Instantons in QCD: Theory and Application of the Instanton Liquid Model

Marcus HütterarXiv 2001 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Numerical and analytical studies of the instanton liquid model (ILM) have allowed the determination of many hadronic parameters over the last decade. This work extends these analytical methods, calculating meson correlation (polarization) functions within the ILM while incorporating dynamical quark loops. Correlators for the $\sigma, \rho, \omega, a_1,$ and $f_1$ mesons are analyzed, with masses and couplings extracted via spectral fits. A separate analysis determines the $\eta'$ mass, with results generally aligning with experimental values within a 10% margin. Furthermore, the model provides predictions for proton form factors related to the proton spin problem and calculates a gauge-invariant gluon mass for small momenta. Finally, the work derives a finite relation between the quark condensate and the QCD scale $\Lambda$ without relying on specific infrared cutoffs or instanton models, demonstrating the internal consistency and phenomenological success of the instanton liquid approach.

Introduction

Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is the fundamental theory of the strong interaction. While perturbation theory effectively describes QCD at high energies (short distances), the low-energy (long distance) regime remains a significant challenge due to its non-perturbative nature. In this regime, the vacuum is not a void but a complex medium filled with topological fluctuations.

One of the most promising frameworks for understanding this non-perturbative vacuum is the Instanton Liquid Model (ILM). Instantons are localized, non-trivial solutions to the classical field equations in Euclidean space. This paper, based on the research of Marcus Hutter, explores how treating the QCD vacuum as a "liquid" of these instantons can explain the emergence of hadronic properties, chiral symmetry breaking, and the mass spectrum of mesons.

The Instanton Liquid Model

Early attempts to model the QCD vacuum used an "instanton gas" approach. However, these models faced an "infrared catastrophe" where the inclusion of large instantons caused the vacuum density to diverge. The ILM resolves this by assuming a repulsive interaction between instantons, which stabilizes the medium at a characteristic density. In this model, instantons have a typical radius of $\rho \approx 0.3$ fm and a mean separation of $R \approx 1$ fm.

This "liquid" state provides a natural mechanism for Chiral Symmetry Breaking. As quarks propagate through the vacuum, they interact with the instanton background. The "zero-modes" of the Dirac operator in the field of an instanton allow quarks to flip helicity, effectively giving them a constituent mass and explaining why the observed masses of protons and mesons are much larger than the current masses of their constituent quarks.

Analytical Methodology

Hutter employs a suite of sophisticated theoretical tools to extract physical predictions from the ILM:

  • Semiclassical Approximation: The QCD path integral is evaluated around the local minima provided by instanton solutions.
  • Zero-Mode Approximation (ZMA): The low-energy physics is dominated by the zero-energy states of quarks in the instanton field. While the ZMA is a simplification, it captures the essential physics of the 't Hooft interaction.
  • Bethe-Salpeter Equations: These are used to sum infinite series of quark-instanton scatterings, allowing for the calculation of bound-state properties (mesons).
  • Spectral Fitting: Theoretical correlation functions—which describe particle propagation through the vacuum—are matched against phenomenological models to extract mass and coupling constants.
  • Large $N_c$ Expansion: By taking the limit where the number of colors ($N_c$) goes to infinity, the complex many-body interactions are simplified while retaining the core features of the theory.

Key Results and Discussion

The Meson Spectrum and the $\eta'$ Anomaly

The model successfully predicts the masses of the $\sigma, \rho, \omega, a_1,$ and $f_1$ mesons within 10% of experimental data. A particularly notable success is the calculation of the $\eta'$ mass. In standard symmetry models, the $\eta'$ should be a Goldstone boson similar in mass to the pion, yet it is significantly heavier. The ILM explains this via the 't Hooft interaction, which explicitly breaks the axial $U(1)_A$ symmetry. The predicted mass of $884 \pm 116$ MeV is in good agreement with the experimental value of 958 MeV.

The Proton Spin Problem

The "proton spin crisis" refers to the experimental finding that the constituent quarks carry only a small fraction of the proton's total spin. Hutter’s work provides a framework to relate this phenomenon to vacuum correlators, suggesting that the topological fluctuations of the gluonic field (instantons) carry a significant portion of the missing angular momentum.

Gauge Invariance and the Gluon Mass

A significant theoretical contribution of this work is the calculation of a gauge-invariant gluon mass ($\approx 480$ MeV) and ghost mass ($\approx 340$ MeV) at small momenta. Furthermore, the paper derives a finite relation between the quark condensate (a measure of chiral symmetry breaking) and the fundamental QCD scale $\Lambda$. This derivation is particularly robust as it does not rely on an arbitrary infrared cutoff or the specifics of a particular instanton model.

Conclusion and Limitations

The Instanton Liquid Model exhibits remarkable internal consistency and provides a unified explanation for a wide array of hadronic phenomena. However, limitations remain. While the ILM is excellent for describing chiral symmetry breaking, it does not inherently explain color confinement—the reason quarks are never observed in isolation. Additionally, the Zero-Mode Approximation, while powerful, may need to be supplemented with "non-zero modes" to accurately describe heavier strange quarks. Despite these challenges, the ILM remains a cornerstone for understanding the non-perturbative structure of the QCD vacuum.

Summary updated

Abstract

Numerical and anaytical studies of the instanton liquid model have allowed the determination of many hadronic parameters during the last 13 years. Most part of this thesis is devoted to the extension of the analytical methods. The meson correlation (polarization) functions are calculated in the instanton liquid model including dynamical quark loops. The correlators are plotted and masses and couplings of the $σ$, $ρ$, $ω$, $a1$ and $f1$ are obtained from a spectral fit. A separated analysis allows the determination of the $η'$ mass too. The results agree with the experimental values on a 10% level. Further I give some predictions for the proton form factors, which are related to the proton spin (problem). A gauge invariant gluon mass for small momenta is also calculated. At the end of the work some predictions are given, which do not rely on the instanton liquid model. A gauge invariant quark propagator is calculated in the one instanton background and is compared to the regular and singular propagator. An introduction to the skill of choosing a suitable gauge, especially a criterium for choosing regular or singular gauge, is given. An application is the derivation of a finite relation betweewn the quark condensate and the QCD scale $Λ$, where neither an infrared cutoff nor a specific instanton model has been used. In general the instanton liquid model exhibits an astonishing internal consistency and a good agreement with the experimental data.
BibTeX
@misc{hutter2001instantons,
  author = {Marcus Hütter},
  title = {{Instantons in QCD: Theory and Application of the Instanton Liquid Model}},
  year = {2001},
  eprint = {hep-ph/0107098},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0107098},
}

Loading related content...

Figure