Interdisciplinary consensus statements on imaging of scapholunate joint instability

Tobias J. Dietrich, Andoni P. Toms, Luís Cerezal, Patrick Omoumi, Robert D. Boutin, Jan Fritz, Rainer Schmitt, Maryam Shahabpour, Fabio Becce, Anne Cotten, Alain Blum, Marco Zanetti, Eva Llopis, Maciej Bień, Radhesh Lalam, P. Diana Afonso, Vasco Mascarenhas, Reto Sutter, James Teh, Grzegorz Pracoń, Milko C. de Jonge, Jean-Luc Drapé, Marc Mespreuve, Alberto Bazzocchi, Guillaume Bierry, Danoob Dalili, Marc García‐Elías, Andrea Atzei, Gregory I. Bain, Christophe Mathoulin, Francisco del Piñal, Luc Van Overstraeten, Robert M. Szabo, Emmanuel Camus, Riccardo Luchetti, Adrian Chojnowski, Jörg Grünert, Piotr Czarnecki, Fernando Corella, Ladislav Nagy, Michiro Yamamoto, И. О. Голубев, Jörg van Schoonhoven, Florian Goehtz, Maciej Klich, Iwona Sudoł‐SzopińskaEuropean 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an interdisciplinary consensus on the best imaging techniques for diagnosing scapholunate joint instability. It highlights that standard X-rays are the first step, with stress views and dynamic fluoroscopy crucial for dynamic instability, while MR and CT arthrography excel at identifying ligament tears and cartilage damage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Scapholunate joint (SLJ) instability is a common cause of wrist pain and dysfunction, often resulting from injury to the scapholunate interosseous ligament (SLIL) and its supporting structures. Diagnosing this condition can be challenging due to the complexity of wrist anatomy and the variety of imaging modalities available, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Clinicians and radiologists often face uncertainty about the optimal imaging work-up to accurately identify the extent of injury and guide treatment. This paper aims to bridge this gap by establishing evidence-based consensus statements on the most effective imaging techniques for SLJ instability.

Methods

The study employed the Delphi technique, a structured communication method designed to achieve consensus among experts. Initially, nineteen hand surgeons developed a preliminary list of questions regarding SLJ instability imaging. These questions were then used by radiologists to formulate statements based on existing literature and clinical experience. The Delphi process involved three iterative rounds where 27 musculoskeletal radiologists rated their agreement with each statement on an 11-point Likert scale. Consensus was defined as at least 80% of panelists scoring 8 or higher. The evidence level for each statement was also assessed using the Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine criteria.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing scientific literature and the collective expertise of the participating radiologists and hand surgeons.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Standard X-rays are foundational: Despite advancements, basic dorsopalmar and lateral wrist radiographs remain the essential starting point for evaluating suspected SLJ instability.
  • Dynamic imaging is key for dynamic instability: Radiographic stress views (like clenched fist views) and dynamic fluoroscopy are vital for accurately diagnosing instability that only manifests during movement.
  • Arthrography for detailed ligament and cartilage assessment: MR arthrography (MRA) and CT arthrography (CTA) are highly accurate for pinpointing tears in the SLIL and identifying articular cartilage defects.
  • Limitations in visualizing secondary stabilizers: While MRI/MRA and ultrasound can identify many extrinsic carpal ligaments, there's a lack of strong evidence for their accuracy in differentiating partial vs. complete tears of some of these secondary stabilizers (e.g., SRL, STTL).
  • Kinematic imaging shows promise but needs standardization: Kinematic-CT and kinematic-MRI can detect dynamic instability, but established protocols and widespread clinical implementation are still lacking.

Key Results

The study achieved consensus on 15 statements across three Delphi rounds. Key agreements include:

  • Statement 1: Dorsopalmar and lateral radiographs are routine for SLJ instability work-up, and stress views/dynamic fluoroscopy are accurate for dynamic instability. (Achieved 89% consensus).
  • Statement 2: MR arthrography (MRA) provides better diagnostic accuracy for SLIL tears than standard MRI. (Achieved 89% consensus).
  • Statement 3: CT arthrography (CTA) is very accurate for determining SLIL tears. (Achieved 89% consensus).
  • Statement 4: Ultrasonography should not be part of the standard diagnostic work-up due to limited data and low sensitivity. (Achieved 100% consensus).
  • Statement 5: Kinematic-CT and kinematic-MRI may detect dynamic SLJ instability, but lack established protocols and evidence of superior accuracy over dynamic fluoroscopy. (Achieved 96% consensus).
  • Statements 6a & 6b: Ultrasonography and MRI/MRA can delineate some extrinsic carpal ligaments, but validated evidence for differentiating partial/complete tears is lacking. (Achieved 82% and 93% consensus, respectively).
  • Statement 7: CTA and MRA are accurate for detecting cartilage defects, though comparative data is missing. (Achieved 96% consensus).
  • Statements 8a-d: Various imaging methods can provide information for SLJ instability staging, with radiographs recommended for alignment and advanced disease, and MRA/CTA for ligamentous and early cartilage defects. (Achieved 82-100% consensus).
  • Statements 9a & 9b: CTA and MRA with dynamic studies are most accurate for SLIL lesions (EWAS classification), while radiographs are a recommended initial modality with limited specificity for advanced stages. (Achieved 96% consensus).
  • Statement 10: MRA and CTA provide the most accurate diagnosis of DCSS tears, though scientific evidence is limited. (Achieved 82% consensus).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the selection of radiologists predominantly from Europe and academic institutions might introduce a bias against the practical perspectives of non-academic radiologists, particularly outside Europe. They also note the limited scientific evidence for some imaging modalities, especially concerning the assessment of secondary stabilizers and the lack of comparative data for certain techniques. Future work could focus on developing standardized protocols for kinematic imaging and conducting comparative studies to establish the definitive accuracy of various modalities for specific SLJ instability components.

Summary updated

Abstract

• Dorsopalmar and lateral wrist radiographs remain the basic imaging modality for routine imaging work-up in patients with suspected scapholunate joint instability. • Radiographic stress views and dynamic fluoroscopy of the wrist allow accurate diagnosis of dynamic scapholunate joint instability. • Wrist MR arthrography and CT arthrography are accurate for determination of scapholunate interosseous ligament tears and cartilage defects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dietrich2021interdisciplinary,
  author = {Tobias J. Dietrich and Andoni P. Toms and Luís Cerezal and Patrick Omoumi and Robert D. Boutin and Jan Fritz and Rainer Schmitt and Maryam Shahabpour and Fabio Becce and Anne Cotten and Alain Blum and Marco Zanetti and Eva Llopis and Maciej Bień and Radhesh Lalam and P. Diana Afonso and Vasco Mascarenhas and Reto Sutter and James Teh and Grzegorz Pracoń and Milko C. de Jonge and Jean-Luc Drapé and Marc Mespreuve and Alberto Bazzocchi and Guillaume Bierry and Danoob Dalili and Marc García‐Elías and Andrea Atzei and Gregory I. Bain and Christophe Mathoulin and Francisco del Piñal and Luc Van Overstraeten and Robert M. Szabo and Emmanuel Camus and Riccardo Luchetti and Adrian Chojnowski and Jörg Grünert and Piotr Czarnecki and Fernando Corella and Ladislav Nagy and Michiro Yamamoto and И. О. Голубев and Jörg van Schoonhoven and Florian Goehtz and Maciej Klich and Iwona Sudoł‐Szopińska},
  title = {{Interdisciplinary consensus statements on imaging of scapholunate joint instability}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s00330-021-08073-8},
}
Figure