Interactions and Co-Governance Policies of Stakeholders in the Carbon Emission Reduction

Yuhao Wang, Jianmin Wang, Zhongbing DongSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex interactions among key stakeholders (government, manufacturing enterprises, R&D, energy, and financial institutions) in China's carbon emission reduction efforts. Using structural equation modeling, it reveals that manufacturing enterprises and the government have the most significant positive influence on carbon reduction intensity, offering a roadmap for effective co-governance mechanisms to achieve national climate goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has set ambitious goals for carbon peak by 2030 and carbon neutralization by 2060, but achieving these targets is a significant challenge for a developing nation. Carbon emissions are deeply intertwined with economic activity, necessitating the active participation of various stakeholders. However, current approaches often suffer from an imperfect market, administrative management, conflicting interests, and a lack of motivation for investment in emission reduction. This paper addresses the critical need to understand the interplay between different stakeholders and to develop effective co-governance mechanisms that foster cooperation and participation to enhance carbon abatement efficiency.

Methods

The researchers employed a structural equation model (SEM) to analyze the relationships among stakeholders and their impact on carbon emission reduction intensity. This involved:

  1. Developing an Evaluation Indicators System: Based on a literature review and expert interviews, they identified five key latent variables representing stakeholders (Government, Manufacturing Enterprises, R&D Organizations, Energy Industry, Financial Institutions) and one for Carbon-reduction intensity. Each latent variable was linked to several observed variables (e.g., responsibilities, power, strategy, urgency, interest, support).
  2. Data Collection: A questionnaire was distributed to collect data on these indicators.
  3. Reliability and Validity Testing: Cronbach's alpha was used to assess the reliability of the evaluation indicators, and exploratory factor analysis (EFA) with principal component analysis and varimax rotation was conducted to determine the structure validity.
  4. Model Building and Testing: AMOS 7.0 software was used to build and test the SEM. Various model fit indices (CMIN/DF, CFI, RMR, GFI, AGFI, RMSEA) were used to evaluate the model's goodness of fit.
  5. Influence Analysis: The SEM was used to estimate the direct and indirect influence coefficients between latent variables and between observed and latent variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected through questionnaires. A total of 700 questionnaires were distributed, with 457 valid responses received, resulting in an effective recovery rate of 76.17%. The respondents were diverse, including government officials, manufacturing enterprise managers, R&D organization representatives, energy supply industry professionals, and financial institution representatives, ensuring a broad perspective.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Manufacturing Enterprises are Central: The study highlights that manufacturing enterprises are not only major emitters but also crucial actors whose engagement is significantly influenced by other stakeholders. Their support level is a particularly strong driver of carbon reduction intensity.
  • Government as a Catalyst: The government plays a leading role, influencing other stakeholders and opening avenues for co-governance. Its power, strategy, and urgency are key factors in driving emission reduction.
  • Financial Institutions' Untapped Potential: While currently having the lowest direct influence on carbon reduction intensity, financial institutions possess significant potential. Their involvement could be amplified through targeted policies like low-carbon authentication systems and preferential tax incentives.
  • Interplay of Interests is Key: The core driver for stakeholder participation is their interest. A fair and reasonable distribution of benefits and shared interests is crucial for motivating stakeholders and creating a virtuous cycle of emission reduction.

Key Results

  • Stakeholder Influence Ranking: The five stakeholders affecting carbon-reduction intensity, in descending order of influence, are: Manufacturing Enterprises (highest), Government, Energy Supply Industry, R&D Organizations, and Financial Institutions (lowest).
  • Positive Influence on Manufacturing Enterprises: The government, R&D organizations, energy industry, and financial institutions all exert a positive influence on manufacturing enterprises' efforts to reduce carbon emissions. The energy supply industry has a particularly strong positive impact (0.872).
  • Government's Broad Impact: The government positively influences manufacturing enterprises (0.702), R&D organizations (0.517), energy supply industry (0.739), and financial institutions (0.767).
  • Overall Carbon Reduction Intensity Drivers: The direct influence coefficients on carbon reduction intensity are: Manufacturing Enterprises (0.908), Government (0.881), Energy Supply Industry (0.691), R&D Organizations (0.624), and Financial Institutions (0.313).
  • Model Fit: The structural equation model demonstrated good fit with the data, with key indices like CFI > 0.90 and RMSEA < 0.08, indicating the model's reliability and validity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the current carbon finance policy in China is imperfect, with a lack of rich green financial products, which may explain the lower influence of financial institutions. The study's focus is primarily on China, and its findings might not be directly generalizable to other contexts without further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research could explore the development of more effective co-governance mechanisms by clarifying stakeholder roles, cooperation, and participation. They also implicitly point to the need for policy improvements in areas like carbon finance to unlock the full potential of all stakeholders. Further research could also delve deeper into the specific mechanisms through which different stakeholders influence each other and carbon reduction intensity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stakeholders need to participate in the carbon abatement activities to achieve carbon peak and carbon neutralization. This paper developed a system of evaluation indices on carbon emission reduction of stakeholders to elucidate the interplaying relationships among stakeholders in carbon emission reduction by using the structural equation model. The analysis showed that (1) the five stakeholders affecting carbon-reduction intensity are ranked in the following descending order: manufacturing enterprises, government, energy supply industry, R&amp;D organizations, and financial institutions, while (2) stakeholders positively affect manufacturing enterprises and government. Notably, manufacturing enterprises exhibit the greater positive influence on carbon-reduction intensity. Finally, (3) the study results indicated how to build the co-governance mechanism by stakeholders to reduce carbon emissions. Overall, this study provided a theoretical support for the stakeholders of carbon emission reduction to clarify their roles, cooperation, and participation in carbon emission reduction, thereby realizing their own interests, while guiding stakeholders toward the carbon emission reduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022interactions,
  author = {Yuhao Wang and Jianmin Wang and Zhongbing Dong},
  title = {{Interactions and Co-Governance Policies of Stakeholders in the Carbon Emission Reduction}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14105891},
}
Figure