Interdependent Gibbs Samplers

Mark Kozdoba, Shie MannorarXiv 2018 · arXiv

Introduction

Gibbs sampling is a foundational tool for Bayesian inference, particularly in complex models like Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) and Hidden Markov Models (HMMs). However, its practical utility is often limited by "mixing time"—the duration required for the sampler to reach the true target distribution. In many high-dimensional applications, standard Gibbs samplers become trapped in local maxima (bottlenecks), resulting in suboptimal solutions that fail to represent the global posterior accurately.

The Challenge of Identifiability

A common heuristic to mitigate the risk of local maxima is to run multiple independent sampling chains and select the result with the highest likelihood. While intuitive, this approach is inefficient because independent chains cannot be easily combined or averaged. This is due to the identifiability problem: in a topic model, for instance, "Topic 1" in the first run may correspond to "Topic 5" in the second. Aligning these results requires solving a computationally expensive permutation problem, preventing simple model averaging.

The Multipath Sampler Approach

This paper introduces the Multipath Sampler, a technique that maintains $m$ separate paths ($p^1, \dots, p^m$) of latent variables simultaneously. Unlike independent chains, these paths are mathematically interdependent through two key mechanisms:

  1. Shared Parameters: Instead of sampling parameters (such as topic distributions) from a single path, the algorithm samples them based on the aggregate information from all $m$ paths. This serves as a form of "in-flight" model averaging.
  2. Independent Path Updates: Given these shared parameters, each of the $m$ paths is updated independently using standard Gibbs steps.

Mathematical Foundation: Posterior Sharpening

The authors demonstrate that the marginal density of the parameters in this multipath configuration is proportional to the original prior multiplied by the data likelihood raised to the power of $m$. By increasing the number of paths, the algorithm effectively "sharpens" the posterior landscape. This transformation makes the global maximum significantly more prominent and easier for the sampler to locate. Furthermore, because the chains are coupled via shared parameters, they are forced into a common coordinate system, resolving the identifiability problem by design.

Experimental Validation

The researchers evaluated the Multipath Sampler across three distinct scenarios:

  • Synthetic HMM: In a Hidden Markov Model designed with ambiguous transition probabilities, a 5-path sampler consistently found solutions with higher log-likelihoods than standard Gibbs sampling, occasionally even outperforming the standard Expectation-Maximization (Baum-Welch) algorithm.
  • Synthetic LDA: Testing on a topic model with 10 overlapping word "bands," the algorithm showed marked improvement in reconstructing ground-truth topics. For a dataset of 1,500 documents, the error metric dropped from 1.12 with a single path to 0.69 with five paths.
  • State of the Union (SOTU) Corpus: Using a dataset of US Presidential speeches (1790–2013), the authors measured "time concentration." The multipath version (mpLDA) produced topics with lower entropy and sharper historical specificity. For example, a "welfare/reform" topic peaked more distinctly in the late 20th century compared to the more diffused results of standard LDA, suggesting that better optimization naturally extracts clearer latent signals.

Discussion and Future Work

While the Multipath Sampler is approximately $m$ times more computationally expensive per iteration than a single-path sampler, the process is highly parallelizable. The experiments also noted a slight risk of overfitting in data-scarce HMM scenarios, where the sampler found likelihoods exceeding the ground truth.

Future research aims to apply this interdependent sampling framework to even more complex models, such as Markov Random Fields or HMMs with massive state spaces, where traditional optimization algorithms are computationally prohibitive. By leveraging the power of posterior sharpening, Multipath Samplers provide a robust path forward for high-fidelity Bayesian inference.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gibbs sampling, as a model learning method, is known to produce the most accurate results available in a variety of domains, and is a de facto standard in these domains. Yet, it is also well known that Gibbs random walks usually have bottlenecks, sometimes termed "local maxima", and thus samplers often return suboptimal solutions. In this paper we introduce a variation of the Gibbs sampler which yields high likelihood solutions significantly more often than the regular Gibbs sampler. Specifically, we show that combining multiple samplers, with certain dependence (coupling) between them, results in higher likelihood solutions. This side-steps the well known issue of identifiability, which has been the obstacle to combining samplers in previous work. We evaluate the approach on a Latent Dirichlet Allocation model, and also on HMM's, where precise computation of likelihoods and comparisons to the standard EM algorithm are possible.
BibTeX
@misc{kozdoba2018interdependent,
  author = {Mark Kozdoba and Shie Mannor},
  title = {{Interdependent Gibbs Samplers}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1804.03958},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.03958},
}
Figure