Interactions with RNA direct the Polycomb group protein SCML2 to chromatin where it represses target genes

Roberto Bonasio, Emilio Lecona, Varun Narendra, Philipp Voigt, Fabio Parisi, Yuval Kluger, Danny ReinbergeLife 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the Polycomb group protein SCML2A uses a novel RNA-binding region (RBR) to localize to chromatin, where it works with the Polycomb Repressive Complex 1 (PRC1) to repress gene expression. This highlights a crucial role for non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) in guiding epigenetic regulators to their targets and suggests SCML2A can directly enforce repression, independent of PRC1.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Epigenetic regulation of gene expression is fundamental to development and cellular differentiation, with Polycomb group (PcG) proteins playing a key role in silencing genes. While the Polycomb Repressive Complex 1 (PRC1) is a major player, how it's recruited to specific genomic loci and how its associated proteins contribute to repression remains incompletely understood, especially in mammals. Specifically, the function of SCML2, a mammalian homolog of Drosophila SCM, and its interaction with chromatin and PRC1 were unclear. The authors aimed to elucidate SCML2's role in PRC1-mediated gene silencing, focusing on its chromatin localization and potential interactions with RNA.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • RNA Immunoprecipitation (RIP): To identify RNA-binding proteins associated with chromatin.
  • In vitro binding assays and Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays (EMSAs): To characterize the nucleic acid binding properties of SCML2 fragments and identify the specific RNA-binding region (RBR).
  • Salt Fractionation and Fluorescence Microscopy: To assess the subnuclear localization of SCML2 and its mutants.
  • Affinity Purification and Mass Spectrometry: To identify proteins that interact with SCML2.
  • Immunoprecipitation (IP): To confirm interactions between SCML2 and PRC1 components like BMI1.
  • Reporter Assays (Luciferase): To test the transcriptional repression activity of SCML2 when artificially tethered to DNA.
  • Chromatin Immunoprecipitation Sequencing (ChIP-seq): To map the genome-wide binding sites of SCML2 and PRC1 components.
  • RNA Immunoprecipitation Sequencing (RIP-seq): To identify ncRNAs bound to SCML2 in vivo.
  • siRNA-mediated Knockdown and RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq): To assess the functional consequences of SCML2 depletion on gene expression.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • ChIP-seq data: Generated for SCML2 (wild-type and RBR mutant) and BMI1 in 293T-REx cells.
  • RIP-seq data: Generated for SCML2 in 293T-REx cells and endogenous SCML2 in K562 cells under different differentiation conditions.
  • RNA-seq data: Generated from control and SCML2-depleted 293T-REx cells.
  • Publicly available lincRNA database: Used for analysis of RIP-seq data.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study focused on characterizing the binding and functional roles of SCML2 in relation to existing knowledge of PcG complexes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Novel RNA-Binding Region (RBR): SCML2 possesses a previously uncharacterized region (amino acids 256-330) that binds RNA, preferring single-stranded RNA over DNA. This RBR is crucial for SCML2's chromatin localization.
  • RNA as a Guide for Chromatin Targeting: The RBR's role in chromatin localization suggests that ncRNAs may act as guides, directing SCML2 to specific genomic locations.
  • SCML2A and PRC1 Cooperation: SCML2A interacts with PRC1 via its SPM domain, and this interaction is important for stabilizing PRC1 at target genes. Loss of the RBR in SCML2A leads to its displacement from chromatin and a subsequent decrease in BMI1 (a PRC1 component) occupancy.
  • Direct Repression by SCML2: SCML2 can repress gene transcription independently of PRC1, as demonstrated by reporter assays and the observation that SCML2 knockdown leads to gene derepression without affecting BMI1 levels.
  • Dynamic RNA Interactions: The repertoire of ncRNAs bound by SCML2 changes during cellular differentiation, indicating that SCML2's RNA interactions are dynamic and context-dependent.

Key Results

  • SCML2A, but not SCML2B, is enriched in the chromatin fraction.
  • The RBR (aa 256-330) is necessary and sufficient for SCML2's RNA binding in vitro.
  • Deletion of the RBR (SCML2AΔRBR) causes SCML2A to be displaced from chromatin.
  • SCML2A co-purifies with all core PRC1 components, and SCML2A can recruit BMI1 to an artificial reporter.
  • Genome-wide analysis shows significant overlap between SCML2 and BMI1 target genes (~46%).
  • SCML2 knockdown leads to upregulation of a majority of its target genes, suggesting a repressive role.
  • Crucially, SCML2 knockdown does not affect BMI1 levels at target genes, indicating PRC1-independent repression by SCML2.
  • RIP-seq identified specific interactions between SCML2A and various ncRNAs, including lincRNAs, which change during differentiation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the RBR's structure and precise mechanism of RNA recognition are not fully elucidated, and prediction algorithms failed to identify known folds. They also note that while they found significant overlap between SCML2 and BMI1 targets, some sites were occupied by only one protein, suggesting the complexity of PRC1 subtypes and potential SCML2-only roles.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Further investigation into whether ncRNAs act as guides for SCML2 to specific genes.
  • Elucidating the precise structural features of the RBR and its interaction with RNA.
  • Exploring the mechanisms by which SCML2 enforces repression independently of PRC1, potentially involving its MBT domains.
  • Investigating the dynamic nature of SCML2-RNA interactions during different cellular processes and states.
  • Utilizing improved technologies and genetic tools to fully characterize SCML2-associated ncRNAs and their action.

Summary updated

Abstract

Polycomb repressive complex-1 (PRC1) is essential for the epigenetic regulation of gene expression. SCML2 is a mammalian homolog of Drosophila SCM, a Polycomb-group protein that associates with PRC1. In this study, we show that SCML2A, an SCML2 isoform tightly associated to chromatin, contributes to PRC1 localization and also directly enforces repression of certain Polycomb target genes. SCML2A binds to PRC1 via its SPM domain and interacts with ncRNAs through a novel RNA-binding region (RBR). Targeting of SCML2A to chromatin involves the coordinated action of the MBT domains, RNA binding, and interaction with PRC1 through the SPM domain. Deletion of the RBR reduces the occupancy of SCML2A at target genes and overexpression of a mutant SCML2A lacking the RBR causes defects in PRC1 recruitment. These observations point to a role for ncRNAs in regulating SCML2 function and suggest that SCML2 participates in the epigenetic control of transcription directly and in cooperation with PRC1.DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.02637.001.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bonasio2014interactions,
  author = {Roberto Bonasio and Emilio Lecona and Varun Narendra and Philipp Voigt and Fabio Parisi and Yuval Kluger and Danny Reinberg},
  title = {{Interactions with RNA direct the Polycomb group protein SCML2 to chromatin where it represses target genes}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.02637},
}
Figure