Integration of Smart City Technology and Business Model Innovation

Zhen Liu, Yixin Liu, Mohamed OsmaniSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper maps the research landscape of integrating Smart City Technologies (SCT) with Business Model Innovation (BMI) over 17 years, revealing a growing trend towards digital transformation and servitization. It highlights that while research is accelerating, it's heavily concentrated on the early stages of business model development, suggesting a need for more focus on implementation and validation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors identify a critical gap in understanding how Smart City Technologies (SCT) can be effectively integrated with Business Model Innovation (BMI). Despite the rapid advancement of SCT and the growing importance of BMI for competitive advantage, there's a lack of clarity on how these two concepts intertwine across different industries and research areas. This fragmentation hinders the development of a holistic view, making it difficult to identify current trends and future directions for research and practice. The paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically analyzing the existing literature to map the research background, multidisciplinary status, and application areas of SCT and BMI integration within business model stages.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining macro-quantitative bibliometric analysis with micro-qualitative content analysis.

  • Bibliometric Analysis: This was used to explore the research background and current status (Objective 1). The Web of Science Core Collection database was used for data collection. Tools like VOSviewer and CiteSpace were employed for:
  • Keyword co-occurrence network visualization to identify research hotspots and their structural distribution.
  • Keyword burst detection and time zone mapping to understand the evolution and trends of research topics over time.
  • Descriptive statistics on publication years and research areas.
  • Content Analysis: This was used to delve deeper into the multidisciplinary research status (Objective 2) and the application of SCT and BMI across business model stages (Objective 3).

The research methodology was structured into six phases: identification of research objectives, database selection, data collection, definition of selection criteria for data quality, macro-quantitative data analysis, and follow-up micro-qualitative analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on data extracted from the Web of Science Core Collection database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Accelerating Growth: Research on SCT and BMI integration has seen a dramatic surge, particularly in the last four years (2020-2023), indicating a rapidly evolving and highly relevant field.
  • Ideation & Design Dominance: The majority of current research focuses on the initial stages of business model development – ideation (strategy definition) and design. This suggests a strong emphasis on conceptualizing and formulating new business models enabled by SCT.
  • Industry 4.0 & Digital Servitization as Key Trends: These concepts are identified as central to the ongoing integration of SCT and BMI, pointing towards a future where manufacturing and services are increasingly digitized and customer-centric.
  • Big Data & AI as Core Enablers: "Big data" and "artificial intelligence" are consistently highlighted as the most influential SCTs driving BMI, impacting various industries from economics to healthcare.
  • Fragmentation Challenge: Despite the growing body of research, the field is characterized by significant fragmentation, making a comprehensive understanding difficult. This paper's multidisciplinary approach aims to address this.
  • Sustainability Focus: Sustainable development is a recurring theme, particularly in the context of circular economy and urban regeneration, indicating a growing awareness of the environmental and social implications of SCT and BMI.

Key Results

  • Publication Trends: A total of 237 articles were published between 2007 and 2023, showing three distinct phases: an initial stage (2007-2013), a progressive stage (2014-2019), and a period of rapid growth (2020-2023). The average annual growth rate is 15.73%.
  • Top Research Areas: Business Economics, Engineering, and Computer Science are the leading research areas, followed by Science Technology Other Topics and Environmental Sciences Ecology.
  • Keyword Hotspots: High-frequency keywords include "business model innovation," "big data," "Industry 4.0," "digital transformation," "management," and "artificial intelligence."
  • Business Model Stages:
    • Ideation (Strategy Definition): Focuses on internal and external factors, with studies employing methods like modeling, case study, and literature review.
  • Design Stage: Emphasizes developing frameworks for digitally enabled BMI, incorporating IoT, AI, and sustainability considerations.
  • Testing, Verification, and Implementation Stages: Research in these later stages is less prevalent but is growing, focusing on assessment models and the application of SCT to ensure smooth BMI implementation.
  • Key Technologies: Cloud computing was an early focus, followed by big data, IoT, AI, and more recently, blockchain and digital servitization.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Data Source: The study relied solely on the Web of Science Core Collection, which might have missed relevant studies from other databases. * Keyword Limitations: The keyword-based analysis might have missed relevant research if keywords were not present in titles or abstracts. * Fragmentation: The high degree of fragmentation in the field makes a truly comprehensive understanding challenging.

Future Work: * Broader Methodologies: Future research could benefit from employing additional research methods and multiple data sources, including in-depth case studies. * Focus on Later Stages: More research is needed on the testing, verification, and implementation stages of business models. * Applied Research: Extending research into applied areas, particularly on technologies like digital twin, BIM, IoT, blockchain, and machine learning, is crucial for achieving digitally enabled sustainable business models. * Urban Planning Context: Further investigation into the relationship between BMI stages and innovation strategies within the context of urban planning is recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

At present, the progress of business model stages supported by a variety of technology categories may unclear, and the integration of technology application and business model innovation (BMI) is hard due to operational practices in various industries and research areas, which block the view of the integration of smart city technology (SCT) and BMI for further development. Thus, this paper aims to explore the current research on the integration of SCT and BMI and identify the current research status and hotspots, assisting in indicating the status of these technologies in the business model stages in order to determine future trends, and adopts a mixed research methodology including a macro-quantitative method based on bibliometrics and a micro-qualitative method using content analysis. The results reveal a 17-year (2007 to 2023) integration of SCT and BMI enhanced by cloud computing, big data, Internet of Things, and artificial intelligence in recent years, with the most current studies focusing on the ideation and design stages of the business model stages with an emphasis on using digital capabilities to refine, formulate, and design the corresponding business model while defining the strategy through internal and external factors. Interestingly, Industry 4.0 and digital servitization are currently the key trends.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2024integration,
  author = {Zhen Liu and Yixin Liu and Mohamed Osmani},
  title = {{Integration of Smart City Technology and Business Model Innovation}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16125102},
}
Figure