TL;DR
This study analyzes how sports science master’s students in China and the US use "metadiscursive nouns"—abstract terms like finding, conclusion, and process—to navigate the persuasive landscape of thesis abstracts. The research reveals that while both groups rely heavily on these nouns to establish an authorial "stance," Chinese students use them significantly more frequently to signpost their arguments and package complex ideas.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Academic writing is more than just a data dump; it is a rhetorical act designed to persuade. A key tool in this process is the metadiscursive noun: abstract words that refer to the organization of the text or the writer’s reasoning (e.g., "This argument suggests...").
Despite their importance, these nouns are understudied in the field of sports science. There is a persistent stereotype that sports science students prioritize physical training over academic writing rigor. By comparing abstracts from Chinese and American students, the authors aim to debunk this myth and provide pedagogical insights into how these "ambassadors of the document" are used to build credibility and guide readers through a highly condensed genre.
Methods
The authors conducted a corpus-based comparative study using two integrated frameworks: Jiang & Hyland’s (2018) functional taxonomy and Jiang’s (2022) five lexico-grammatical patterns.
The analytical workflow involved:
- Identification: Using AntConc 4.2.4 to generate frequency lists and concordance lines.
- Tagging: Employing TreeTagger 3.0 for part-of-speech tagging to ensure syntactic accuracy.
- Classification: Manually reviewing nouns to distinguish between technical terms (e.g., "a case study") and metadiscursive functions (e.g., "This study explored...").
- Statistical Analysis: Normalizing frequencies per 1,000 words and using Chi-square tests in SPSS 27 to determine if differences between the two groups were statistically significant.
Datasets
The researchers analyzed two primary corpora consisting of abstracts published between 2021 and 2023:
- Corpus CSA: 15 abstracts from Chinese master’s students (8,934 words), sourced from CNKI.
- Corpus ASA: 15 abstracts from American master’s students (6,486 words), sourced from ProQuest. All selected abstracts were authored by native speakers of their respective linguistic groups (Chinese or English).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Entity Nouns as Identity Builders: "Entity nouns" (like study, research, and thesis) were the most prevalent category. By using these, students aren't just labeling their work; they are establishing their disciplinary identity and "self-promoting" their research within the academic community.
- Stance Over Engagement: In the concise world of abstracts, there is almost no room for "engagement" (dialogic moves to involve the reader). Instead, writers use nouns to "stamp" their personal voice and evaluate information. For example, labeling a finding as a "shortcoming" or an "innovation" signals a critical judgment rather than a neutral fact.
- The Power of the Anaphoric Anchor: The "Determiner + N" pattern (e.g., "This approach") was the dominant structure. This allows writers to encapsulate an entire previous paragraph or idea into a single noun phrase, creating a cohesive flow without repetitive explanations.
- Cultural Frequency: Chinese students used metadiscursive nouns significantly more often than their American counterparts (30.4 vs. 23.6 per 1,000 words). This suggests that Chinese students may rely more heavily on these explicit rhetorical signposts to ensure clarity and persuasion when writing in English.
Key Results
- Overall Frequency: A total of 425 metadiscursive nouns were detected. The difference in usage frequency between the two groups was statistically significant ($p < 0.05$).
- Dominant Categories:
- Entity Nouns: Comprised 53.7% of usage in the Chinese corpus and 68.6% in the American corpus.
- Attribute Nouns: (e.g., quality, manner) were the second most common.
- Relation Nouns: (e.g., reason, result) were the least frequent.
- Syntactic Preferences: The "Determiner + N" and "N + post-nominal clause" patterns appeared most frequently, while "Determiner + be + N" was the least favored, likely because it is seen as too "obtrusive" or "face-threatening" in a formal abstract.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the sample size is relatively small (30 abstracts total), which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Furthermore, the study focused exclusively on the abstract section of the thesis.
Future research could expand the corpus size and investigate other sections—such as the Introduction or Conclusion—where "engagement" functions might be more prevalent. There is also a call for more explicit pedagogical training for sports science students to help them master these "powerful rhetorical tools" for more cohesive and persuasive academic writing.
Summary updated