Interaction Between Smoking and Internet Gaming Disorder on Spontaneous Brain Activity

Xianxin Qiu, Xu Han, Yao Wang, Weina Ding, Yawen Sun, Yan Zhou, Hao Lei, Fuchun LinFrontiers in Psychiatry 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Converging evidence indicates that both smoking and internet gaming disorder (IGD) independently affect spontaneous brain activity. However, the interaction between these two factors remains poorly understood. This study investigated this interaction using amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation (ALFF) based on resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) in 178 participants across four groups: healthy controls, smokers, individuals with IGD, and those with both (IGD-Smoking). Voxel-wise analysis revealed significant interactions in the right medial prefrontal cortex (MPFC)/ventral striatum, bilateral cerebellum, visual-related regions, and the left temporal gyrus. These findings suggest that smoking and IGD interact non-additively in the human brain, potentially predisposing individuals with one condition to the other.

Introduction

Addiction is rarely a solitary condition. It is common for individuals with behavioral addictions, like Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD), to also use substances like nicotine. While the individual neural impacts of smoking and IGD are well-documented, their comorbidity—how they work together—is less understood. Do they affect the same circuits independently, or do they interfere with one another? Understanding this interaction is crucial for developing better diagnostic tools and treatments for patients dealing with multiple addictive behaviors. This study specifically examines "spontaneous brain activity"—the background noise of the brain when it’s not focused on a specific task—to identify these interaction effects.

Methods

The researchers employed resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) on 178 participants: 60 healthy controls, 46 cigarette smokers, 38 individuals with IGD, and 34 with both IGD and smoking. The primary metric was the Amplitude of Low-Frequency Fluctuation (ALFF), which measures the intensity of local brain activity at rest. A voxel-wise two-way analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was used to isolate the effects of smoking, IGD, and their interaction.

Key Results

The study identified several "interaction hotspots" where the presence of IGD fundamentally altered the brain's response to smoking. Significant interactions were found in the right MPFC, ventral striatum, bilateral cerebellum, visual regions, and the left temporal gyrus.

Voxel-wise interaction between IGD and smoking across brain slices.

Reward Circuitry and Inhibitory Control

In the right MPFC and ventral striatum—primary reward hubs—smokers showed significantly higher ALFF than healthy controls. However, this difference vanished when comparing the IGD-Smoking group to the pure IGD group, suggesting that IGD may "blunt" the typical reward-system response to nicotine.

ALFF values in the right MPFC/ventral striatum across study groups.

Conversely, in the cerebellum and visual-related regions (involved in inhibitory control and sensory processing), smoking typically decreased activity relative to healthy controls. Again, the presence of IGD changed this dynamic, with the IGD-Smoking group showing no significant difference compared to the IGD-only group.

Clinical Correlations

In the smoking group, higher activity in the MPFC correlated with higher scores for anxiety and depression. This suggests that spontaneous brain activity reflects the psychological state of the individual. The overlapping circuits identified suggest that people with IGD may be more "primed" to start smoking, and smokers may be more susceptible to internet addiction.

Discussion and Limitations

While these findings provide a novel look at addictive interactions, the study has limitations. The IGD-Smoking group was relatively small (n=34), and alcohol use was self-reported rather than quantitatively measured. Furthermore, as a cross-sectional study, it cannot establish directionality—whether IGD causes smoking or vice versa. Future research using task-based fMRI (e.g., exposure to gaming or smoking cues) is needed to see how these interaction regions react under active stimulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Converging lines of evidence indicates that smoking and internet gaming disorder (IGD) affect spontaneous brain activity, respectively. However, little is known about whether these two factors work together on the human brain. In this study, we investigated the interaction between smoking and IGD on local spontaneous brain activity using amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation (ALFF) based on resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI). Forty-six cigarette smokers, 38 IGD individuals, 34 participants with both IGD and cigarette smoking (IGD-Smoking), and 60 healthy individuals involved in the study. Voxel-wise analysis of covariance of ALFF revealed that there were significant interactions between IGD by smoking in the right medial pre-frontal cortex (MPFC)/ventral striatum, bilateral cerebellar, and visual-related regions as well as the left temporal gyrus. In the right MPFC/ventral striatum and left temporal gyrus, ALFF in smoking group was significantly higher than healthy group while there were no significant ALFF differences between IGD-Smoking group and IGD group. While in the bilateral cerebellar and visual-related regions, ALFF in the smoking group was significantly lower than healthy group while ALFF in IGD-Smoking group did not show significant difference with IGD group. In addition, in the smoking group, ALFF of the right MPFC/ventral striatum was associated positively with anxiety and depression scores while the ALFF value in the smoking group had a trend toward negative correlation with SDS scores in the bilateral cerebellar and visual-related regions. The ALFF value in the smoking group was associated positively with anxiety score in the left temporal gyrus. These findings indicate that smoking and IGD interacted with each other in the human brain. Our results, in terms of spontaneous brain activity, may imply the fact that IGD people are more tended to get smoking. Moreover, it is possible to predict that smokers may be more easily to get internet addiction than healthy people.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiu2020interaction,
  author = {Xianxin Qiu and Xu Han and Yao Wang and Weina Ding and Yawen Sun and Yan Zhou and Hao Lei and Fuchun Lin},
  title = {{Interaction Between Smoking and Internet Gaming Disorder on Spontaneous Brain Activity}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2020.586114},
}
Figure