Integration of Terrestrial Laser Scanning and NURBS Modeling for the Deformation Monitoring of an Earth-Rock Dam

Hao Xu, Haibo Li, Xing-guo Yang, Shunchao Qi, Jia‐wen ZhouSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for monitoring the deformation of large structures like earth-rock dams by combining Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) for dense point cloud acquisition with Non-Uniform Rational B-Splines (NURBS) for high-resolution surface modeling. This integrated approach provides a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of deformation patterns compared to traditional point-based methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional methods for monitoring the deformation of large geotechnical structures, such as dams, bridges, and tunnels, often rely on discrete measurement points. While these methods can provide valuable data, they offer limited spatial coverage, making it challenging to capture the complete deformation characteristics (distribution and evolution) of the entire structure. This lack of comprehensive data can hinder a thorough understanding of potential instability mechanisms and the prediction of catastrophic failures. The paper aims to bridge this gap by enabling the detailed, whole-structure monitoring of deformation.

Methods

The core of the methodology lies in the integration of two key technologies:

  • Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS): This technique is used to rapidly acquire dense 3D point clouds of the dam surface. TLS offers high accuracy and spatial resolution, capturing millions of data points in a relatively short time. The paper utilizes a pulse-based scanner (Riegl VZ-400) capable of high measurement rates and angular resolution.
  • Non-Uniform Rational B-Splines (NURBS) Modeling: After acquiring the point clouds, NURBS technology is employed to create a high-precision, high-spatial-resolution surface model of the dam. This involves several steps:
  • Data Preprocessing: Alignment of multiple scans using the Iterative Closest Point (ICP) algorithm and terrain filtering to remove noise and unwanted objects.
  • Triangulation: Conversion of the aligned point cloud into a Triangulated Irregular Network (TIN).
  • Panel Demarcation: Segmentation of the TIN into panels based on surface curvature.
  • Surface Patch Insertion: Creation of four-sided patches within each panel.
  • Grid Generation: Generation of a quadrangular mesh within each patch.
  • NURBS Surface Construction: Fitting a NURBS surface to the generated grid to create a smooth, accurate model.

The deformation is then measured by comparing multi-temporal NURBS surface models using a shortest distance (SD) comparison algorithm.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected from the Changheba Dam, a large earth-rock dam in Southwest China. Two sets of TLS data were acquired:

  • October 2016: Treated as the reference model.
  • April 2017: Treated as the test model.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather applies its methodology to a real-world case study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Comprehensive Deformation Picture: TLS combined with NURBS modeling allows for the visualization and analysis of deformation across the entire dam surface, not just at discrete points. This provides a much richer understanding of how the structure is behaving.
  • High Accuracy and Resolution: NURBS modeling, when applied to dense TLS point clouds, can achieve millimeter-level precision, making it suitable for detecting subtle deformations.
  • Deformation Patterns Revealed: The study highlights specific deformation patterns in the Changheba Dam, such as larger deformations in the middle of the dam compared to the sides, and increasing deformation with elevation.
  • Influence of External Factors: The research points to the impact of human activities and data gaps (e.g., missing point clouds) on deformation analysis, emphasizing the need for careful interpretation.
  • NURBS as a Powerful Tool: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of NURBS fitting surfaces for reconstructing complex geometries and reducing noise, making it a valuable tool for deformation monitoring.

Key Results

  • The methodology successfully generated high-accuracy, high-spatial-resolution NURBS surface models of the Changheba Dam.
  • Analysis of the deformation distribution revealed that surface deformations were generally larger in the middle of the dam than at the sides near the banks.
  • Deformations were observed to increase with increasing elevation.
  • The maximum observed settlement in cross-sections was up to approximately 90 mm between October 2016 and April 2017.
  • The error distribution in the NURBS modeling process was generally within ±0.002 m, with larger errors concentrated in areas of high curvature.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Acquisition Time: The millimeter-level measurement requires significant time for data acquisition in the field. Future work aims to optimize data acquisition to reduce field working time.
  • Data Processing Complexity: Data processing is described as time-consuming and complicated, with some procedures requiring personal experience and expertise.
  • Areas of High Curvature: The NURBS fitting surface may not be sufficiently subtle to represent objects with very large curvatures, leading to larger errors in those specific areas (e.g., construction platforms, steps, drainage ditches). However, the authors note that these areas were not the primary focus of the study.
  • Data Gaps: Missing point cloud data (e.g., for the upstream face in April 2017) required manual filling, which can affect the accuracy of the results in those specific regions.

Future research will focus on optimizing field data acquisition and exploring further improvements in data processing to enhance the efficiency and robustness of the methodology.

Summary updated

Abstract

A complete picture of the deformation characteristics (distribution and evolution) of the geotechnical infrastructures serves as superior information for understanding their potential instability mechanism. How to monitor more completely and accurately the deformation of these infrastructures (either artificial or natural) in the field expediently and roundly remains a scientific topic. The conventional deformation monitoring methods are mostly carried out at a limited number of discrete points and cannot acquire the deformation data of the whole structure. In this paper, a new monitoring methodology of dam deformation and associated results interpretation is presented by taking the advantages of the terrestrial laser scanning (TLS), which, in contrast with most of the conventional methods, is capable of capturing the geometric information at a huge amount of points over an object in a relatively fast manner. By employing the non-uniform rational B-splines (NURBS) technology, the high spatial resolution models of the monitored geotechnical objects can be created with sufficient accuracy based on these point cloud data obtained from application of the TLS. Finally, the characteristics of deformation, to which the geotechnical infrastructures have been subjected, are interpreted more completely according to the models created based on a series of consecutive monitoring exercises at different times. The present methodology is applied to the Changheba earth-rock dam, which allows the visualization of deformation over the entire dam during different periods. Results from analysis of the surface deformation distribution show that the surface deformations in the middle are generally larger than those on both sides near the bank, and the deformations increase with the increase of the elevations. The results from the present application highlight that the adhibition of the TLS and NURBS technology permits a better understanding of deformation behavior of geotechnical objects of large size in the field.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2018integration,
  author = {Hao Xu and Haibo Li and Xing-guo Yang and Shunchao Qi and Jia‐wen Zhou},
  title = {{Integration of Terrestrial Laser Scanning and NURBS Modeling for the Deformation Monitoring of an Earth-Rock Dam}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s19010022},
}
Figure