TL;DR
This study explored the feasibility of integrating an internet-mediated walking program (Stepping Up to Health, SUH) into family medicine clinics. While providers successfully referred patients, they rarely used the system to monitor progress, highlighting challenges in integrating new technologies into busy clinical workflows. However, patients who completed the program showed significant increases in physical activity.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Chronic diseases are a major health burden, and physical activity is a cornerstone of prevention and management. While interventions like the "Stepping Up to Health" (SUH) program have shown promise in increasing physical activity, translating these into routine clinical practice remains a significant challenge. Primary care physicians (PCPs) face time constraints, lack of training, and limited access to effective resources, hindering their ability to promote physical activity. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how to effectively integrate such digital health tools into the existing family medicine clinical workflow, specifically focusing on the development and feasibility of a provider-facing interface for referring patients and monitoring their progress. The goal is to make physical activity promotion a more seamless part of the patient-centered medical home (PCMH) model.
Methods
The study employed a two-phased, mixed-method design:
- Phase I: Interface Development: This phase focused on user-centered design. Six physician-medical assistant (MA) pairs from two family medicine clinics participated in iterative interviews and provided feedback on mock-ups of a clinical interface. The goal was to develop an interface that allowed PCPs to efficiently refer patients to SUH and monitor their progress.
- Phase II: Feasibility and Evaluation: In this phase, providers used the developed interface to refer patients to a six-week SUH intervention. The feasibility of integration was assessed through qualitative interviews with providers, surveys, and online usage logs. Patient outcomes were measured by pedometer step counts.
Datasets
- Provider Interview Data: Qualitative data from semi-structured interviews with physicians and MAs were collected and analyzed to inform interface design and assess feasibility.
- Online Usage Logs: Website usage data from the clinical interface was collected to track provider engagement with the monitoring features.
- Pedometer Data: Step count data from participants' pedometers (Omron HJ-720-ITC) were collected at baseline and at the end of the six-week intervention to measure changes in physical activity.
- Patient Surveys: Online satisfaction surveys were administered to patients at the end of the intervention.
No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on evaluating the integration of an existing intervention (SUH) into a clinical setting.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Provider-centric design is crucial: The iterative design process, incorporating direct provider feedback, was essential for developing a functional interface. Providers emphasized the need for alerts for non-compliant patients and summary views of patient data.
- Referral is feasible, monitoring is not: While providers found the interface easy to use for referring patients, they rarely utilized the monitoring features. This highlights a disconnect between the referral process and ongoing patient management within the clinical workflow.
- Integration with EMR is a major barrier: The lack of integration with the electronic medical record (EMR) system made accessing the SUH interface inconvenient, requiring providers to remember separate logins and navigate to a different system.
- Time constraints and competing priorities dominate: The short duration of patient visits and the multitude of other demands on providers' time were significant barriers to actively monitoring patients within the SUH system.
- MAs could play a key role: While physicians viewed referrals as an added burden, MAs found the process more manageable, suggesting that a team-based approach, with MAs taking on more monitoring responsibilities, could improve adoption.
- Significant patient impact: Despite provider challenges, patients who completed the SUH intervention demonstrated a substantial increase in their daily step counts.
Key Results
- Interface Development: A three-page interface was developed, including recruitment, summary, and detailed patient pages, based on provider input.
- Referral Success: Providers referred 139 patients, and 37 (27%) enrolled in the six-week SUH intervention. Of those enrolled, 34 (92%) completed the program.
- Monitoring Underutilization: The Clinic Summary Page was viewed only 100 times across all providers, and Detailed Patient Pages were viewed for only 15 participants.
- Patient Activity Increase: Intent-to-treat analyses showed patients significantly increased their total daily steps by an average of 1493 steps/day (p < 0.01). Aerobic walking minutes per week also increased significantly.
- Patient Satisfaction: Most users found the intervention useful and easy to use.
- Provider Barriers: Key barriers to monitoring included lack of EMR integration, competing priorities, patient disinterest, and physician unease with exercise referrals.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study did not use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) design, limiting its ability to establish definitive clinical efficacy.
- The short duration of the pilot intervention (6-7 weeks) may not reflect real-world practice where long-term monitoring is needed.
- The study did not assess changes in physiological outcomes (e.g., blood pressure, cholesterol), focusing instead on satisfaction and engagement.
- Workflow integration issues were not fully explored during the development phase.
- The sample size of patients was small and from only two clinics, limiting generalizability.
- Future Work:
- Conduct a large, randomized clinical trial to compare SUH with other intervention strategies and evaluate large-scale implementation.
- Future research needs to test the effectiveness of integrating SUH with clinical information systems over longer evaluation periods.
- Further investigation into ensuring the interface is flexible enough to accommodate workflow variations and acceptable to providers is needed.
- Exploring team-based approaches, particularly involving MAs, for patient monitoring is recommended.
Summary updated