Inter-Regional Proteomic Profiling of the Human Brain Using an Optimized Protein Extraction Method from Formalin-Fixed Tissue to Identify Signaling Pathways

Jennilee M. Davidson, Stephanie L. Rayner, Sidong Liu, Flora Cheng, Antonio Di Ieva, Roger S. Chung, Albert LeeInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study presents an optimized method for extracting proteins from formalin-fixed human brain tissue, overcoming a major hurdle in proteomic analysis. This improved method allows for robust inter-regional proteomic profiling, revealing commonalities in signaling pathways across different brain regions and paving the way for deeper understanding of brain function and disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The human brain is incredibly complex, with different regions specialized for various functions. Understanding the molecular underpinnings of these functions and how they are regulated is crucial for advancing neuroscience and developing treatments for neurological disorders. Proteomics, the study of proteins, offers a powerful lens for this, but analyzing human brain tissue is challenging. A common method for preserving tissue is formalin fixation, which unfortunately crosslinks proteins, making them difficult to extract and analyze using standard proteomic techniques. This limitation has historically favored the use of fresh frozen tissue, which is not always available, especially for clinical samples. This paper addresses the critical need for an efficient and reliable method to extract proteins from readily available formalin-fixed brain tissue for in-depth proteomic analysis.

Methods

The core of this research lies in developing and optimizing a protein extraction protocol. The authors compared two lysis buffers: one with Tris/SDS and another with Tris/SDS/SDC/Triton X-100, both combined with heating. They found that the latter buffer, along with a specific heating and agitation protocol, significantly improved protein extraction efficiency from formalin-fixed brain tissue.

Following extraction, the proteins were subjected to:

  • In-gel tryptic digestion: Proteins were digested into smaller peptides.
  • Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS): This is a standard technique for identifying and quantifying peptides and, by extension, proteins.
  • Label-Free Quantification (LFQ) proteomics: This method was used to compare protein abundance across different brain regions without the need for isotopic labeling.
  • Bioinformatic Analysis:
    • Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA): Used to identify and analyze canonical signaling pathways.
  • PANTHERdb: Employed for Gene Ontology (GO) annotation to classify proteins by molecular function and biological process.

The key innovation here is the optimized lysis buffer and extraction protocol, which enables robust proteomic analysis from formalin-fixed tissue, a significant improvement over existing methods that often struggle with this sample type.

Datasets

The study utilized post-mortem formalin-fixed brain tissue from three human donors. Samples were collected from four distinct neuroanatomical regions: pre-frontal cortex, motor cortex, temporal cortex, and occipital cortex. This provided a total of 12 brain tissue samples for analysis. The data generated from these samples have been deposited in the ProteomeXchange Consortium via the PRIDE partner repository (dataset identifiers PXD039808 and 10.6019/PXD039808).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Formalin Fixation is Not a Dead End for Proteomics: The study demonstrates that with the right approach, formalin-fixed tissue can yield high-quality proteomic data, opening up vast archives of valuable biological samples.
  • The Devil is in the Buffer: The specific combination of TrisHCl, SDS, SDC, and Triton X-100, along with optimized heating, proved crucial for efficiently breaking down formalin crosslinks and extracting proteins.
  • Brain Regions Share Molecular Language: Despite anatomical differences, various brain regions exhibit surprisingly similar activated signaling pathways, suggesting common underlying mechanisms for neuroanatomically linked functions.
  • Synaptogenesis is a Common Theme: The "Synaptogenesis Signaling Pathway" was consistently identified as significantly enriched across multiple brain region comparisons, highlighting its fundamental role in brain function.
  • Energy Metabolism is Regionally Dynamic: While some pathways are conserved, the study revealed differential regulation of energy metabolism pathways (like oxidative phosphorylation and glycolysis) between brain regions, hinting at region-specific metabolic demands.

Key Results

  • The optimized Tris/SDS/SDC/Triton X-100 lysis buffer with heating resulted in significantly higher protein abundance, peptide sequence identifications, and peptide group identifications compared to a simpler Tris/SDS buffer.
  • The method achieved high quantitative reproducibility among technical replicates, with Pearson correlation coefficients ranging from 0.868 to 0.929.
  • An average of 2450 ± 338 proteins and 9277 ± 882 peptide groups were identified per sample from just 20 µg of formalin-fixed brain tissue.
  • Inter-regional analysis revealed that proteins generally had low regional specificity, but significant differences in protein abundance and pathway activation were observed between regions.
  • Ingenuity Pathway Analysis identified several significantly enriched canonical pathways, including "Synaptogenesis Signaling Pathway," "Opioid Signaling Pathway," and "G Beta Gamma Signaling," with varying activation states across brain regions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study used a limited number of donors (three) and suggest that future work could benefit from larger sample sizes and comparisons across different ages and sexes. They also highlight the importance of accounting for sub-specific regional proteomes in future studies, as different gyri within the same lobe can exhibit distinct proteomic profiles. The study's findings provide a rich resource for further investigation into specific signaling pathways and potential therapeutic targets, particularly in areas like motor function, energy metabolism, and neurotransmitter signaling. The developed method is presented as a robust and efficient tool for routine analysis of formalin-fixed human brain tissue, enabling broader proteomic exploration of neurological processes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Proteomics offers vast potential for studying the molecular regulation of the human brain. Formalin fixation is a common method for preserving human tissue; however, it presents challenges for proteomic analysis. In this study, we compared the efficiency of two different protein-extraction buffers on three post-mortem, formalin-fixed human brains. Equal amounts of extracted proteins were subjected to in-gel tryptic digestion and LC-MS/MS. Protein, peptide sequence, and peptide group identifications; protein abundance; and gene ontology pathways were analyzed. Protein extraction was superior using lysis buffer containing tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane hydrochloride, sodium dodecyl sulfate, sodium deoxycholate, and Triton X-100 (TrisHCl, SDS, SDC, Triton X-100), which was then used for inter-regional analysis. Pre-frontal, motor, temporal, and occipital cortex tissues were analyzed by label free quantification (LFQ) proteomics, Ingenuity Pathway Analysis and PANTHERdb. Inter-regional analysis revealed differential enrichment of proteins. We found similarly activated cellular signaling pathways in different brain regions, suggesting commonalities in the molecular regulation of neuroanatomically-linked brain functions. Overall, we developed an optimized, robust, and efficient method for protein extraction from formalin-fixed human brain tissue for in-depth LFQ proteomics. We also demonstrate herein that this method is suitable for rapid and routine analysis to uncover molecular signaling pathways in the human brain.
BibTeX
@article{davidson2023inter,
  author = {Jennilee M. Davidson and Stephanie L. Rayner and Sidong Liu and Flora Cheng and Antonio Di Ieva and Roger S. Chung and Albert Lee},
  title = {{Inter-Regional Proteomic Profiling of the Human Brain Using an Optimized Protein Extraction Method from Formalin-Fixed Tissue to Identify Signaling Pathways}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms24054283},
}
Figure