Interactions of Grid-Forming Power Converters and Synchronous Machines

Ali Tayyebi, Dominic Groß, Adolfo Anta, Friederich Kupzog, Florian DörflerarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

An inevitable consequence of the global power system transition towards nearly 100% renewable-based generation is the loss of conventional bulk generation by synchronous machines, their inertia, and accompanying frequency and voltage control mechanisms. This gradual transformation of the power system to a low-inertia system leads to critical challenges in maintaining system stability. Novel control techniques for converters, so-called grid-forming strategies, are expected to address these challenges and replicate functionalities that so far have been provided by synchronous machines. We present a low-inertia high-fidelity case study that includes synchronous machines and models of grid-forming converters. We study interactions between synchronous machines and converters and analyze the response of various grid-forming control approaches to contingencies, i.e., large changes in load and the loss of a synchronous machine. Our case study highlights the positive impact of the grid-forming converters on frequency stability and analyze the potential limitations of each control technique when interacting with synchronous machines. Our studies also analyze how and when the interaction between the fast grid-forming converter, the dc source and ac current limitations, and the slow synchronous machine dynamics contributes to system instability. Lastly, we introduce an effective solution to address the instability issues due to the GFCs ac and dc current limitation.

The Challenge of Low-Inertia Power Systems

Traditional power grids rely on the physical inertia of massive, spinning synchronous machines (SMs) to resist sudden changes in frequency. As the global energy landscape shifts toward nearly 100% renewable generation, these machines are being replaced by power electronics-based converters. Unlike SMs, converters lack inherent mechanical inertia, leading to "low-inertia" systems prone to rapid frequency swings and potential instability.

While "grid-forming" (GFC) control strategies aim to make converters emulate the stabilizing behavior of SMs, most research evaluates these in isolation. This study addresses the critical transition phase: how GFC strategies interact with remaining "slow" synchronous machines, particularly when converters reach their physical current and power limits.

Methodology and Test System

The researchers employed a high-fidelity electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulation based on a modified IEEE 9-bus test system. In this setup, two of the three original synchronous machines were replaced with aggregate models representing 200 commercial converter modules, totaling 100 MVA.

The modified IEEE 9-bus test system featuring a synchronous machine (SM) and grid-forming converters (GFC).

The study compared four prominent GFC control architectures:

  1. Droop Control: Mimics the speed-droop characteristic of SM governors.
  2. Virtual Synchronous Machine (VSM): Explicitly emulates the differential equations of a physical rotor.
  3. Matching Control: Exploits the structural similarity between a converter’s DC-link voltage and an SM’s rotational frequency.
  4. Dispatchable Virtual Oscillator Control (dVOC): A nonlinear strategy based on oscillator synchronization.

Key Insights: The "Fast vs. Slow" Conflict

A primary finding is the inherent conflict between the near-instantaneous response of GFCs and the slow mechanical turbine dynamics of SMs. In mixed systems, GFCs immediately "pick up the slack" during disturbances. However, this rapid response can lead to a critical vulnerability: DC-link collapse.

Detailed model of the grid-forming converter, including the DC energy source, DC-link capacitor, and converter bridge.

Most GFC controls (Droop, VSM, dVOC) prioritize maintaining AC voltage. If a disturbance is large enough to hit the DC source's current limit, these controllers continue drawing power from the DC-link capacitor to support the AC side. This causes the DC voltage ($v_{dc}$) to collapse, leading to system failure.

In contrast, Matching Control proved inherently robust. By naturally linking the converter's frequency to its DC-link voltage, it automatically "slows down" when the DC source saturates, preventing voltage collapse and allowing the converter to survive disturbances that crash other controllers.

Key Results and Stability Solutions

The study demonstrated that replacing SMs with GFCs universally improves frequency stability metrics, such as the Rate of Change of Frequency (RoCoF) and the frequency nadir. However, stability thresholds vary significantly by control strategy. Under a 0.9 pu load increase, VSM, Droop, and dVOC failed due to DC-link collapse, while Matching Control remained stable by transitioning to a "constant current source" mode.

To address these limitations, the authors introduced a universal current limitation scheme. By modifying the active power set-point ($\Delta p^*$) when current thresholds are exceeded, they successfully stabilized Droop, VSM, and dVOC even under extreme loading conditions.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While GFCs are essential for future grid stability, their interaction with legacy synchronous machines introduces complex dynamics. Future work will need to explore high-frequency line dynamics and the seamless transition between grid-forming and grid-following modes. The authors suggest that hybrid control strategies—combining the robustness of Matching Control with the performance of dVOC—represent a promising path for the evolving power grid.

Summary updated

Abstract

An inevitable consequence of the global power system transition towards nearly 100% renewable-based generation is the loss of conventional bulk generation by synchronous machines, their inertia, and accompanying frequency and voltage control mechanisms. This gradual transformation of the power system to a low-inertia system leads to critical challenges in maintaining system stability. Novel control techniques for converters, so-called grid-forming strategies, are expected to address these challenges and replicate functionalities that so far have been provided by synchronous machines. We present a low-inertia high-fidelity case study that includes synchronous machines and models of grid-forming converters. We study interactions between synchronous machines and converters and analyze the response of various grid-forming control approaches to contingencies, i.e., large changes in load and the loss of a synchronous machine. Our case study highlights the positive impact of the grid-forming converters on frequency stability and analyze the potential limitations of each control technique when interacting with synchronous machines. Our studies also analyze how and when the interaction between the fast grid-forming converter, the dc source and ac current limitations, and the slow synchronous machine dynamics contributes to system instability. Lastly, we introduce an effective solution to address the instability issues due to the GFCs ac and dc current limitation.
BibTeX
@misc{tayyebi2019interactions,
  author = {Ali Tayyebi and Dominic Groß and Adolfo Anta and Friederich Kupzog and Florian Dörfler},
  title = {{Interactions of Grid-Forming Power Converters and Synchronous Machines}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1902.10750},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1902.10750},
}
Figure