Intermolecular Casimir-Polder forces in water and near surfaces

Priyadarshini Thiyam, Clas Persson, Bo E. Sernelius, Drew F. Parsons, Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen, M. BoströmPhysical 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into the subtle yet crucial Casimir-Polder (CP) forces governing how methane molecules interact with each other and with surfaces in water. By accounting for the finite size of molecules, the researchers provide more accurate estimates of binding energies, revealing that methane molecules attract each other in water and are attracted to SiO2 surfaces but repelled by hexane. This work offers a more refined understanding of molecular interactions in complex fluid environments, relevant for fields like energy extraction and materials science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the forces that govern how molecules interact, especially in complex environments like liquids and near surfaces, is fundamental to many scientific and engineering disciplines. Specifically, the adsorption and desorption of molecules are critical in processes such as gas extraction (like methane from shale gas), catalysis, and the behavior of materials in biological systems. The Casimir-Polder (CP) force is a key long-range interaction responsible for these phenomena, arising from the quantum fluctuations of the electromagnetic field.

However, traditional models often treat molecules as point-like entities. This simplification can lead to inaccuracies, particularly when molecules are close enough for their electron clouds to interact or when considering interactions at contact distances. This paper addresses the limitation of point-particle approximations by developing and applying a theoretical framework that explicitly incorporates the finite size of molecules, specifically methane, in aqueous solutions and near various surfaces (SiO2, hexane, air). This allows for a more realistic estimation of the dispersion contribution to binding energies, which is crucial for understanding phenomena like selective adsorption and desorption.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in its theoretical treatment of the Casimir-Polder interaction, extending existing models to account for finite molecular size.

  • Finite-Size Casimir-Polder Energy: The authors utilize a formulation for the Casimir-Polder interaction energy between two polarizable particles in a liquid, expressed as a sum over Matsubara frequencies. Crucially, they employ a non-expanded theoretical approach that directly incorporates the finite size of the molecules. This is achieved by using a Gaussian function to represent the spatial distribution of the polarization cloud of the molecule.
  • Green's Functions: To handle the retardation, background medium (water), and finite size effects, the researchers derive and utilize specific Green's function elements. These elements are adapted from existing formalisms but are modified to include the finite size of the interacting particles.
  • Molecule-Surface Interaction: For interactions between a molecule and a planar interface, the paper adopts a non-retarded van der Waals energy formulation. This formulation is also adapted to include finite size effects, allowing for the estimation of binding energies at contact distances.
  • Excess Polarizability Calculation: The excess polarizabilities of methane molecules in water are calculated. This involves obtaining the polarizabilities of methane in vacuum (using quantum chemical calculations) and then using a dielectric sphere model to account for the influence of the surrounding water medium.
  • Dielectric Function Modeling: The dielectric functions for the relevant media (hexane, water, and SiO2) are obtained from experimental data and first-principles calculations, as described in detail in the paper.

The key novelty lies in the consistent application of the finite-size formalism to both molecule-molecule and molecule-surface interactions in a liquid environment, moving beyond simplified point-particle approximations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on theoretical calculations and existing experimental data for dielectric functions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Finite Size Matters: The most significant insight is that accounting for the finite size of molecules is not just a minor correction but is essential for obtaining physically meaningful binding energies, especially at contact distances. Without it, interactions can diverge, which is unphysical.
  • Water as a Mediator: The presence of water as a background medium significantly influences the interactions. It weakens the coupling between molecules compared to vacuum, making the series-expanded theory a surprisingly good approximation in some cases, even though the non-expanded theory is used for the primary calculations.
  • Selective Surface Interactions: Methane molecules exhibit distinct behaviors near different surfaces in water. They are attracted to SiO2 surfaces but repelled by hexane and air surfaces. This selectivity is a direct consequence of the interplay between the molecule's polarizability and the dielectric properties of the surface and the surrounding water.
  • Dispersion Energy Contributions: The study provides quantitative estimates for the dispersion contribution to binding energies. For instance, two methane molecules in water attract each other with an energy of approximately -0.23 kBT at their contact distance.

Key Results

  • Methane-Methane Attraction in Water: Two finite-sized methane molecules in water attract each other with a van der Waals binding energy of approximately -0.23 kBT at their contact distance (defined as p=2a, where 'a' is the Gaussian radius of the molecule).
  • Methane-Surface Interactions:
    • Methane in water is attracted to a SiO2 surface, with an estimated binding energy contribution of -0.79 kBT at contact.
  • Methane in water is repelled by a hexane surface, with a binding energy contribution of +0.14 kBT at contact.
  • Methane in water is repelled by an air surface, with a binding energy contribution of +1.54 kBT at contact.
  • Validation of Expanded Theory: The paper demonstrates that for molecule-molecule interactions in water, the series-expanded theory can be a reasonable approximation, especially due to the reduced coupling in the liquid medium. However, the non-expanded theory is crucial for accurate results at close separations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study primarily focuses on methane as the interacting molecule. The generality of the findings to other molecules with different polarizabilities and sizes might need further investigation.
  • The dielectric functions used are based on models and experimental data, which inherently have their own uncertainties.
  • The paper acknowledges that for very close separations, orbital overlap effects become important, which are not fully captured by the CP formalism.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest extending this work to study the interactions of different molecules in water and near various surfaces, which is crucial for applications in selective adsorption and separation processes.
  • Investigating the role of other types of interactions (e.g., electrostatic if molecules are polar) in conjunction with CP forces would provide a more complete picture.
  • Exploring the impact of temperature and pressure on these interactions could also be a valuable future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Casimir-Polder force is an important long-range interaction involved in adsorption and desorption of molecules in fluids. We explore Casimir-Polder interactions between methane molecules in water, and between a molecule in water near SiO(2) and hexane surfaces. Inclusion of the finite molecular size in the expression for the Casimir-Polder energy leads to estimates of the dispersion contribution to the binding energies between molecules and between one molecule and a planar surface.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thiyam2014intermolecular,
  author = {Priyadarshini Thiyam and Clas Persson and Bo E. Sernelius and Drew F. Parsons and Anders Malthe‐Sørenssen and M. Boström},
  title = {{Intermolecular Casimir-Polder forces in water and near surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.90.032122},
}
Figure