Inter-Limb Muscle Synergies and Kinematic Analysis of Hands-and-Knees Crawling in Typically Developing Infants and Infants With Developmental Delay

Qi L. Xiong, Xiao Wu, Jun Yao, Theresa Sukal‐Moulton, Nong Xiao, Lin Chen, Xiao Zheng, Yuan Liu, Wen S. HouFrontiers in Neurology 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Hands-and-knees crawling serves as a vital motor milestone and a unique indicator of central nervous system (CNS) development. This study quantified inter-limb muscle synergy and kinematics during crawling in typically developing (TD) infants, infants at risk of developmental delay (ARDD), and infants with confirmed developmental delay (CDD). Results showed that infants with CDD exhibit fewer muscle synergies, higher muscle co-activation, and reduced movement smoothness (higher Jerk-Cost) compared to TD and ARDD groups. These findings suggest that neurological injury leads to a constrained neuromuscular control strategy, impacting motor performance.

Introduction

While clinical assessments frequently use crawling to identify motor delays, they often lack the granularity to distinguish between physical weakness and underlying neurological impairment. Crawling is a complex four-beat gait requiring sophisticated coordination between all four limbs. This study aimed to bridge the gap by examining how CNS health manifests in the "software" of movement—muscle synergies—and the resulting physical smoothness of the crawl.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed 66 infants across three categories:

  • Typically Developing (TD, n=20): Healthy, full-term infants.
  • At Risk of Developmental Delay (ARDD, n=33): Infants with risk factors like prematurity but no confirmed delay.
  • Confirmed Developmental Delay (CDD, n=13): Infants with clinically diagnosed delays.

Participants were matched by developmental age to ensure functional comparability. Data collection involved two synchronized systems: a 6-camera 3D motion capture system to track 14 reflective markers and an 8-channel surface electromyography (EMG) system to record activity from bilateral limb muscles (triceps, biceps, quadriceps, and hamstrings).

Experimental setup showing (A) the placement of EMG electrodes and reflective markers on a schematic and (B) a snapshot of an infant during data collection.

Kinematic and Synergy Analysis

The study focused on two primary metrics:

  1. Jerk-Cost (JC): A kinematic measure of movement smoothness. Lower JC values indicate more efficient, smoother transitions in acceleration.
  2. Muscle Synergies: Using Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF), complex EMG signals were decomposed into basic motor subtasks. This reveals how the CNS organizes muscle groups to work together.

Key Findings

The analysis revealed significant differences in how the CNS manages movement in infants with developmental delays:

  • Reduced Motor "Library": Infants in the CDD group utilized significantly fewer muscle synergies (average 1.85) compared to the TD and ARDD groups (average 2.45). This suggests a simplified, less flexible control strategy.
  • Increased Co-activation: Muscles in CDD infants tended to fire together in "clumps" rather than independently. The average number of co-activating muscles per synergy was 5.73 for CDD, compared to approximately 4.95 for the other groups.
  • The Link to Smoothness: A direct correlation was found between the number of co-activating muscles and the Jerk-Cost ($r = 0.330, p = 0.007$). The more constrained the muscle control, the jerkier the infant's movement.
  • ARDD Resilience: Interestingly, infants at risk (ARDD) performed similarly to typically developing infants, suggesting that their CNS control strategies for crawling remained intact despite their risk factors.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that neurological impairments in infants with CDD result in a "simplified" and constrained neuromuscular control strategy. By quantifying these differences through muscle synergy and Jerk-Cost analysis, clinicians may eventually use these metrics as early biomarkers for neurological health, enabling more targeted and timely interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hands-and-knees-crawling is an important motor developmental milestone and a unique window into the development of central nervous system (CNS). Mobility during crawling is regularly used in clinical assessments to identify delays in motor development. However, possible contribution from CNS impairments to motor development delay is still unknown. The aim of this study was to quantify and compare inter-limb muscle synergy and kinematics during crawling among infants at a similar developmental age, however, clinically determined to be typically developing (TD, <i>N</i> = 20) infants, infants at risk of developmental delay (ARDD, <i>N</i> = 33), or infants with confirmed developmental delay (CDD, <i>N</i> = 13). We hypothesized that even though all of the groups are at a similar developmental age, there would be differences in kinematic measures during crawling, and such differences would be associated with CNS impairment as measured by electromyography (EMG) features. Surface EMG of eight arm and leg muscles and the corresponding joint kinematic data were collected while participants crawled on hands and knees at their self-selected velocity. Temporal-spatial parameters and normalized Jerk-Cost (JC) function (i.e., smoothness of movement) were computed from the measured kinematics. The inter-limb muscle synergy and the number of co-activating muscles per synergy were measured using EMGs. We found that the infants with CDD demonstrated higher normalized JC values (less movement smoothness), fewer muscle synergies, and more co-activating muscles per synergy, compared to infants with TD (<i>p</i> < 0.05) and ARDD (<i>p</i> < 0.05). Furthermore, the normalized JC values were correlated (<i>p</i> < 0.05) with the number of co-activation muscles per synergy. Our results suggest a constrained neuromuscular control strategy due to neurological injury in infants with CDD, and such constrain may contribute to the reduced movement smoothness in infant crawling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiong2018inter,
  author = {Qi L. Xiong and Xiao Wu and Jun Yao and Theresa Sukal‐Moulton and Nong Xiao and Lin Chen and Xiao Zheng and Yuan Liu and Wen S. Hou},
  title = {{Inter-Limb Muscle Synergies and Kinematic Analysis of Hands-and-Knees Crawling in Typically Developing Infants and Infants With Developmental Delay}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2018.00869},
}
Figure