approach using Laguerre diagrams, leading to algorithms that achieve optimal regret bounds of $O(n^{-1/3})$ for both internal and external regret, a significant improvement over previous methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, decision-makers don't have complete information about the consequences of their actions. This is known as "partial monitoring," where instead of observing the direct outcome, they receive random feedback signals. The challenge is to make optimal decisions and minimize "regret" (the difference between the payoff achieved and the best possible payoff) in such an uncertain environment. Traditional regret minimization algorithms often assume full observability. This paper tackles the problem of achieving optimal regret bounds in the more complex partial monitoring setting, specifically focusing on "internal regret," which considers whether a chosen strategy could have been improved by sticking to a different fixed strategy on the stages where it was actually employed.

Methods

The authors propose new algorithms based on a generalization of "calibration." Calibration, in this context, is a technique that ensures predictions are statistically consistent with observations. They move beyond the standard Voronoi diagrams to a more general concept called Laguerre diagrams. This allows them to define and construct algorithms that achieve optimal regret bounds. The core idea involves:

  • Laguerre Diagrams: Generalizing Voronoi diagrams to create a more refined partitioning of the decision space, which is crucial for handling the complexities of partial monitoring.
  • Calibration-Based Algorithms: Constructing strategies that are "calibrated" with respect to these Laguerre diagrams. This means that when the algorithm predicts a certain outcome distribution, the actual observed signals are statistically close to that prediction.
  • Optimal Regret Bounds: The proposed algorithms are shown to achieve $O(n^{-1/3})$ bounds for both internal and external regret, which is theoretically optimal for this class of problems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithm development and analysis rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Laguerre Diagrams as a Powerful Tool: The generalization from Voronoi to Laguerre diagrams is a key insight, providing a more flexible and powerful framework for partitioning the signal space in partial monitoring problems. This allows for finer-grained analysis and better regret bounds.
  • Bridging Full and Partial Monitoring: The paper demonstrates how techniques developed for full monitoring (like calibration) can be adapted and generalized to the more challenging partial monitoring setting, achieving optimal results.
  • Simultaneous Optimal Regret: Achieving optimal bounds for both internal and external regret simultaneously is a significant theoretical contribution, as previous work often focused on one or the other, or achieved suboptimal bounds.
  • Computational Complexity Trade-offs: While the algorithms achieve optimal regret rates, the paper acknowledges that their computational complexity can be high, particularly in terms of the number of actions and signals. This highlights a common trade-off in theoretical machine learning between performance guarantees and practical efficiency.

Key Results

The paper's main theoretical result is the development of algorithms for sequential decision-making under partial monitoring that achieve:

  • Optimal Internal and External Regret: The algorithms bound both internal and external regret at stage $n$ by $O(n^{-1/3})$. This rate is proven to be optimal.
  • General Framework: The algorithms are designed for a general partial monitoring framework, making them applicable to a wide range of problems where outcomes are not directly observed.
  • Calibration Generalization: The use of Laguerre diagrams for calibration is a novel approach that enables these optimal bounds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The paper notes that the proposed algorithms, while theoretically optimal in terms of regret, can have high computational complexity, especially concerning the number of actions and signals. This is a significant practical limitation.
  • Efficiency: The authors mention that while the algorithms are "efficient" in terms of regret rate, they are not necessarily efficient in terms of computational complexity.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests exploring algorithms with better computational efficiency, potentially by reducing the dependency on the number of actions and signals. It also leaves open the question of whether algorithms can be developed whose complexity is polynomial in the minimal number of best-response areas needed to cover the signal space.

Summary updated

Abstract

We provide consistent random algorithms for sequential decision under partial monitoring, when the decision maker does not observe the outcomes but receives instead random feedback signals. Those algorithms have no internal regret in the sense that, on the set of stages where the decision maker chose his action according to a given law, the average payoff could not have been improved in average by using any other fixed law. They are based on a generalization of calibration, no longer defined in terms of a Voronoï diagram but instead of a Laguerre diagram (a more general concept). This allows us to bound, for the first time in this general framework, the expected average internal, as well as the usual external, regret at stage n by O(n-1/3), which is known to be optimal.
BibTeX
@article{perchet2011internal,
  author = {Vianney Perchet},
  title = {{Internal Regret with Partial Monitoring: Calibration-Based Optimal Algorithms}},
  journal = {J. Mach. Learn. Res.},
  year = {2011},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=2MjgH-S2arI},
}
Figure