Integrating short-read and long-read single-cell RNA sequencing for comprehensive transcriptome profiling in mouse retina

Meng Wang, Yumei Li, Jun Wang, Soo Hwan Oh, Rui ChenbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study integrates short-read and long-read single-cell RNA sequencing to create the most comprehensive catalog of full-length transcript isoforms in the mouse retina to date. By combining these technologies, researchers can now more accurately identify and quantify transcript isoforms, revealing novel isoforms and cell-type-specific splicing patterns crucial for understanding retinal biology and disease.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The complexity of the transcriptome is significantly increased by alternative splicing, where a single gene can produce multiple mRNA isoforms. Accurately characterizing these isoforms, especially at the single-cell level, is crucial for understanding gene regulation, cellular function, and the molecular basis of diseases. Traditional short-read RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) technologies, while excellent for gene expression quantification and cell type identification, are limited in their ability to fully resolve full-length transcript isoforms due to their short read lengths. This limitation leaves a gap in our understanding of the complete alternative splicing landscape and isoform diversity within individual cells.

Methods

The authors developed and applied a workflow that integrates both short-read (Illumina) and long-read (Oxford Nanopore) single-cell RNA sequencing.

  • Short-read sequencing: Used for standard scRNA-seq analysis, including cell clustering and annotation, leveraging tools like Cell Ranger and Seurat.
  • Long-read sequencing: Employed to capture full-length transcripts. This involved specialized library preparation and a custom bioinformatics pipeline for basecalling, alignment, and isoform detection using tools like Guppy, Minimap2, and Flair.
  • Isoform Analysis: The Flair tool was used for isoform detection and quantification, followed by SQANTI3 for isoform classification against reference annotations.
  • Differential Isoform Usage Analysis: This was performed by merging cells into pseudo-bulk samples to analyze isoform usage across cell classes and subclasses, using Fisher's exact tests for significance.
  • Down-sampling Analysis: Simulations were conducted by subsampling the long-read data to assess the saturation of isoform detection at different sequencing depths.

Datasets

The study utilized transcriptomic data from approximately 30,000 single cells from mouse retinas. This included:

  • 1.54 billion Illumina short reads.
  • 1.40 billion Oxford Nanopore long reads.

The raw sequencing data, gene transfer format (GTF) files, and cell class by isoform count matrices have been submitted to the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) under accession number GSE255520. USCS genome browser tracks are also available.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Long-read sequencing excels at isoform identification: While short-read sequencing is sufficient for cell annotation and gene expression, long-read sequencing is essential for accurately identifying and quantifying full-length transcript isoforms.
  • A vast landscape of novel isoforms: The study discovered a significant number of previously uncharacterized transcript isoforms, highlighting the limitations of current annotation databases.
  • Cell-type-specific splicing is widespread: Isoform usage is not uniform across all cell types; many isoforms show distinct expression patterns in specific retinal cell classes and subclasses, suggesting cell-type-specific regulatory mechanisms.
  • Fusion transcripts are more common than expected: The identification of over 1,000 potential gene fusion isoforms in the retina opens new avenues for understanding gene interactions and their role in cellular function and disease.
  • Down-sampling reveals saturation points: The study provides insights into how much sequencing depth is needed to capture a comprehensive set of isoforms, distinguishing between canonical and novel isoforms.

Key Results

  • Identified 44,325 transcript isoforms in the mouse retina.
  • 38% of identified isoforms were previously uncharacterized, and 17% were expressed exclusively in distinct cellular subclasses.
  • Achieved 98.0% consistency in cell class categorization between long-read and short-read datasets, and 97.4% agreement at the bipolar cell type level.
  • Discovered over 1,000 potential gene fusion isoforms.
  • Demonstrated that long-read sequencing approaches saturation for canonical isoforms at moderate read depths, but novel isoforms continue to be discovered even with full datasets.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low expression levels of novel isoforms: Many novel isoforms were detected at lower expression levels, which could explain why they were missed in previous studies and may require deeper sequencing for full characterization.
  • Saturation of cell-class-specific isoforms: The identification of cell-class-specific isoforms has not yet reached saturation, indicating that further sequencing depth could reveal even more unique isoforms.
  • Functional validation: While the study identifies novel isoforms and fusions, further functional studies are needed to understand their biological roles and implications in retinal health and disease.
  • Application to human samples: The authors suggest that their analytical approaches can be applied to human samples, paving the way for isoform-focused research in human aging and disease contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The vast majority of protein-coding genes in the human genome produce multiple mRNA isoforms through alternative splicing, significantly enhancing the complexity of the transcriptome and proteome. To establish an efficient method for characterizing transcript isoforms within tissue samples, we conducted a systematic comparison between single-cell long-read and conventional short-read RNA sequencing techniques. The transcriptome of approximately 30,000 mouse retina cells was profiled using 1.54 billion Illumina short reads and 1.40 billion Oxford Nanopore long reads. Consequently, we identified 44,325 transcript isoforms, with a notable 38% previously uncharacterized and 17% expressed exclusively in distinct cellular subclasses. We observed that long-read sequencing not only matched the gene expression and cell-type annotation performance of short-read sequencing but also excelled in the precise identification of transcript isoforms. While transcript isoforms are often shared across various cell types, their relative abundance shows considerable cell-type-specific variation. The data generated from our study significantly enhance the existing repertoire of transcript isoforms, thereby establishing a foundational resource for future research into the mechanisms and implications of alternative splicing within retinal biology and its links to related diseases.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2024integrating,
  author = {Meng Wang and Yumei Li and Jun Wang and Soo Hwan Oh and Rui Chen},
  title = {{Integrating short-read and long-read single-cell RNA sequencing for comprehensive transcriptome profiling in mouse retina}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.02.20.581234},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure