Integrating images from multiple microscopy screens reveals diverse patterns of change in the subcellular localization of proteins

Alex X. Lu, Yolanda Chong, Ian Hsu, Bob Strome, Louis‐François Handfield, Oren Kraus, Brenda Andrews, Alan M MoseseLife 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel computational approach to integrate and analyze protein localization data from multiple microscopy experiments. By doing so, they can distinguish specific cellular responses from general ones, uncover nuanced protein behaviors, and generate new hypotheses about protein function, all from a massive dataset of nearly 400,000 images.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cells respond to various stimuli (like drugs, genetic mutations, or environmental changes) is crucial for biology and medicine. A key cellular response is the change in where proteins are located within the cell (subcellular localization). High-throughput microscopy allows us to observe these changes across many proteins and conditions. However, existing methods typically analyze each experiment (perturbation) in isolation. This makes it difficult to compare responses across different conditions, distinguish truly specific responses from general cellular stress reactions, and discover broader patterns of protein behavior. The sheer volume of data generated also poses a significant challenge for manual analysis or even standard computational approaches.

Methods

The core of this work is a new, scalable computational method for analyzing protein localization changes across multiple microscopy screens. Here's a breakdown:

  • Image Segmentation and Feature Extraction: They start by segmenting microscopy images into individual cells. For each cell, they extract a set of five quantitative features that describe the distribution of a GFP-tagged protein relative to cellular landmarks (like the cell center, edge, or bud neck). This creates a "protein localization profile" for each protein in each experimental condition.
  • Unsupervised Localization Change Detection: To compare profiles across different experiments, they developed an unsupervised algorithm. This algorithm compares a protein's localization profile under a specific perturbation to its profile in an untreated wild-type state. It generates a "protein localization change profile" (a vector of z-scores) that quantifies the magnitude and direction of changes for each feature, effectively correcting for "global effects" or systematic biases present in image acquisition.
  • Integration and Clustering: These individual protein localization change profiles are then concatenated across multiple experiments for each protein. This creates a comprehensive profile of how a protein behaves across all tested conditions. Hierarchical agglomerative clustering is then applied to these concatenated profiles to group proteins with similar response patterns.
  • Visualization: The results are visualized using clustered heat maps, where rows represent proteins and columns represent different experimental conditions, with color intensity indicating the magnitude of the localization change.

Datasets

The study utilized a substantial dataset comprising:

  • 24 experimental screens of yeast strains.
  • Nearly 400,000 images in total.
  • This included data from the CYCLOPS database, specifically 15 image-based screens of the yeast GFP-fusion collection.
  • These screens covered various perturbations: untreated wild-type cells, an rpd3Δ deletion strain, and time-course experiments with rapamycin (RAP), hydroxyurea (HU), and α-factor (αF) treatments.
  • Data from two independent screens of the GFP-fusion collection in strains deleted for IKI3 was also included.
  • Additionally, they generated new screens for seven kinase deletion mutants (elm1Δ, hal5Δ, hsl1Δ, kin1Δ, kin2Δ, mck1Δ, vhs1Δ).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Single-Screen Analysis: The most significant idea is that integrating data from multiple screens provides a richer context than analyzing each experiment in isolation. This allows for the discovery of patterns that are invisible when looking at individual perturbations.
  • Distinguishing Specific vs. General Responses: By comparing how proteins behave across diverse conditions, the method can differentiate between responses that are specific to a particular perturbation and those that are part of a general cellular stress response.
  • Uncovering Nuanced Protein Behavior: The approach revealed that even proteins with similar overall functions can exhibit subtle differences in their localization dynamics under various stresses.
  • Hypothesis Generation through Clustering: Grouping proteins with similar localization change patterns provides a powerful way to generate hypotheses about their shared functions or regulatory mechanisms.
  • Localization as an Independent Layer of Regulation: The study suggests that protein localization changes can occur independently of transcriptional or protein abundance changes, highlighting it as a distinct regulatory mechanism.

Key Results

  • The method successfully analyzed nearly 400,000 images from 24 experimental screens, demonstrating its scalability.
  • They identified 1159 protein change profiles with strong signals, which were then clustered.
  • Manual evaluation of images confirmed that clusters with strong signals in their protein change profiles had a high ratio of visible localization changes.
  • They found examples of stress-responsive proteins (like Msn2, Dot6, Rtg3) exhibiting coordinated nuclear import under hydroxyurea and rapamycin treatment, with subtle differences in their temporal dynamics.
  • The study revealed perturbation-specific responses for ribosomal subunits, suggesting extra-ribosomal functions.
  • A reciprocal pattern of localization changes was observed for membrane and Golgi proteins between hydroxyurea and rapamycin treatments, a pattern that would have been missed without integrating data.
  • The analysis showed little correlation between protein localization change similarity and transcript profile similarity, but a greater correlation with protein abundance change profile similarity, suggesting localization changes are more specific than abundance changes.
  • They identified new patterns of localization change in kinase deletion mutant screens, even in cases with limited prior biological knowledge.

Limitations and Future Work

  • False Positives and Negatives: The authors acknowledge that image acquisition and analysis steps can introduce artifacts and errors, leading to potential false positives and negatives. They recommend human validation of results, especially for weaker signals.
  • Data Dimensionality: The clustering method's performance can decrease with increasing data dimensionality, suggesting that adaptations for higher-dimensional data might be needed as the number of screens grows.
  • Limited Proteome Coverage: The yeast GFP collection does not yet cover the entire proteome, meaning some proteins are not included in the analysis.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their approach can be extended to study proteomic differences in tissue or cell types and could be applied to human cell screens for drug target identification and understanding drug side effects. They also highlight the potential to incorporate other image information, such as cell morphology and protein abundance, into future integrative analyses.

Summary updated

Abstract

The evaluation of protein localization changes on a systematic level is a powerful tool for understanding how cells respond to environmental, chemical, or genetic perturbations. To date, work in understanding these proteomic responses through high-throughput imaging has catalogued localization changes independently for each perturbation. To distinguish changes that are targeted responses to the specific perturbation or more generalized programs, we developed a scalable approach to visualize the localization behavior of proteins across multiple experiments as a quantitative pattern. By applying this approach to 24 experimental screens consisting of nearly 400,000 images, we differentiated specific responses from more generalized ones, discovered nuance in the localization behavior of stress-responsive proteins, and formed hypotheses by clustering proteins that have similar patterns. Previous approaches aim to capture all localization changes for a single screen as accurately as possible, whereas our work aims to integrate large amounts of imaging data to find unexpected new cell biology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2018integrating,
  author = {Alex X. Lu and Yolanda Chong and Ian Hsu and Bob Strome and Louis‐François Handfield and Oren Kraus and Brenda Andrews and Alan M Moses},
  title = {{Integrating images from multiple microscopy screens reveals diverse patterns of change in the subcellular localization of proteins}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.31872},
}

Loading related content...

Figure