Integrating genomic sequencing resources: an innovative perspective on recycling with universal Angiosperms353 probe sets

Xueqin Wang, Tao Xiong, Yiying Wang, Xinru Zhang, Zhen GaoHorticulture 2024 · DOI

Abstract

High-throughput sequencing (HTS) has transformed plant phylogenomics, yet the diversity of sequencing strategies often leads to fragmented data resources. This paper explores the potential of the universal Angiosperms353 probe set as a bridge for integrating disparate genomic datasets. By benchmarking software tools and evaluating various sequencing strategies—including RNA-seq, whole-genome sequencing (WGS), and genome skimming—we demonstrate that these 353 nuclear genes can be effectively "mined" from existing data. Our findings highlight RNA-seq as a particularly potent source for gene recovery and provide a roadmap for maximizing the utility of global genomic resources in building the plant Tree of Life.

Introduction

The advent of high-throughput sequencing (HTS) has moved plant biology from a few DNA markers to thousands of genomic loci. However, this progress has introduced a "silo" effect: labs using different methods like Transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq), Whole-Genome Sequencing (WGS), or Target Capture (Hyb-seq) often find their data difficult to compare.

The Angiosperms353 probe set, designed to capture 353 single-copy nuclear genes across all flowering plants, offers a potential solution. While originally intended for Hyb-seq (target enrichment), its "universality" suggests it could serve as a common denominator for recycling data from other HTS strategies, allowing researchers to build unified datasets without the cost of new sequencing runs.

Figure 5: Conceptual representation of target enrichment where specific nuclear genes (red) are identified within genomic DNA fragments (blue).

Methodology and Benchmarking

To assess this potential, the study conducted a two-phase evaluation:

  1. Software Benchmarking: A comparison of two bioinformatic pipelines—HybPiper (assembly-based) and Easy353 (k-mer based)—using an 18-taxa dataset to measure gene recovery and sequence length.
  2. Strategy Evaluation: An expansion to a 343-taxa dataset covering major angiosperm clades (ANA grade, Monocots, Eudicots, etc.) to test how sequencing strategy and depth influence gene capture.

The "Recycling" Potential of HTS Data

The results reveal that the Angiosperms353 genes are remarkably accessible across different data types. RNA-seq emerged as a "hidden gem," yielding the highest average gene recovery (>300 genes). Since these 353 genes are protein-coding, they are naturally expressed and captured in transcriptomes. WGS and genome skimming also showed significant potential, particularly when sequencing depth exceeded 30×.

Figure 6: Integration of diverse sequencing reads to recover target gene sequences, illustrating the "mining" process from various HTS sources.

Key Findings

  • Strategy Efficiency: RNA-seq (>300 genes) proved most effective, followed by WGS (~144 genes) and Genome Skimming (~57 genes). RAD-seq was found to be largely ineffective due to its sparse and lineage-specific nature.
  • Tool Performance: While HybPiper is efficient for high-depth data, Easy353 recovered longer average sequences (755 bp vs 644 bp) and offered a more user-friendly interface.
  • Taxonomic Universality: No significant bias was observed across the tested angiosperm groups, confirming the probe set's broad applicability from basal angiosperms to advanced eudicots.

Discussion and Future Directions

The ability to "recycle" genomic data promotes a more collaborative and cost-effective research environment. However, challenges remain, particularly regarding paralogy (gene duplication) in polyploid genomes and tissue-specific expression bias in RNA-seq.

Future research should aim to combine universal sets like Angiosperms353 with lineage-specific probes to resolve both deep evolutionary branches and shallow species radiations. By adopting these integrative bioinformatic approaches, the botanical community can maximize the value of every gigabase sequenced, moving closer to a comprehensive understanding of plant evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Sequencing strategies have continually advanced, with high-throughput sequencing (HTS) technologies emerging as pivotal tools in plant phylogenomics. As a standard form of target capture sequencing, hybridization target enrichment sequencing (Hyb-seq) is innovative and flexible, and then HTS strategy is widely adopted in phylogenomics. The universal Angiosperms353 probe sets (Angiosperms353) are instrumental in Hyb-seq and have been witnessed increased application in recent years. This review integrates numerous publications and empirical datasets to comprehensively assess the potential applications of Angiosperms353. Through evaluations using 18-taxa and 343-taxa genomic datasets, this review explores potential factors influencing Angiosperms353 gene capture. The RNA-seq strategy yielded the highest number of Angiosperms353 genes, followed by whole-genome sequencing and genome skimming. Increased sequencing depth enhanced gene capture yields, and no evident bias was observed across all tested angiosperm groups. In the genomics era with extensive HTS data, this review provides comprehensive guidelines for the practical application of Angiosperms353, promoting resource recycling and maximizing genomic data sharing and utilization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024integrating,
  author = {Xueqin Wang and Tao Xiong and Yiying Wang and Xinru Zhang and Zhen Gao},
  title = {{Integrating genomic sequencing resources: an innovative perspective on recycling with universal Angiosperms353 probe sets}},
  booktitle = {Horticulture},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s44281-023-00026-z},
}
Figure