Inter-Operator Resource Management for Millimeter Wave, Multi-Hop Backhaul Networks

Omid Semiari, Walid Saad, Mehdi Bennis, Zaher DawyIEEE Trans. Wireless Communications 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for optimizing multi-hop millimeter-wave (mmW) backhaul networks in dense small cell deployments involving multiple mobile network operators (MNOs). By leveraging matching theory, the framework enables MNOs to cooperatively form backhaul links and allocate resources, leading to significant improvements in network performance and substantial cost savings compared to non-cooperative or random approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid densification of wireless networks, particularly with the advent of small cell networks (SCNs), has created a massive demand for high-capacity backhaul infrastructure. Traditional fiber backhauls are expensive and difficult to deploy in dense urban areas. Millimeter-wave (mmW) communication offers a promising wireless backhaul solution due to its high bandwidth. However, deploying mmW backhaul in SCNs presents several challenges:

  • Network Formation: Efficiently establishing multi-hop mmW links between numerous small base stations (SBSs) is complex, especially when these SBSs belong to different MNOs.
  • Resource Management: Allocating limited mmW sub-channels across these multi-hop links to maximize performance while considering factors like interference and signal degradation is crucial.
  • Inter-Operator Cooperation: MNOs often operate independently, leading to suboptimal resource utilization and increased costs. Sharing backhaul infrastructure between MNOs is economically beneficial but requires a robust framework to manage cooperation.
  • Economic Factors: The cost of backhaul infrastructure is a significant portion of the total cost of ownership for MNOs, necessitating the integration of economic considerations into network design.

This paper addresses these challenges by proposing a cooperative framework that allows MNOs to share their mmW backhaul infrastructure, optimizing both network formation and resource allocation.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in a two-stage framework based on matching theory:

  1. Multi-Hop Network Formation Game: This stage formulates the problem of establishing multi-hop mmW backhaul links as a one-to-many matching game. SBSs from one MNO can act as "anchored base stations" (A-BSs) to provide backhaul support to "demanding base stations" (D-BSs) from other MNOs. The game is designed to yield a stable and Pareto optimal multi-hop network. A novel algorithm, inspired by the deferred acceptance algorithm, is used to solve this game, considering both wireless channel characteristics and economic factors (like inter-operator pricing).
  2. Resource Management Game: Once the network topology is formed, this stage focuses on allocating mmW sub-channels across the established multi-hop links. This is also formulated as a one-to-many matching game, but it incorporates peer effects, where the utility of assigning a sub-channel to a D-BS depends on how other D-BSs are assigned. A new distributed algorithm is developed to find a stable and Pareto optimal resource management solution that effectively handles these peer effects and considers link rates and costs.

The framework is designed to be distributed, allowing SBSs to make decisions locally, which is crucial for scalability and practicality in dense networks.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulations with parameters derived from existing literature and industry standards.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cooperation is Key: The paper strongly demonstrates that inter-operator cooperation in mmW backhaul networks leads to significant performance gains and cost efficiencies that are unattainable with non-cooperative or random approaches.
  • Matching Theory as a Unifying Framework: Utilizing matching theory for both network formation and resource allocation provides a powerful and elegant way to solve complex, interrelated optimization problems in a distributed manner.
  • Joint Consideration of Technical and Economic Factors: The framework's ability to simultaneously account for wireless channel conditions (like Line-of-Sight probability) and economic factors (pricing, cost) is crucial for practical deployment.
  • Handling Peer Effects in Resource Allocation: The development of a novel algorithm to address peer effects in resource allocation is a significant contribution, as it directly tackles the complex interdependencies in such systems.
  • Robustness to Blockage: The cooperative approach shows improved resilience to signal blockage, a common challenge for mmW communications, by enabling alternative routing paths.

Key Results

  • Substantial Performance Gains: The proposed cooperative framework achieves significant improvements in the average sum rate:
  • Up to 27% improvement over non-cooperative schemes.
  • Up to 54% improvement over random allocation schemes.
  • Performance is comparable to an optimal solution (within 3.2% gap for smaller networks).
  • Improved Rate Statistics: The framework enhances the statistics of the backhaul sum rate, leading to more consistent and reliable performance across SBSs.
  • Manageable Complexity: The proposed distributed algorithms are shown to have manageable complexity, scaling polynomially with network size, making them practical for dense deployments.
  • Economic Insights: The paper provides insights into managing pricing and cooperation costs, offering a design guideline for MNOs to balance costs and benefits. For instance, it shows how an MNO can determine its acceptable pricing based on its budget and other MNOs' pricing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The paper assumes a single gateway (MBS) to the core network. In practice, multiple gateways might exist, which could simplify the problem. It also assumes a relatively static CSI within the channel coherence time.
  • Dynamic Pricing and Strategies: The economic model is a primary step. Future work could explore more complex scenarios with dynamic pricing policies and competing strategies among MNOs.
  • Interference Modeling: While interference is considered, more sophisticated models could be explored.
  • Integration with Access Networks: The focus is on backhaul. Future work could integrate this backhaul management with access network resource allocation.
  • Real-world Deployment: While simulations are extensive, real-world testing would be valuable to validate the framework's performance under diverse conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, a novel framework is proposed for optimizing the operation and performance of a large-scale, multi-hop millimeter wave (mmW) backhaul within a wireless small cell network (SCN) that encompasses multiple mobile network operators (MNOs). The proposed framework enables the small base stations (SBSs) to jointly decide on forming the multi-hop, mmW links over backhaul infrastructure that belongs to multiple, independent MNOs, while properly allocating resources across those links. In this regard, the problem is addressed using a novel framework based on matching theory that is composed to two, highly inter-related stages: a multi-hop network formation stage and a resource management stage. One unique feature of this framework is that it jointly accounts for both wireless channel characteristics and economic factors during both network formation and resource management. The multi-hop network formation stage is formulated as a one-to-many matching game which is solved using a novel algorithm, that builds on the so-called deferred acceptance algorithm and is shown to yield a stable and Pareto optimal multi-hop mmW backhaul network. Then, a one-to-many matching game is formulated to enable proper resource allocation across the formed multi-hop network. This game is then shown to exhibit peer effects and, as such, a novel algorithm is developed to find a stable and optimal resource management solution that can properly cope with these peer effects. Simulation results show that the proposed framework yields substantial gains, in terms of the average sum rate, reaching up to 27% and 54%, respectively, compared to a non-cooperative scheme in which inter-operator sharing is not allowed and a random allocation approach. The results also show that our framework provides insights on how to manage pricing and the cost of the cooperative mmW backhaul network for the MNOs.
BibTeX
@article{semiari2017inter,
  author = {Omid Semiari and Walid Saad and Mehdi Bennis and Zaher Dawy},
  title = {{Inter-Operator Resource Management for Millimeter Wave, Multi-Hop Backhaul Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=JeUl9q14bgV},
}
Figure