Interference Mitigation for Visible Light Communications in Underground Mines Using Angle Diversity Receivers

Pablo Palacios Játiva, Milton Román Cañizares, César A. Azurdia-Meza, David Zabala‐Blanco, Ali Dehghan Firoozabadi, Fabián Seguel, Samuel Montejo‐Sánchez, Ismael SotoSensors 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of inter-cell interference (ICI) in underground mining Visible Light Communication (VLC) systems by introducing Angle Diversity Receivers (ADRs). They propose two novel ADR designs, a pyramid and a hemi-dodecahedron, and evaluate their performance with different signal combining schemes, demonstrating significant improvements in data rate and signal quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underground mining environments present unique challenges for communication systems. They are often characterized by harsh conditions, including dust, moisture, and electromagnetic interference, making traditional wireless solutions unreliable. Visible Light Communication (VLC), which uses LED lighting for both illumination and data transmission, offers a promising alternative due to its inherent resistance to electromagnetic interference. However, in a multi-cell VLC system, especially in confined mining spaces, inter-cell interference (ICI) becomes a significant problem. When the coverage areas of adjacent VLC cells overlap, the signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) at the receiver can degrade substantially, impacting communication quality and data rates. This paper aims to mitigate this ICI in underground mining VLC systems by proposing and evaluating advanced receiver designs.

Methods

The authors propose two Angle Diversity Receiver (ADR) designs:

  • Pyramidal ADR: This design utilizes four photodiodes (PDs) strategically placed on the triangular faces of a pyramid. This arrangement allows the PDs to capture light from different angles, diversifying the reception and helping to reduce ICI.
  • Hemi-Dodecahedron ADR (Novel Approach): This is a new design featuring six pentagonal faces. It includes one PD on the upper face and five PDs on the lateral faces. This structure is designed to offer improved granularity and compactness, further enhancing ICI mitigation.

Both ADR designs are analyzed mathematically, considering Line-of-Sight (LoS) and Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) propagation components, as well as thermal and shot noises, which are critical in mining environments. The performance of these ADRs is then evaluated using three signal combining schemes:

  • Select Best Combining (SBC): Selects the PD with the highest SINR.
  • Equal Gain Combining (EGC): Combines signals from all PDs with equal weights.
  • Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC): Combines signals from all PDs with weights proportional to their SINR.

The performance is compared against a baseline system using a single PD.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use simulated data based on realistic underground mining scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ADRs are crucial for underground VLC: The confined and multi-cell nature of underground mines makes ICI a severe bottleneck, and ADRs are shown to be an effective solution.
  • Hemi-Dodecahedron shines: The novel hemi-dodecahedron ADR design demonstrates superior performance over the pyramidal ADR, likely due to its more optimized geometric distribution of PDs.
  • MRC is the champion combiner: Across both ADR designs and scenarios, the Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC) scheme consistently yields the best results in terms of data rate, SINR, and BER. This highlights the importance of intelligently weighting signals based on their quality.
  • Lighting standards are met: The proposed VLC systems not only improve communication but also ensure that minimum lighting standards for underground mines are met, showcasing the dual benefit of VLC.
  • Distance matters: As expected, RMS delay spread decreases with increasing transmitter-receiver distance, a fundamental characteristic of optical communication.

Key Results

  • User Data Rate (UDR): The hemi-dodecahedron ADR with MRC achieved a maximum UDR of 250 Mbps in the mining roadway and 120 Mbps in the mine working face. This significantly outperforms the pyramidal ADR and the single PD.
  • Bit Error Rate (BER): For a BER of 10⁻⁴, the hemi-dodecahedron ADR with MRC showed an Eb/No improvement of 3 dB and 19 dB over the pyramidal ADR and single PD, respectively, in the mining roadway. Similar improvements were observed in the mine working face.
  • Signal-to-Interference-Plus-Noise Ratio (SINR): The hemi-dodecahedron ADR with MRC achieved SINR values of 120 dB and 118 dB in the mining roadway and mine working face, respectively, demonstrating substantial ICI mitigation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: The study relies on simulations. The authors acknowledge that experimental measurements in actual underground VLC mining environments are necessary for further validation.
  • ADR Optimization: While the proposed ADR models show promise, further optimization of their design, potentially in combination with other diversity schemes, could lead to even greater ICI mitigation.
  • Modulation Techniques: The paper uses On-Off Keying (OOK) for simplicity. Exploring more advanced modulation techniques could further enhance data rates and system performance.
  • Physical Constraints: The ADRs are designed for helmet mounting, implying a need for compact and lightweight designs. Future work could focus on optimizing the ADR size and weight while maintaining performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposes two solutions based on angle diversity receivers (ADRs) to mitigate inter-cell interference (ICI) in underground mining visible light communication (VLC) systems, one of them is a novel approach. A realistic VLC system based on two underground mining scenarios, termed as mining roadway and mine working face, is developed and modeled. A channel model based on the direct component in line-of-sight (LoS) and reflections of non-line-of-sight (NLoS) links is considered, as well as thermal and shot noises. The design and mathematical models of a pyramid distribution and a new hemi-dodecahedral distribution are addressed in detail. The performances of these approaches, accompanied by signal combining schemes, are evaluated with the baseline of a single photo-diode in reception. Results show that the minimum lighting standards established in both scenarios are met. As expected, the root-mean-square delay spread decreases as the distance between the transmitters and receivers increases. Furthermore, the hemi-dodecahedron ADR in conjunction with the maximum ratio combining (MRC) scheme, presents the best performance in the evaluated VLC system, with a maximum user data rate of 250 Mbps in mining roadway and 120 Mbps in mine working face, received energy per bit/noise power of 32 dB and 23 dB, respectively, when the bit error rate corresponds to 10 - 4 , and finally, values of 120 dB in mining roadway and 118 dB in mine working face for signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio are observed in a cumulative distribution function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jativa2020interference,
  author = {Pablo Palacios Játiva and Milton Román Cañizares and César A. Azurdia-Meza and David Zabala‐Blanco and Ali Dehghan Firoozabadi and Fabián Seguel and Samuel Montejo‐Sánchez and Ismael Soto},
  title = {{Interference Mitigation for Visible Light Communications in Underground Mines Using Angle Diversity Receivers}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20020367},
}
Figure