Integrality, duality and finiteness in combinatoric topological strings

Robert de Mello Koch, Yang‐Hui He, Garreth Kemp, Sanjaye RamgoolamJournal of High Energy Physics 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper connects abstract concepts in group theory and number theory with the framework of topological string theory. It demonstrates how to combinatorially construct fundamental properties of finite groups, like representation dimensions and characters, using amplitudes from 2D topological field theories and topological string theories. This approach offers new insights into group theory and has implications for understanding quantum gravity and holography.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A well-known fact in finite group theory is that the order of a group ($|G|$) is divisible by the dimension ($d_R$) of any of its irreducible complex representations. While this integrality is proven, it's not immediately obvious how to construct these dimensions or the ratios $|G|/d_R$ using purely combinatorial methods based on the group's multiplication table. This paper tackles the challenge of finding such combinatorial algorithms, drawing inspiration from topological quantum field theory (TQFT) and topological string theory. Furthermore, it explores how these constructions relate to deeper questions in quantum gravity, specifically the factorization puzzle in 2D/3D holography arising from wormholes.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in leveraging the framework of 2D Dijkgraaf-Witten topological field theories (G-TQFT2), which are built upon finite groups $G$. These theories provide a way to associate amplitudes to surfaces with boundaries. The authors then extend this to combinatoric topological string theories (G-CTST) by summing over different genera of surfaces, weighted by a string coupling.

Key techniques include:

  • Combinatorial Construction of Ratios: The paper shows how to construct the integer ratios $|G|^2/d_R^2$ (and thus $d_R$) by computing G-TQFT2 amplitudes on surfaces of various genera and performing finite algebraic operations. This involves using group multiplications shaped by the fundamental groups of surfaces.
  • Character Construction: Boundary amplitudes of G-TQFT2/G-CTST are used to construct normalized characters of finite groups. This is achieved through a process that involves solving polynomial equations derived from these amplitudes.
  • S-duality: The paper investigates the S-duality of G-CTST, revealing a dual expansion in terms of the dimensions $d_R$.
  • Finiteness Relations: Universal relations among G-TQFT2 amplitudes are derived from the finiteness of the number of conjugacy classes ($K$) in a group. These relations are captured by null states in an inner product constructed by coupling G-TQFT2 to a TQFT based on symmetric group algebras.
  • 2D/3D Holography: The authors explore a potential 3D holographic dual for the coupled theory, using it to shed light on the factorization puzzle in holography related to wormholes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constructions and algorithms applicable to any finite group.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Group Theory and String Theory: The paper establishes a concrete link between fundamental concepts in finite group representation theory (dimensions, characters) and the machinery of topological string theory. This suggests that string theory can provide a powerful computational and conceptual framework for understanding group theory.
  • Combinatorial Construction of Group Invariants: The work demonstrates that key group-theoretic quantities, which are often derived through abstract algebraic or analytic means, can be constructed purely combinatorically using topological string amplitudes. This is a significant step towards a more constructive approach to representation theory.
  • Finiteness as a Structural Principle: The finiteness of the number of conjugacy classes ($K$) in a group is shown to be a crucial element that leads to universal relations between TQFT amplitudes. This highlights how structural properties of groups manifest in the physics of topological theories.
  • Holographic Interpretation of Group Theory: The exploration of a 3D holographic dual for the coupled theory suggests that the structure of finite groups might be deeply connected to the emergent properties of quantum gravity, particularly in the context of wormholes and factorization puzzles.

Key Results

  • Algorithm for $|G|^2/d_R^2$ Construction: A finite algorithm is presented to construct the integer ratios $|G|^2/d_R^2$ from G-TQFT2 amplitudes.
  • Combinatoric Construction of Normalized Characters: The paper provides algorithms for constructing normalized characters of finite groups using G-TQFT2/G-CTST amplitudes.
  • Universal Finiteness Relations: Finite $K$ relations are derived for G-TQFT2 amplitudes, which are shown to be captured by null states in a specific inner product.
  • S-duality Interpretation: S-duality for G-CTST is studied, revealing a dual expansion in terms of representation dimensions.
  • Framework for 2D/3D Holography: The paper proposes a scenario for a 3D holographic dual that offers a new perspective on the factorization puzzle in holography, linking it to the choice of observables within the theory.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the paper presents combinatorial algorithms, the practical implementation for very large groups might still be computationally intensive. The authors mention that subsequent improvements to Burnside's algorithm were focused on reducing computational cost.
  • Explicit Construction of 3D Holographic Dual: The paper discusses the scenario of a 3D holographic dual but does not provide a full explicit construction or verification.
  • Generalization to Other Theories: The authors suggest that the developed framework could be generalized to other topological quantum field theories and potentially to higher-dimensional wormhole physics.
  • Understanding Non-Integer Characters: While the paper focuses on constructing integer normalized characters, it also mentions that non-integer characters live in algebraic extensions of rational numbers and are characterized by polynomials. Further investigation into these could be fruitful.
  • Complexity and Black Holes: The authors suggest exploring connections with discussions of complexity and black holes, which is a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract A remarkable result at the intersection of number theory and group theory states that the order of a finite group G (denoted |G| ) is divisible by the dimension d R of any irreducible complex representation of G . We show that the integer ratios $$ {\left|G\right|}^2/{d}_R^2 $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:msup> <mml:mfenced> <mml:mi>G</mml:mi> </mml:mfenced> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> </mml:msup> <mml:mo>/</mml:mo> <mml:msubsup> <mml:mi>d</mml:mi> <mml:mi>R</mml:mi> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> </mml:msubsup> </mml:math> are combinatorially constructible using finite algorithms which take as input the amplitudes of combinatoric topological strings ( G -CTST) of finite groups based on 2D Dijkgraaf-Witten topological field theories ( G -TQFT2). The ratios are also shown to be eigenvalues of handle creation operators in G -TQFT2/ G -CTST. These strings have recently been discussed as toy models of wormholes and baby universes by Marolf and Maxfield, and Gardiner and Megas. Boundary amplitudes of the G -TQFT2/ G -CTST provide algorithms for combinatoric constructions of normalized characters. Stringy S-duality for closed G -CTST gives a dual expansion generated by disconnected entangled surfaces. There are universal relations between G -TQFT2 amplitudes due to the finiteness of the number K of conjugacy classes. These relations can be labelled by Young diagrams and are captured by null states in an inner product constructed by coupling the G -TQFT2 to a universal TQFT2 based on symmetric group algebras. We discuss the scenario of a 3D holographic dual for this coupled theory and the implications of the scenario for the factorization puzzle of 2D/3D holography raised by wormholes in 3D.
BibTeX
@article{koch2022integrality,
  author = {Robert de Mello Koch and Yang‐Hui He and Garreth Kemp and Sanjaye Ramgoolam},
  title = {{Integrality, duality and finiteness in combinatoric topological strings}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2022)071},
}
Figure