Instanton-soliton loops in 5D super-Yang-Mills

Constantinos Papageorgakis, Andrew B. RoystonarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates the role of "soliton loops" in 5D super-Yang-Mills (SYM) theory, which are crucial for understanding its ultraviolet (UV) behavior and its connection to the 6D (2,0) conformal field theory. The authors argue that for these specific instanton-solitons, their contribution to perturbative processes is not exponentially suppressed, potentially offering a mechanism to cancel UV divergences and render the theory finite.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantum field theories (QFTs) often become ill-defined at high energies (UV divergences). For theories like 5D super-Yang-Mills, which are power-counting nonrenormalizable, this problem is particularly acute. While supersymmetry can tame divergences at low orders, a logarithmic divergence was found at 6 loops. A common approach to address such issues is to consider contributions from "soliton loops" – virtual particle-antiparticle pairs of solitons. Conventionally, these contributions are thought to be exponentially suppressed, making them negligible. However, this paper questions this assumption for instanton-solitons in 5D SYM, suggesting they might play a more significant role in canceling these problematic UV divergences and thus making the theory well-defined. This is crucial for understanding the relationship between 5D SYM and the enigmatic 6D (2,0) theory, which is believed to describe the low-energy behavior of M5-branes.

Methods

The authors extend previous work on scalar theories to analyze the "form factor" associated with soliton-antisoliton pair production. This form factor dictates how strongly solitons interact with perturbative particles. They employ a semiclassical approach, focusing on the dynamics of "moduli" – parameters that describe the soliton's configuration. A key technique involves analyzing the Hamiltonian of the system and performing a canonical transformation to separate collective (soliton) coordinates from internal fluctuations. They then use techniques adapted from 2D kink theory to evaluate the form factor, paying particular attention to velocity corrections and the behavior of the soliton size.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Soliton size matters: The exponential suppression of soliton contributions is not a universal feature but depends on the ratio of the soliton's size to its Compton wavelength.
  • Instanton-solitons are different: In 5D SYM, instanton-solitons have a non-compact size modulus, meaning their size can vary continuously. This breaks the conventional argument for exponential suppression.
  • Non-suppressed contributions: The paper argues that for 5D instanton-solitons, the analogous form factor does not lead to faster-than-any-power suppression in the perturbative coupling.
  • Potential for UV finiteness: This lack of suppression opens the door for soliton-antisoliton loop contributions to cancel the UV divergences observed in 5D SYM, making the theory finite.
  • Connection to 6D (2,0) theory: Understanding the UV behavior of 5D SYM is essential for its identification with the 6D (2,0) theory, a fundamental object in M-theory.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that for a class of scalar theories, the soliton form factor exhibits an exponential suppression that depends on the ratio of soliton size to Compton wavelength. However, when applied to instanton-solitons in 5D SYM, this exponential suppression is argued to be absent. This implies that virtual instanton-soliton loops could contribute to perturbative processes in a way that is not exponentially suppressed, potentially offering a mechanism to cancel the UV divergences found in 5D SYM.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their arguments do not definitively prove that instanton-soliton contributions are not suppressed, but rather that they allow for this possibility. They suggest that a more detailed investigation is needed to explore the implications of these non-suppressed contributions for canceling the UV divergences. This would likely require an alternative approach to the one used here, potentially involving a deeper understanding of the quantum theory of these solitons and their interactions. The paper also notes that turning on a scalar VEV can stabilize the soliton size, but this does not salvage the argument for exponential suppression when integrating over all possible sizes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soliton contributions to perturbative processes in QFT are controlled by a form factor, which depends on the soliton size. We provide a demonstration of this fact in a class of scalar theories with generic moduli spaces. We then argue that for instanton-solitons in 5D super-Yang-Mills theory the analogous form factor does not lead to faster-than-any-power suppression in the perturbative coupling. We also discuss the implications of such contributions for the UV behavior of maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills in 5D and its relation to the (2,0) CFT in 6D. This is a contribution to the proceedings of the "String Math 2013'" conference and is a condensed version of results appearing in 1404.0016 and 1403.5017.
BibTeX
@misc{papageorgakis2014instanton,
  author = {Constantinos Papageorgakis and Andrew B. Royston},
  title = {{Instanton-soliton loops in 5D super-Yang-Mills}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1409.4093},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.4093},
}

Loading related content...

Figure