Abstract
We report local probe investigations of the magnetic interaction between BiFeO$_{3}$ films and a ferromagnetic Co$_{0.9}$Fe$_{0.1}$ layer. Within the constraints of intralayer exchange coupling in the Co$_{0.9}$Fe$_{0.1}$, the multiferroic imprint in the ferromagnet results in a collinear arrangement of the local magnetization and the in-plane BiFeO$_{3}$ ferroelectric polarization. The magnetic anisotropy is uniaxial, and an in-plane effective coupling field of order 10 mT is derived. Measurements as a function of multiferroic layer thickness show that the influence of the multiferroic layer on the magnetic layer becomes negligible for 3 nm thick BiFeO$_{3}$ films. We ascribe this breakdown in the exchange coupling to a weakening of the antiferromagnetic order in the ultrathin BiFeO$_{3}$ film based on our x-ray linear dichroism measurements. These observations are consistent with an interfacial exchange coupling between the CoFe moments and a canted antiferromagnetic moment in the BiFeO$_{3}$.
Introduction: Controlling Magnetism with Electricity
In the pursuit of energy-efficient spintronics, controlling magnetism via electric fields—rather than power-intensive currents—remains a primary goal. Multiferroic materials, which exhibit both ferroelectric and magnetic order, offer a promising pathway. Bismuth ferrite (BiFeO$_3$ or BFO) is particularly notable for its room-temperature multiferroicity. However, as an antiferromagnet, its internal moments cancel out, necessitating coupling with a ferromagnetic layer like Co$_{0.9}$Fe$_{0.1}$ (CoFe) to translate electric field control into usable magnetic switching. This study investigates the nature of this interfacial exchange coupling and its limits at reduced thicknesses.
Methods and Characterization
The researchers synthesized heterostructures of BFO thin films (ranging from 3 nm to 150 nm) capped with a thin layer of CoFe. To map the interaction, they employed Piezoresponse Force Microscopy (PFM) for ferroelectric domains and Magnetic Force Microscopy (MFM) for magnetic domains. High-resolution magnetization mapping was performed using Scanning Electron Microscopy with Polarization Analysis (SEMPA), while X-ray Linear Dichroism (XLD) probed the antiferromagnetic order. Micromagnetic simulations (OOMMF) were used to quantify the effective coupling field.
The Magnetic Mirror: Domain Replication
A central finding is that the CoFe layer acts as a "magnetic mirror," adopting a nearly perfect replica of the BFO's domain structure. The magnetization in the CoFe aligns collinearly with the in-plane ferroelectric polarization of the BFO.
The coupling is uniaxial, meaning the BFO defines a preferred magnetic axis rather than a single direction. SEMPA analysis revealed that the CoFe magnetization rotates by approximately 60° when transitioning between BFO stripe domains, mirroring the underlying ferroelectric variants. The authors derived an effective in-plane coupling field of approximately 10 mT.
The 10 nm Threshold and Magnetic Breakdown
The strength of this interaction is highly sensitive to the BFO layer thickness. While robust in thicker films, the coupling drops off sharply below 10 nm. By the time the BFO is thinned to 3 nm, the CoFe layer becomes completely decoupled, ignoring the multiferroic template.
This breakdown is not due to mechanical strain but rather a reduction in the BFO's Néel temperature. XLD measurements confirmed that in ultrathin films, the antiferromagnetic order weakens at room temperature. Cooling the 3 nm samples to 15 K restored the magnetic order, demonstrating that the interface is capable of coupling if the multiferroic order is thermally stable. The presence of the BFO interface also significantly increases the coercivity of the CoFe layer, jumping from ~2.4 mT in isolation to ~9 mT when coupled.
Conclusion
The study establishes a critical thickness limit for BFO-based exchange coupling. These insights are vital for the design of scaled-down multiferroic devices, highlighting the need to stabilize magnetic order in ultrathin films to maintain electrical control of magnetism at the nanoscale. Future work will likely focus on finding ways to stabilize magnetic order in even thinner multiferroic layers to facilitate extreme miniaturization.
Summary updated