Interaction of Alkene Radical Cations with Solvent Molecules As Described with Density Functional Theory

M. Mohr, Hendrik Zipse, D. Marx, Michele ParrinelloThe Journal of Physical Chemistry A 1997 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how alkene radical cations interact with solvent molecules using density functional theory (DFT). They found that while some DFT functionals (like BLYP) struggle to accurately describe the structure of water adducts, hybrid functionals (like BHLYP) and including more solvent molecules improve the results, suggesting DFT can be a powerful tool for studying these important chemical intermediates in solution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Alkenes are fundamental building blocks in organic chemistry, and their radical cations are key intermediates in many oxidation reactions. These reactions often occur in polar solvents like water or alcohols. To accurately model these processes, it's crucial to understand how the solvent molecules interact with the reactive radical cation. This interaction can range from simple electrostatic attraction ("unreactive solvation") to the formation of new covalent bonds ("reactive solvation"), leading to species called distonic radical cations. Previous studies hinted that accurately describing the structure and energetics of these distonic radical cations, especially those involving water, could be challenging for standard computational methods. This paper aims to systematically evaluate the performance of various DFT functionals and compare them to high-level ab initio methods to determine their suitability for studying these systems.

Methods

The researchers employed a range of computational chemistry techniques. They used Density Functional Theory (DFT), specifically focusing on gradient-corrected functionals like BLYP and hybrid functionals like B3LYP and BHLYP. They also performed calculations using post-Hartree-Fock methods, including MP2 and QCISD, which are considered more accurate but computationally expensive.

A key aspect of their methodology was the optimization of molecular geometries for various radical cation adducts. They then characterized these optimized structures by calculating harmonic frequencies to confirm they represent true minima on the potential energy surface. To understand the origins of discrepancies between methods, they performed energy decomposition analyses, breaking down the binding energy into contributions from exchange, correlation, and other terms.

For a subset of calculations, they utilized the Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics (CPMD) code with a plane wave basis set and effective core potentials. This approach is known to avoid basis set superposition errors (BSSE).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical calculations of model systems rather than analyzing experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DFT's Nuances for Radical Cations: Not all DFT functionals are created equal when it comes to describing radical cations. While BLYP is generally good, it shows a specific weakness in accurately predicting the structure of the ethylene radical cation-water adduct, despite getting the binding energy right.
  • Hybrid Functionals Save the Day: The introduction of exact Hartree-Fock exchange, as in the BHLYP functional, significantly improves the description of the ethylene radical cation-water adduct's structure, bringing it into much better agreement with high-level ab initio methods.
  • Solvent Matters (A Lot): The problems encountered with the single water adduct are mitigated by adding more water molecules. This suggests that for systems like ethylene radical cation in aqueous solution, modeling a cluster of water molecules is essential for accurate results, even with simpler DFT functionals.
  • Covalent vs. Electrostatic Bonding: The study clearly distinguishes between systems dominated by covalent bonding (ethylene radical cation-ammonia) and those primarily driven by electrostatic interactions (ethylene radical cation-hydrogen fluoride). DFT methods, particularly BHLYP, can capture these differences well.
  • The "Intermediate Case" Challenge: The ethylene radical cation-water adduct represents an interesting "intermediate case" between purely electrostatic and purely covalent bonding, making it a particularly challenging system for some DFT functionals.

Key Results

  • Ammonia and HF Adducts: BLYP accurately describes the structures and energetics of the ethylene radical cation adducts with ammonia ([CH2CH2·NH3]•+) and hydrogen fluoride ([CH2CH2·HF]•+), showing pronounced covalent and electrostatic bonding, respectively.
  • Water Adduct Structure Issue: BLYP significantly overestimates the C-O bond length in the [CH2CH2·OH2]•+ adduct, predicting a more electrostatic interaction than is actually present. However, its binding energy prediction is surprisingly close to more accurate methods.
  • BHLYP Improvement: The hybrid BHLYP functional resolves the structural deficiency of BLYP for the water adduct, yielding a C-O bond length in excellent agreement with QCISD calculations.
  • Cluster Effect: As more water molecules are added to the ethylene radical cation, the structural discrepancies between BLYP and MP2 calculations for the adducts (5b and 5c) diminish.
  • Energy Decomposition: The analysis revealed that covalent bonding (e.g., with ammonia) is strongly influenced by the exchange term, while electrostatic interactions (e.g., with HF) are more reliant on other energy components. The water adduct shows a mix, with BLYP favoring electrostatic character and BHLYP leaning towards covalent.

Limitations and Future Work

  • BLYP's Weakness: The primary limitation identified is the inadequacy of the BLYP functional to accurately describe the structure of the [CH2CH2·OH2]•+ radical cation, although its energetics are reasonable. This is highlighted as a specific exception rather than a general failing for all distonic radical cations.
  • Computational Cost: While DFT is generally more efficient than high-level ab initio methods, the computational cost can still be a factor, especially for larger systems or when using more sophisticated hybrid functionals.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that BLYP, especially when used with clusters of solvent molecules, is likely to provide a realistic description of alkene radical cations in aqueous solution. Further investigations into other alkene radical cation systems and more complex solvent environments are implied. The development and application of improved DFT functionals for such challenging systems remain an active area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Structures and energetics of several distonic radical cations, in particular the adducts between ethylene radical cation and water, ammonia, and hydrogen fluoride, are investigated using various density functional and post Hartree−Fock methods. Both the structure and the energetics of the [CH2CH2·NH3]•+ and [CH2CH2·HF]•+ adducts with pronounced covalent and electrostatic bonding, respectively, are well described using the gradient-corrected BLYP functional. The intermediate bonding situation of [CH2CH2·OH2]•+, in particular the structure, is not well described with BLYP, whereas the binding energy is in surprisingly close agreement with post Hartree−Fock methods. The reason for this behavior is analyzed in terms of the different contributions to the total energy, and it is shown that the deficiency is remedied when the nonlocal hybrid functional BHLYP is used. Finally, it is found that the performance of BLYP improves on inclusion of additional water molecules. Thus the weakness of BLYP to describe the structure of the [CH2CH2·OH2]•+ radical cation is a specific exception rather than typical for the large class of distonic radical cations. One can therefore expect BLYP to provide a realistic description of alkene radical cations in aqueous solution.
BibTeX
@article{mohr1997interaction,
  author = {M. Mohr and Hendrik Zipse and D. Marx and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Interaction of Alkene Radical Cations with Solvent Molecules As Described with Density Functional Theory}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry A},
  year = {1997},
  doi = {10.1021/jp972344q},
}
Figure