Interference Analysis for Coexistence of UAVs and Civil Aircrafts Based on Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast

Yiyang Liao, Ziye Jia, Chao Dong, Lei Zhang, Qihui Wu, Hui‐Ling Hu, Zhu HanIEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the growing challenge of integrating Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) into airspace alongside traditional civil aircraft (CAs) by analyzing interference on the Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast (ADS-B) system. Using stochastic geometry, they model this coexistence and derive analytical expressions for received signal quality, offering insights into optimal transmission power and density for safe airspace management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As UAVs become more prevalent in various sectors, ensuring their safe integration into existing airspace is paramount. A key technology for tracking aircraft is ADS-B, which broadcasts flight information. However, when UAVs also utilize ADS-B, their signals can interfere with those from civil aircraft, degrading the accuracy of information received by ground stations. This interference is exacerbated by limited channel capacity and is influenced by factors like the density of aircraft and their transmission power. This paper aims to quantify this interference and understand its impact on the ADS-B monitoring system's performance.

Methods

The authors employ stochastic geometry (SG), a powerful mathematical framework for analyzing random spatial point processes, to model the complex interactions in the airspace. Specifically, they use a three-dimensional Poisson Point Process (3D-PPP) to represent the random distribution of both UAVs and CAs within a defined airspace volume. They then develop a network model that considers the air-to-ground (AG) channel gains, pathloss, and small-scale fading. A channel model is established to describe the signal propagation. Building on these models, they derive an analytical expression for the successful received probability (Psuc) at the ground station, which serves as a metric for the ADS-B monitoring system's performance. This involves calculating the Signal-to-Interference-plus-Noise Ratio (SINR) and its probability distribution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulated data generated based on the proposed models and parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UAVs and CAs are not just additive interference: The paper highlights that the coexistence of UAVs and CAs creates a complex interference scenario that needs specific modeling, rather than simply treating one as a background noise for the other.
  • Density and Power are a delicate balance: The study reveals that increasing the transmission power of UAVs generally improves their own received probability, but this comes at the cost of increased interference for CAs. Similarly, higher UAV density leads to lower received probability. This suggests a need for carefully calibrated transmission power and density settings for both UAVs and CAs to ensure overall airspace safety.
  • Short-range vs. Long-range UAVs behave differently: The analysis shows that long-range UAVs are more susceptible to interference and their received probability is significantly lower compared to short-range UAVs, even with similar transmission power.
  • Pathloss is a critical factor: The paper demonstrates that pathloss has a significant impact on received probability, with sharp drops occurring beyond a certain threshold, emphasizing the importance of accurate pathloss modeling.

Key Results

  • The paper provides theoretical derivations for the successful received probability (Psuc) of UAVs at the ground station, considering interference from both other UAVs and CAs.
  • Simulations validate the theoretical models, showing that:
  • Increasing UAV transmission power ($P_u$) generally increases the received probability for short-range UAVs, but has diminishing returns at higher power levels. For long-range UAVs, $P_u$ has a more significant impact in the higher power range.
  • Increasing UAV density ($\lambda_1$) decreases the received probability. Beyond a certain density, the ground station may struggle to monitor the airspace.
  • Pathloss exponent ($\alpha$) has a critical impact, with the received probability dropping sharply when $\alpha$ exceeds a certain value (around 3).
  • Increasing the transmission power of CAs ($P_c$) decreases the received probability of UAVs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on UAVs: While CAs are considered as interferers, the primary focus of the analysis and simulations is on the performance of the ADS-B monitoring system for UAVs. The paper suggests that analyzing the performance for CAs would follow a similar reasoning process.
  • Single Ground Station: The model assumes a single ground station. Future work could explore scenarios with multiple ground stations.
  • Simplified Channel Model: While the paper considers small-scale fading, more complex channel models could be investigated.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the findings can inform the appropriate deployment of ADS-B equipment on UAVs to improve airspace safety and air traffic flow management. Further research could explore optimal power and density settings for different airspace scenarios and operational requirements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the advantages of high mobility and easy deployment, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) are widely applied in both military and civilian fields. In order to strengthen the flight surveillance of UAVs and guarantee the airspace safety, UAVs can be equipped with the automatic dependent surveillance-broadcast (ADS-B) system, which periodically sends flight information to other aircrafts and ground stations (GSs). However, due to the limited resource of channel capacity, UAVs equipped with ADS-B results in the interference between UAVs and civil aircrafts (CAs), which further impacts the accuracy of received information at GSs. In detail, the channel capacity is mainly affected by the density of aircrafts and the transmitting power of ADS-B. Hence, based on the three-dimensional poisson point process, this work leverages the stochastic geometry theory to build a model of the coexistence of UAVs and CAs and analyze the interference performance of ADS-B monitoring system. From simulation results, we reveal the effects of transmitting power, density, threshold and pathloss on the performance of the ADS-B monitoring system. Besides, we provide the suggested transmitting power and density for the safe coexistence of UAVs and CAs.
BibTeX
@article{liao2024interference,
  author = {Yiyang Liao and Ziye Jia and Chao Dong and Lei Zhang and Qihui Wu and Hui‐Ling Hu and Zhu Han},
  title = {{Interference Analysis for Coexistence of UAVs and Civil Aircrafts Based on Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2024.3414502},
}
Figure