TL;DR
This paper introduces InterIDEAS, a novel dataset and methodology for analyzing intertextuality in philosophical texts using Large Language Models (LLMs). By bridging literary studies and NLP, InterIDEAS enables a more systematic and scalable understanding of how philosophical ideas connect, evolve, and influence each other, offering new avenues for both philosophical research and AI development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the intricate web of connections between philosophical texts—how ideas are referenced, debated, and built upon—is crucial for grasping intellectual traditions and the evolution of thought. Traditionally, this analysis relies on manual reading and subjective interpretation, which is time-consuming, prone to bias, and limited by human cognitive capacity. Existing computational methods, like bibliometrics, often struggle with the nuanced, non-standardized, and dense nature of philosophical writing, especially from earlier periods. The challenge is to develop a method that can systematically extract and analyze these subtle intertextual relationships from authentic philosophical texts at scale.
Methods
The core of the InterIDEAS approach is a sophisticated data collection pipeline that combines Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) with prompt engineering and human expert review.
- Philosophical Text Processing: Texts are segmented into coherent paragraphs and embedded into vector representations.
- Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG): A vector database stores these embeddings, allowing an LLM (specifically GPT-4) to retrieve relevant text segments based on queries. This grounds the LLM's responses in the actual text.
- Prompt Engineering: A multi-stage prompting strategy is employed:
- Role-Playing: The LLM adopts the persona of a philosopher.
- Chain-of-Thought (CoT): The LLM breaks down the task into sequential reasoning steps.
- Few-Shot Prompting (FS): Examples of desired outputs are provided to guide the LLM.
- Prompt Chaining (PC): A sequence of prompts is used to extract specific attributes of references.
- Human Expert Review: Philosophers and experts iteratively refine the prompts based on LLM outputs, correcting errors and improving the system's accuracy and robustness. This human-in-the-loop approach is key to handling the subtleties of philosophical discourse.
The system extracts four key attributes for each reference: Content Type (nominal, verbal, thematic), Intertextual Function (name-dropping, contextual explanation, critical engagement, conceptual application/expansion), and Sentiment (positive, neutral, negative).
Datasets
The primary contribution is the InterIDEAS dataset, a newly curated benchmark for intertextuality analysis in philosophy. It comprises over 15,000 cross-referential data pairs, covering more than 3,150 philosophers and philosophical schools, extracted from approximately 45,000 pages of philosophical books published between 1750 and 1950. The dataset is designed to capture nuanced relationships beyond simple citations.
For evaluating LLM performance on sentiment classification, a subset of 2,236 reference-attitude pairs was created.
Key Insights and Ideas
- LLMs as Philosophical Analysts: The research demonstrates that LLMs, when guided by sophisticated RAG and prompt engineering, can achieve impressive accuracy in identifying and analyzing complex intertextual relationships in philosophical texts, approaching human expert levels.
- Bridging Qualitative and Quantitative: InterIDEAS shows that the dichotomy between qualitative (deep reading) and quantitative (large-scale analysis) approaches can be overcome. The dataset facilitates both by providing structured data from authentic texts.
- Nuance in Philosophical Discourse: The analysis reveals that philosophical texts employ a rich variety of intertextual functions and sentiments, often going beyond simple mentions to engage critically or build upon existing ideas.
- The Power of Prompt Engineering: The study highlights the critical role of prompt engineering and human feedback in tailoring LLMs for specialized, nuanced tasks like philosophical analysis, significantly improving performance over baseline LLM outputs.
Key Results
- The InterIDEAS framework, using GPT-4 with RAG, FS, and PE, achieved the highest accuracy (0.74–0.91) and recall (0.75–0.91) in extracting intertextual information across paragraphs, significantly outperforming baseline GPT-4 and other LLM-only approaches.
- Human experts still achieve the highest scores (accuracy ~0.988, recall ~0.988), but the developed LLM approach comes close, offering a scalable alternative.
- The dataset analysis shows that nominal references are most common (67.9%), followed by thematic (23.7%) and verbal (8.8%). Name-dropping is the most frequent intertextual function (52.0%), while neutral sentiment predominates (77.4%).
- Sentiment classification experiments showed that fine-tuning significantly improved model performance, with Llama 3 achieving the best results after fine-tuning. GPT-4 with few-shot learning also demonstrated robust and balanced performance.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * The current approach focuses on explicit references and may miss implicit intertextuality. * The LLM can sometimes struggle with semantic dissection when multiple references are in parallel structures or with literary expressions involving complex emotions (irony, rhetorical questions). * LLMs may exhibit stereotyping based on input information (e.g., "Hitler"). * The dataset currently excludes symbol- and aphorism-based texts and is limited to English-language texts, raising concerns about Eurocentrism.
Future Work: * Extend the dataset to include other styles of texts (symbolic, aphoristic) and languages. * Apply the approach to other text-based fields like law and history. * Further investigate how LLMs can be used for pedagogical tasks, such as syllabus design and analytical assignments.
Summary updated