Intellectual Property Protection for Deep Learning Model and Dataset Intelligence

Yongqi Jiang, Yansong Gao, Chunyi Zhou, Hongsheng Hu, Anmin Fu, Willy SusiloEngineering Applications of AI 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive survey of intellectual property (IP) protection techniques for deep learning (DL) models and datasets. It systematically categorizes existing methods, analyzes their strengths and weaknesses, and highlights challenges and future research directions, particularly in the context of emerging AI models like LLMs and distributed learning environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid advancement and widespread adoption of deep learning models, especially large language models (LLMs) and diffusion models, have led to significant commercial value. However, the high cost of developing these models (requiring extensive data, computational resources, and expertise) makes their intellectual property (IP) a prime target for theft and unauthorized use. Existing surveys often focus solely on model IP protection, overlooking the crucial IP aspects of the datasets used to train these models. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a holistic overview of IP protection strategies for both DL models and datasets, considering various settings and attack vectors.

Methods

The paper categorizes IP protection methods into two main types: reactive (responding after infringement) and proactive (preventing infringement).

  • Reactive methods are further divided into:
  • Model Watermarking: Invasively embedding tamper-proof watermarks into models (e.g., by modifying weights, structures, or dynamic parameters).
  • Model Fingerprinting: Non-invasively identifying unique model characteristics (e.g., through specific input-output pairs or behavior) to verify ownership.
  • Dataset Watermarking: Embedding external patterns or triggers into datasets.
  • Dataset Fingerprinting: Identifying inherent connections between models and their training datasets.
  • Proactive methods focus on preventing unauthorized use:
  • Proactive Authorization Control: Restricting model functionality for unauthorized users through techniques like input encryption or model encryption.
  • Domain Authorization Control: Degrading model performance on unauthorized domains.

The survey also delves into IP protection in distributed learning settings (like federated learning) and analyzes various attacks that target these IP protection mechanisms.

Datasets

The paper discusses IP protection methods that are applicable to various types of datasets, including text, images, and non-fungible tokens. It does not introduce new datasets but reviews methods that are evaluated on existing datasets relevant to tasks like image classification, object detection, and language modeling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dataset IP is as crucial as Model IP: The paper emphasizes that well-curated datasets are valuable assets and require robust IP protection strategies, which are often overlooked in existing research.
  • Dual-level IPP: The survey systematically covers IP protection for both model intelligence and dataset intelligence, offering a more comprehensive view.
  • Challenges in Distributed Settings: Distributed learning environments (like federated learning) introduce unique challenges for IP protection, such as the inability of the server to access client data and the potential for collusion attacks among malicious clients.
  • Trade-offs are Inevitable: Effective IP protection often involves balancing competing objectives like robustness, covertness, and model fidelity.
  • Emerging AI Models Pose New Threats: The rise of LLMs and generative models presents new avenues for IP infringement and requires tailored protection strategies.

Key Results

The paper is a survey and does not present novel experimental results. Instead, it synthesizes and analyzes the results of existing research. It provides a structured comparison of various IPP approaches, highlighting their advantages and drawbacks across different categories (e.g., model access, dataset access, security tools compatibility, robustness). The paper identifies that while many methods exist, none are perfect, and each has limitations when facing sophisticated attacks or specific deployment scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Usable Unified Verification Metrics: There's a need for standardized, comprehensive metrics that can evaluate both reactive and proactive IPP schemes, including anti-attack capabilities.
  • Model and Dataset Intelligence IPP: IP protection needs to extend beyond models to encompass datasets and generated outputs, especially for creative AI applications.
  • Beyond Classification Tasks: Current IPP research is heavily focused on classification tasks. Future work should address more complex tasks like object detection, image generation, and speech recognition, as well as large foundation models.
  • Theoretical Analysis and Proof: Deep IPP methods often lack rigorous theoretical analysis, relying heavily on assumptions about threat models. Future research should focus on providing theoretical guarantees for robustness and effectiveness.
  • Effectiveness and Efficiency in Distributed Settings: Developing IPP methods that are efficient, robust, and effective across diverse distributed learning scenarios remains a significant challenge.
  • Multi-Modal LLM Intelligence IPP: Protecting multi-modal LLMs is complex due to the need to maintain correlations across modalities and balance multiple design objectives.

The paper concludes by emphasizing the ongoing need for innovative research in deep IPP to safeguard valuable AI assets in an increasingly complex digital landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the growing applications of Deep Learning (DL), especially recent spectacular achievements of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and LLaMA, the commercial significance of these remarkable models has soared. However, acquiring well-trained models is costly and resource-intensive. It requires a considerable high-quality dataset, substantial investment in dedicated architecture design, expensive computational resources, and efforts to develop technical expertise. Consequently, safeguarding the Intellectual Property (IP) of well-trained models is attracting increasing attention. In contrast to existing surveys overwhelmingly focusing on model IPP mainly, this survey not only encompasses the protection on model level intelligence but also valuable dataset intelligence. Firstly, according to the requirements for effective IPP design, this work systematically summarizes the general and scheme-specific performance evaluation metrics. Secondly, from proactive IP infringement prevention and reactive IP ownership verification perspectives, it comprehensively investigates and analyzes the existing IPP methods for both dataset and model intelligence. Additionally, from the standpoint of training settings, it delves into the unique challenges that distributed settings pose to IPP compared to centralized settings. Furthermore, this work examines various attacks faced by deep IPP techniques. Finally, we outline prospects for promising future directions that may act as a guide for innovative research.
BibTeX
@article{jiang2024intellectual,
  author = {Yongqi Jiang and Yansong Gao and Chunyi Zhou and Hongsheng Hu and Anmin Fu and Willy Susilo},
  title = {{Intellectual Property Protection for Deep Learning Model and Dataset Intelligence}},
  journal = {Engineering Applications of AI},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=cfK5c0fb6R},
}
Figure